Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04.b. Strategic Plan Trackers for the Third Quarter of FY 2022-23Page 1 of 34 Item 4.b. F--1-448�411C-S0 May 2, 2023 TO: ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE FROM: CHRISTINA GEE, MANAGEMENT ANALYST REVIEWED BY: PHILIP LEIBER, DEPUTYGENERAL MANAGER ROGER S. BAILEY, GENERAL MANAGER SUBJECT: RECEIVE STRATEGIC PLAN TRACKERS FOR THE THIRD QUARTER OF FY 2022-23 Attached are the Strategic Plan Trackers for the third quarter of Fiscal Year (FY) 2022-23, the first year of Central San's FYs 2022-24 Strategic Plan. These reports provide an update on the progress on each goal and strategy through the fulfillment of the key success measures (KSMs) and the key metrics. Per the Committee's request, last fiscal year's quarterly performance has been included for metrics that are On Hold / Delayed / At Risk or Off Track. The color legend is defined as follows for each tracker: BLUE — Completed • Key Metrics Tracker: Target was met for the FY • KSMs Tracker: KSM was fulfilled GREEN — On Track / Revised Approach • Key Metrics Tracker: Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent • KSMs Tracker: KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent YELLOW— On Hold / Delayed /At Risk • Key Metrics Tracker: Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable • KSMs Tracker: KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable RED — Off Track Key Metrics Tracker: Target is in danger of not being met for the FY KSMs Tracker: KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by June 30, 2024. Staff will be available at the meeting to answer questions. May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 17 of 84 Page 2 of 34 ATTACHMENTS: 1. Key Success Measures Tracker 2. Key Metrics Tracker May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 18 of 84 Page 3 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 1 - CUSTOMER AND COMMUNITY Provide Exceptional Service Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Ongoing. Permit Counter, Collection System Operations (CSO), Assess customer satisfaction and develop inventive ways to meet those expe Gemmell /Seitz / Barnett and Communications (re: construction projects) send out regular customer surveys. Provide core service of collecting and treating wastewater, along with Respond in a timely manner to requests for service. Seitz value-added programs. Ongoing. Permit Counter, Household Hazardous Waste Continue to administer customer -facing programs. Schectel / Collection Facility (HHWCF), and Residential Recycled Water Fill Deliver High- Gemmell Station are open to the public. Quality Customer cn Q3: Opened Recreational Vehicle Disposal Station on March 6 . Service Q1/Q2/Q3: Meetings will be scheduled as needed prior to new Hold informational community meetings for all major sewer renovation projects, Barnett / projects being advertised for bid. including outreach to officials of the impacted cities/county. Carpenter Minimize impacts to residents and Q1/Q2/Q3: Meetings continue to be held as needed. businesses during capital projects, Meet individually with property owners and/or tenants on projects involving Barnett / construction work, and maintenance. private easements. Carpenter Barnett / Q1/Q2/Q3: Issues are addressed as they arise.Carpenter Troubleshoot and resolve construction issues as rapidly as possible. Q1: Two hundred and seventy-seven (277) people were served through virtual and community events. Conduct public tours and presentations highlighting infrastructure investments. Barnett / Q2: One hundred and five (105) people were served through Lavender virtual and community events. 03: One hundred and fifty (150) people were served through virtual and community events. Q1: Next session tentatively planned to be held in person in Host Central San Academy annually. Gee spring 2023. Q2: Planning next session to begin in Q3. Promote Initiatives Perform extensive customer and community outreach. Q3: Hosted the 2023 Academy. Q1: Pipeline customer newsletter in production. to Advance Affordable and Barnett / Zumbo / Q2: Pipeline customer newsletter mailed to approximately Equitable Access q Develop engaging videos, publications, and brochures. Vallee 155,000 customer addresses. Premiered our latest student to Services education film, "Disappearing Act." Q3: Produced and mailed spring Pipeline newsletter. Q1/Q2: Continue to monitor and grow YouTube, Facebook, Expand social media outreach. Barnett / Vallee Twitter, Instagram, and Linkedln followers and impressions. 03: Launched Central San page on Nextdoor. Q1: Underway. Maintain responsible rates and Conduct a Cost -of -Service Study. Gemmell Q2: Completed and results presented at 1/12 Financial offer services at affordable levels. Workshop. 03: Rate Workshop planned for April 20, 2023. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 19 of 84 Page 1 Page 4 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 1 - CUSTOMER AND COMMUNITY Provide Exceptional Service Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) 01: Underway. Perform annual reviews of rate structure and fees. Gemmell 02: Completed and results presented at 1/12 Financial Workshop. Q3 Capacity Fee Study is underway. Q1: Financing plan to be presented in context of rate proposal for FY 2023-24 onward. 02: LIHWAP program underway. Notification that it will be Administer financing programs. Gemmell / Leiber expanded to provide funding for low-income customers for CURRENT bills in addition to arrearages. Q3: Ongoing. Q1/Q2/Q3: Ongoing outreach during events, meetings, and Connect and engage elected officials, staff, and stakeholders on initiatives. Barnett outreach on programs, services, and legislative perspectives. Form and sustain relationships with federal, state, and local elected officials Ongoing. and stakeholders. Support Board Member engagement with elected officials. Barnett / Young Ongoing. Staff participates in multiple industry organizations and forums to share information, attend trainings, and represent Build Neighborhood and Participate in industry organizations and forums. All Managers Central San. 01: General Manager will be the in -coming President for Industry WateReuse and will be President of CA WateReuse in two Relationships years. Q1: Several Mutual Aid requests received from CalWARN but Support member organizations and pp 9 none that Central San could meet. sister agencies. Provide assistance and mutual aid to other agencies. Deutsch Q2: One request. We did not have any spares of the requested item in stock. 03: One request. We did not have any spares of the requested item in stock. Ongoing. Staff presents at various conferences and applies for Share industry -leading work. All Managers and receives awards for exceptional achievements. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 20 of 84 Page 2 Page 5 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 2 — ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP Meet regulatory requirements, promote sustainability, and identify and reduce contributions to climate change and mitigate its impacts Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q2: Completion of calendar year 2022 with no violations. Eligible Continue to attain National Association of Clean Water Agencies (NACWA) Weer for Platinum 25. Platinum Peak Performance Awards. Continue to keep sanitary sewer overflows at a reduced level. Seitz Q1: Scope for the 1A project has been finalized with the consultant team. Key decisions include including modified Comply with all applicable regulations. seismic improvements to the building in the 1A scope and Scope improvements to the Solids Handling Facilities. Lopez / Gemmell bidding the furnace improvements separate from the 1A bid. / Hodges Q2: Design progressed through the 95% submittal to address dewatering, furnace and air pollution control improvements. Project to be bid in Q3. Q3: QA/QC of design drawings to push bid into Q4. Upgrade aeration tank diffusers to continue proper biological treatment and Q1: 50% design documents submitted.Q2: Aeration Diffuser prepare to meet future discharge limitations. Lopez / Mizutani RFQ/RoFP issued. Q3: 50 /o Design Submittal completed. Achieve Compliance Participate in Bay Area Clean Water Agencies, California Association of Schectel / Ongoing. in All Regulations Sanitation Agencies, NACWA, and other like organizations. Barnett Foster relationships Ongoing. with regulatory agencies. Communicate with and participate in meetings and workshops with local, state, Schectel / and federal regulatory bodies. Barnett Q1: Provided tracking, review, and presentations for Board to take positions on key priority legislation. Q2: Worked on new legislative concept for upcoming session Track, review, and comment on proposed legislation and regulations. Barnett with associations, peer agencies, and NGOs. Q3: Submitted bill on financial approval changes in Sanitary District Act. Accepted and AB 759 authored by Assemblymember Grayson. Secured sponsorship by CASA and Participate in legislative and support by CSDA. regulatory processes. Q1-Q4: Wipes, FOG, PFAS, microplastics are all key advocacy Support key advocacy initiatives through customer communications and Barnett initiatives taken up during the Q1-Q4 timeframe. outreach. Incorporate potential impacts of regulatory changes into long-range Schectel / infrastructure and financing plans. Gemmell / Lopez Q1: Five thousand, seven hundred and sixty nine (5,769) Educate on Pollution students were served through education programs. Prevention and Provide industry -leading public and Present student education programs that meet the Next Generation Science Barnett / Q2: Three thousand, eight hundred and sixty three (3,863) students were served through education programs. Environmental student education programming. standards. Lavender Q3: Four thousand, three hundred and ninety-three (4,393) Protection students were served through education programs. Delta Discovery Data will be added when it becomes available" Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 21 of 84 Page 3 Page 6 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 2 — ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP Meet regulatory requirements, promote sustainability, and identify and reduce contributions to climate change and mitigate its impacts Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Promoted P2 Week and tips via social media, PSAs aired on CCTV, and Rossmoor TV. Barnett / Q2: P2 information shared via social media and fall Pipeline Conduct creative public education outreach that encourages positive customer Lavender/ newsletter. Recycling cooking oil television commercial behavioral changes. Zumbo / Vallee campaign aired 546 spots across 47 networks. Q3: FOG, wipes, and other pollution prevention messages shared via social media and Pipeline newsletter. Q3: Discussions have continued between Central San staff andstaff Continue exploring partnerships with Contra Costa Water District (CCWD), at Valley Water and SFPUC. Santa Clara Valley Water District (Valley Water) and San Francisco Public LaBella Utilities Commission (SFPUC) to advance the Refinery Recycled Water Exchange Project. Q1: Proposed Central San-EBMUD Recycled Water Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) brought to REEP Committee for review in July 2022. Q2: Central San-EBMUD Recycled Water Opportunities MOU Collaborate with East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) on a potable reuse fully executed in October 2022 and Work Plan completed in study. LaBella December 2022. Q3: EBMUD issued an RFP and selected a consultant to assist with their work on the MOU. Results are expected by the end of calendar year 2023 and the MOU term currently ends on June 30, 2024. Explore and advance cooperative opportunities. Q2: Met withConcord First Group to discuss updated assumptions on December 14tn ass Be Partner in Continue to work with CCWD and the City of Concord in plans to supply Gemmell / Concord released Concord First Group as Master a Regional Development recycled water to the Concord Community Reuse Project. LaBella Developer. New RFP Selection Process is being discussed so of Local Water Supply project is delayed. Q1: DSRSD had adequate wastewater supply, so the diversion Continue to divert raw wastewater to produce recycled water to meet Dublin project was not operated this dry season. San Ramon Services District — East Bay Municipal Utility District Recycled Gemmell / Water Authority (DERWA)'s peak summer irrigation demand, per the LaBella Agreement. Q1: Discussions with Diablo Country Club continue. Facilitate recycled water solutions (e.g., satellite water recycling facilities), LaBella consistent with the Guiding Principles. Ongoing. Continue to operate and maintain a reliable recycled water distribution system Gemmell / Foss for Zone 1 customers. Continue to provide recycled water to residents and businesses; evaluate and Ongoing. process new customer requests. Continue the Residential Recycled Water Fill Station and Commercial Recycled Gemmell /Foss Water Truck Fill Programs. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 22 of 84 Page 4 Page 7 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 2 — ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP Meet regulatory requirements, promote sustainability, and identify and reduce contributions to climate change and mitigate its impacts Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Project is scheduled to be complete by April 2023 (original completion date was Dec 2022). Complete Phase 1A of the Filter Plant and Clearwell Renovations Project. Lopez / Mizutani Q2: Project is scheduled to be complete by July 2023. Previously April 2023. Q3: Project is scheduled to be complete by July 2023. Q1: Membrane pilot operation completed in June 2022 and pilot decommissioned in July 2022. Carollo pilot report and alternatives evaluation report anticipated in Q2. Staff's business case evaluation of filtration options anticipated in Q3. Complete the Tertiary Membrane Filter Pilot. Gemmell / Frost Q2: Received draft Membrane Pilot report. Final Pilot report and Draft alternatives evaluation report anticipated in Q3. Q3: 2 Workshops scheduled for Q4 to review final report and alternatives evaluation. Q1: Priority has shifted to Fleet Electrification due to regulatory requirements. Q2: Engaged GHD to develop a scope of work for this effort, Develop a policy on net zero carbon footprint. LaBella which will begin in February 2023. Q3: Work on Central San's baseline for scope 1, scope 2, and scope 3 GHG emissions continued with strong support from Central San's Regulatory Compliance group. Q1: Project on track to complete construction this fiscal year. Q2: Construction continues to be delayed, pending approval from Kinder Morgan and PG&E to cross over their existing easements Implement the 1.75-me awatt solar energy project on the La issproperty. p g gyp g LaBella to construct the project. Q3: Construction continues to be delayed, awaiting approval by Kinder Morgan for the crossing of their three easements and two pipelines on Central San's Lagiss property with the interconnection facilities. Identify and Advance Sustainability Reduce reliance on non-renewable Q1: Fleet Electrification RFP issued in September 2022. Initiatives, Including energy and responsibly manage Q2: Completed consultant selection for Fleet Electrification Reducing Energy greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Evaluatelhicharging stationsit electric vehicle cargng on site. LaBella aea / Cheng Strategic Plan. Usage and Emissions Q3: Development of Fleet Electrification Strategic Plan is in progress. Q1: Solids Handling Project scope has been coordinated with Weer / Lopez / Plant staff to facilitate maximum use of landfill gas (LFG) in Maximize landfill gas usage in daily operations and by capital improvements. Hodges furnace operations. Q2: Use of LFG is included with furnace improvements. Q3: Use of LFG is included with furnace improvements. Q1: Two Workshops were conducted.Q3: Three Workshops Complete the long-term Biosolids Handling and Disposal Evaluation feasibility were conducted. study and investigate how anaerobic digestion may potentially reduce Gemmell anthropogenic carbon from treatment plant energy supply by producing biogas. Q1: Tracked monthly GHG emissions. Continue to track and report GHG emissions. Cheng / Schectel Q2: Tracked monthly and annual GHG emissions. Q3: Tracked monthly GHG emissions. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 23 of 84 Page 5 Page 8 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 2 — ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP Meet regulatory requirements, promote sustainability, and identify and reduce contributions to climate change and mitigate its impacts Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1/Q2/Q3: Compiled monthly energy report dashboard. On - Track and review energy usage; evaluate ways to optimize efficiency in Shima / Meyer / going RAPIDS program coordination with consultant for energy - accordance with Board policies. Lee saving opportunities evaluations. On -going in-house LED replacement. Q1: Retrofitted 133 light fixtures to LED. Explore opportunities for cost-effective Replace incandescent lighting and air conditioning equipment with energy- Meyer / Lee Q2: Retrofitted 98 light fixtures to LED. energy conservation and efficiency. efficient devices. Q3: There was a total of 73 lighting and 0 air conditioning replacements. Q1: On -going, bid documents to procure UV equipment were Assess and replace the existing disinfection system with the latest ultraviolet Gemmell / issued on September 2022. Q2: SRF application submitted in December; Procurement award high -efficiency lamps. Cauble scheduled in Q3. Q3: Procurement awarded. Q1: Monthly Green Team Steering Committee meetings initiated. Evaluating green business recertification strategy for Central San. Q2: Progress made on moving the Vehicle Maintenance Shop closer to green business recertification. The first Central San Restart the Green Team to solicit organization -wide ideas. LaBella Swap Meet, sponsored by the Green Team, was held in December 2022. Q3: The Green Team Steering Committee continued to make progress on the green business recertifications, including coordination with the Warehouse on transitioning to greener cleaning products and paper products with post -consumer recyclable content. Expand internal sustainability practices. Q1: Several Green Team articles have been published in the LC this quarter. Q2: New composting bins were purchased and placed around Promote environmentally conscious behavior in day-to-day operations. LaBella / the District. Articles to support proper disposal of solid waste All Managers have been published in the LC and will continue. Q3: Several articles were included in the LC to promote environmentally -conscious behavior in Central San's operations and beyond. Q1: This is one of the goals of the Institute for Sustainable Advance circular economies with suppliers and contractors towards a smaller King / Mizuno / Infrastructure's Envision Framework, which Central San will be ecological footprint. Lopez / Waples piloting. Kickoff Meetings with key staff will be held in Q2. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 24 of 84 Page 6 Page 9 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 3 — WORKFORCE DIVERSITY AND DEVELOPMENT Recruit, educate, empower, and retain a workforce from diverse backgrounds Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4/ Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Post job opportunities in a variety of places. O'Malley Ongoing. Summer student and internship positions are offered in Offer internships in cross -disciplinary positions. O'Malley / multiple workgroups, including Engineering, Plant Maintenance, All Managers the Lab, Information Technology, and Communications. Recruit from a Diverse Broadly solicit applications to hire a Q1/Q2: Next program planned for Spring 2023. Pool of Qualified diverse staff who embody Central Applicants San's values. Host the Externship Program for college students and recent graduates. Gee / O'Malley Q3: Hosted the 2023 Externship Program. Collaborate with schools and/or apprenticeship programs as requested to form a O'Malley / Ongoing. Staff regularly collaborates with schools (e.g., Los talent pipeline. All Managers Medanos College) and BAYWORK. Ongoing. Central San is a signatory agency with BAYWORK and Continue participation in intra-agency workforce development efforts. O'Malley a supporting agency of Bay Area Consortium for Water & Wastewater Education (BACWWE). Ongoing. Clarifier Speaker Series is held monthly and the Lateral Foster a sense of community through internal events, team -building exercises, the All Managers Connection employee newsletter is released monthly. Q1: Held Employee Appreciation Picnic on September 21. employee newsletter, and increased interdepartmental cooperation. Q2: Holiday events held including annual meal at Back Forty restaurant. Ongoing. Staff is appraised on a yearly basis. Promote employee engagement and Establish and communicate clear expectations and standards through All Managers inspire dedication. performance planning and appraisals. Convey important initiatives to employees to increase their understanding of Ongoing. Clarifier Speaker Series is held monthly and the Lateral Central San's operations and their role in its success. All Managers Connection employee newsletter is released monthly. Engage Employees and Q2: Meetings have been completed. Conduct Labor Host General Manager lunches with the division workgroups. Bailey / Crayton Relations in a Transparent, Effective, and Collaborative Recognize staff accomplishments via newsletters, the intranet, Board All Managers Ongoing. Environment announcements, and other avenues. Expand the employee recognition program. O'Malley Celebrate employees' achievements. Continue to hold the Innovations Fair, which recognizes and thanks employees for Gee Q1: Innovations Fair was held on September 21. innovative projects. Q3: Another Innovations Fair will be planned. Engage the bargaining units in informal discussions to implement collaborative O'Malley Ongoing. Sustain and grow collaborative solutions to workplace issues. relationships with the bargaining units. Track and implement action items from quarterly Labor Management Committee O'Malley Ongoing. meetings. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 25 of 84 Page 7 Page 10 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 3 — WORKFORCE DIVERSITY AND DEVELOPMENT Recruit, educate, empower, and retain a workforce from diverse backgrounds Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1/Q2: Roger continues to meet with bargaining representatives. As bargaining matters come up and negotiations gets closer, Board members will be brought into these meetings. For now, Roger briefs Board Members during meetings with them one on Continue General Manager and Board Member meetings with the bargaining Bailey / Crayton / one. representatives. Young Q3: Roger has recently met with both Bargaining Units. As matters come up that involve Board members, they will be brought in. Roger continues to brief Board members during his one on one meetings with them. Q1: Supervisory Academy and Mentorship Program in progress. Two employees are enrolled in the Career Development Continue the Leadership and Supervisory Academies, Mentorship Program, and Gee / O'Malley Program. Q2: Supervisory Academy concluded. Launching Management Career Development Program. Leadership Academy in March 2023. Q3: Launched Management Academy and Leadership Speaker Series. Ongoing. Develop employees to meet their full Encourage staff to obtain professional or technical certifications and registrations. All Managers potential and fill future leadership Q1/Q2/Q3: Rollout of enhanced performance appraisal forms is in roles. Perform appraisals with a coaching and career development approach. All Managers progress, pending Oracle module launch. Retain Skilled Workers Continue to host and participate in multiagency workforce development programs O'Malley Ongoing. by Investing in Resources and Opportunities for All for staff from Central San and sister agencies. Employees to Grow and Ongoing. Thrive Continue to expand internal training opportunities. O'Malley Ongoing. Offer comprehensive benefits such as online therapy services and the Employee O'Malley Assistance Program. Support the mental and physical Ongoing. Wellness Program events continue year-round. wellbeing of all employees. Encourage participation in the Wellness Program. O'Malley / Q1: Team Battle steps challenge was held. Weight Management Howard Program kicked off. Q3: Wellness Expo was held and Cake Walk is being planned. Ongoing. Financial webinars are held monthly. Health seminars Hold financial and health seminars. O'Malley are held periodically. Build a diverse workplace that Q1: DEI initiative was launched District wide in July. DEI Task Foster a Culture of celebrates differences and is O'Malley /Bailey Force has been selected and has begun meeting. Diversity, Equity, and inclusive of individual perspectives, Conduct an assessment to identify strengths and weaknesses. / Gee Q2: DEI Task Force continues to meet and is beginning to look Inclusion (DEI) ideas, and values. into assessment. Q3: DEI Task Force released the DEI survey. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 26 of 84 Page 8 Page 11 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 3 — WORKFORCE DIVERSITY AND DEVELOPMENT Recruit, educate, empower, and retain a workforce from diverse backgrounds Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Develop programs/initiatives with metrics based on the outcomes of the Q1/Q2/Q3: Pending results of the assessment. assessment. All Managers Encourage and respectfully acknowledge the voicing of different views and All Managers Ongoing. Leadership Team has held several DEI learning workshops and are committed to employing DEI principles in perspectives. everyday activities. Ongoing. Q1: Standing item has been added to Managers' Forum agendas Promote inclusivity and a sense of belonging through leadership. All Managers to check in on how well inclusion was practiced during the meeting. Q2/Q3: 3 Managers are participating on DEI task force to propagate DEI learning through the organization. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 27 of 84 Page 9 Page 12 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 4 — GOVERNANCE AND FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY Uphold integrity, transparency, and wise financial management in an effective governing model Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Support Central San's values and conduct all business in an ethical manner. All Managers Ongoing. Update website with the latest Board agendas, public notices, financial documents, Young Ongoing. Govern and operate with honor and and other content. Respond promptly to Public Records Act requests. Young transparency. Renew California Special District Leadership Foundation Transparency Certificate Young of Excellence. Issue the Annual Financial Report no later than six months after the end of the Q1: FY 21-22 ACFR being finalized and audit underway. On fiscal year. Mizuno track to issue ACFR by November/December 2022. Q2: FY 21-22 ACFR audit opinion issued in December 2022. Q1: Applied for the Distinguished Budget Award for FY 22-23 Promote and Uphold Ethical Behavior, Earn the Government Finance Officers Association Certificate of Achievement budget. Finalizing FY 21-22 ACFR and plan to submit for COA in Openness, and (COA) for Excellence in Financial Reporting and the Distinguished Budget Mizuno Q2: Received COA for FY 20-21 ACFR. Submitted application for Accessibility Presentation Award. FY 21-22 ACFR COA award. Produce accurate, timely, and meaningful financial reports. Q1: Initial ERP contract has been closed out. Contract management module work underway. Permitting & Community Development on track for implementation in 2023. Q2: Continued progress on new module for CIP development. Continue to evolve the enterprise resource planning (ERP) software and Leiber / Mallory / Information Technology team members continue to develop associated systems to meet reporting needs. All Managers Oracle report creation skills through training and taking on new assignments. Q3: Still working on Contracts and Permitting modules. Quote obtained for on board i ng/offboard i ng for employee -assigned asset tracking. Q1-Q2: Promoted voter registration and get out the vote Promote voter registration efforts. Barnett messages via social media. Q3: No activities required in Q3 based on election timing. Support the elections process. Enable voting through a secure, public ballot drop box on campus. Young Q1: Vote box is securely and permanently mounted. Conduct first by -district election. Young No election needed. Adhere to the Brown Act to provide public access to meetings. Young Encourage and Facilitate Public Livestream Board meetings online. Young Q1: Website is in process of being re -branded from 75th theme to Participation Maintain the virtual Customer Experience website. Barnett general Central San theme. Q2: Website has been rebranded and updated. Encourage civic engagement. Q3: Website continues to be promoted. Q1-Q2: Planning efforts for in -person events now that most events are returning to normal. Planned and co -hosted Recycled Host public events. Barnett Water Townhall in Lafayette. Q3: Returning to in -person construction outreach. Meetings being planning as part of capital improvements. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 28 of 84 Page 10 Page 13 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 4 — GOVERNANCE AND FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY Uphold integrity, transparency, and wise financial management in an effective governing model Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Expecting reimbursement for initial draw of $14.68M in Q2. Q2: Initial low -interest SRF reimbursement received. Held discussions with Regional San on forming a JPA allowing Central Mitigate rate increases by leveraging financing opportunities. Leiber / Gemmell San to issue revenue bonds (lower interest than COPs) not / Mizuno needing the additional cost and time constraints associated with an election to approve said bonds. Q3: Awaiting Draft State Intended Use Plan to see if UV Disinfection project makes the fundable list. Q1: Financial Plan to be presented in upcoming workshop. Conduct long-range planning. Develop scenarios to utilize debt prudently in financing the 10-Year Capital Q2: Draft Financial Plan compiled to be presented to Board on Improvement Plan (CIP). Leiber / Mizuno 1/12/23. Anticipates use of low -interest financing in accordance with Debt Management Policy. Q3: Continuing. Q1: Continuing to monitor SRF program funding availabilities Q2: Development of a Grants Administrative procedure outlining Actively pursue state and federal funding via loans and grants. Leiber / Gemmell formalized protocols for grant management. Expected to be / Mizuno rolled out in Q3. Q3: Awaiting Draft State Intended Use Plan to see if UV Disinfection project makes the fundable list. Q1: Proposal for disposition of variances inclusive of potential Maintain Financial Fund Rate Stabilization Account and Pension and Other Post -Employment Leiber Mizuno / contributions to trusts pending. Q2: Board approved contribution of an additional $1 M into OPEBtrust Stability and Benefits Trust with available funds from favorable year-end variances. utilizing prior year budgetary variance. Sustainability Q3/Q4: Completed for this fiscal year. Q1: Pension fully funded at 12/31/2021. Proposal for disposition Ensure resiliency against recession or other economic events. of variances inclusive of potential contributions to OPEB trust pending. Strive towards full funding of employee -related obligations in accordance with Leiber / Mizuno Q2: Completed RFP issuance and evaluation process for new pension/OPEB actuarial consultant. To work with consultant to Board policies. obtain actuarial reports for FY 23-24 budgeting purposes in Q3. Q3: OPEB report shows strong OPEB funding at 93.3 and 98.6% as of 7/1/22 and 7/1/23 (projected) for actuarial purposes. Q1: Three plans are coordinated and integrated. Develop budgets in alignment with the Strategic Plan, Enterprise Risk Q2: Commenced internal planning meetings with EPM consultnat Management, and 10-Year Financial Plan. Leiber / Mizuno on FY 23-24 budget project plan. Q3: Budget process on track to produce budget consistent with financial plan presented in January 2023. Q1-Q3: Developed and disseminated nine monthly budget -to - Manage costs. Disseminate relevant and reliable interim financial information to management for actual expenditure overviews and three quarterly financial review monitoring and controlling of their respective cost centers. Mizuno to the Board, as well as monthly detail -level budget reports internally. Annual ACFR also issued to Board in December. Pursue efficiencies and new technology for cost control. All Managers Ongoing. Optimizations continuing. O&M Budget savings on track. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 29 of 84 Page 11 Page 14 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 4 — GOVERNANCE AND FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY Uphold integrity, transparency, and wise financial management in an effective governing model Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Promote open competition and equal opportunity for qualified suppliers and service providers by soliciting and awarding high-level service and commodity -based King / Mizuno contracts. Utilize annual requirements contracts to improve efficiency and savings through King / Mizuno negotiated pricing. Q1: FY 2020-21 Benchmarking Study is drafted and pending receipt of California agency survey data. Complete annual Benchmarking Study to identify potential gaps. Gee Q2: FY 2020-21 Benchmarking Study is scheduled to be presented to Admin Committee and full Board in Q3. Q3: FY 2020-21 study was presented to the Board. Internal data collection for the AWWA survey was performed. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 30 of 84 Page 12 Page 15 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL FIVE — SAFETY AND SECURITY Provide a safe, secure, and healthful workplace that foresees and addresses threats Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Monitor accident/incident causes to identify and mitigate hazards. Ledbetter Maintain low injury and illness Provide regular analyses to the District Safety Committee, Safety Teams, and Ledbetter rates in a safe workplace. Management Team on accident/incident causation and corrective measures. Reduce and Eliminate Risks of Injury or Illness Increase visibility of Safety staff in the field. Ledbetter Enhance the safety culture through improved training and Conduct training based upon accident/incident causal factors, new processes, Ledbetter communications. equipment, or procedures. Notify supervisors and managers promptly of upcoming safety -related regulations. Ledbetter Q1: Reported to Finance Committee, scheduled for Board on 11 /3/22. Maintain and report on the Enterprise Risk Management Program and risk Q2: Will prepare annual report for presentation in Q3. inventory. Deutsch Q3: ERM Team met, preparing for Committee and Board presentations. Q1: Shifting to calendar year audit program with next update Evaluate and apply risk effective for 2023, and to be discussed with Board in February management practices. 2023. Develop annual internal audit plans based on risk assessments. Johnson Q2: Preparing for February board discussion. Q3: Presented annual audit plan to the Board via annual audit workshop. Began fieldwork for first project identified in the 2023 Audit Plan. Protect Personnel and Ongoing. Assets from Threats Test and improve internal controls to mitigate risks of loss. All Managers and Emergencies Address findings from regular internal and external audits. All Managers Ongoing. Q1: Scheduled for Q3. Train staff and conduct an exercise of the Continuity of Operations Plan. Deutsch Q2: No change. Q3: Inclement weather prevented event — hoping to do in Q4. Q1/Q2: Major update in September 2022. Enhance capability to mitigate, Maintain the Emergency Operations Plan. Deutsch Q3: No change. prepare for, respond to, and Expand participation in California Water/Wastewater Agency Response Network Ongoing. recover from emergencies. (CaIWARN) to represent the needs of wastewater agencies in emergency planning Deutsch and responses. Cross -train staff in mission -critical functions. All Managers Ongoing. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 31 of 84 Page 13 Page 16 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL FIVE — SAFETY AND SECURITY Provide a safe, secure, and healthful workplace that foresees and addresses threats Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Hired consultant to enhance security program and develop Budget and complete the projects identified in the Security Action Plan. Deutsch project scopes. Q2: Conducted kickoff, initiated work on Task 1. Q3: Site Visit, drafted security survey, scheduling interviews. Q1: Focus has been on increased transient population and theft Provide regular security awareness training to staff. Deutsch controls. Q2: Continued communication regarding above topic. Evaluate and implement p Q3: Additional measures included in above item. improvements to meet new or evolving threats. Q1: New Guard Station delivered; outfitting to begin in Q2. Renovate security guard posts and update monitoring equipment. Deutsch Q2: Ongoing, will transition to new main gate in early Q3. Q3: Delivery and Contractor Entrance was opened, staffed with guards. Q1: Hired consultant to enhance security program and develop Expand access control systems and harden certain facilities. Deutsch project scopes. Q2: Ongoing, additional assets installed. Q3: Ongoing. Q1: In process Q2: In process. Cyber Security status update will be provided to Address cybersecurity concerns as part of the Information Technology (IT) Mallory the Board in March 2023. Strategic Plan. Q3: Gave Board status update in March 2023. Cybersecurity plan to be finalized with the Process and Technology Optimization (PTO) Strategic Plan in late Q4. Q1: On track; vendor completed the network penetration testing Stay updated on the latest trends and emerging threats in Conduct third -party cybersecurity assessments focusing on technology, people, Mallory in October 2022. Q2: Report to Admin Committee and Board will take place in cybersecurity. and physical assets. March 2023. Q3: See above key success measure. Q1/Q2: Done on a monthly basis IT contributes to the Lateral Understand and Connection (LC) with Cyber Security and Technology tips to Reduce Impacts of Share news and tips with staff. Mallory increase efficiency. Cybersecurity Attacks Q3: Provided IT Tips article on where to find ERP Oracle training videos in the Lateral Connection. Q1/Q2: No notable attacks during the quarter, and no impacts. Keep safeguards in place to block and filter attacks. Mallory Q3: No notable attacks/impacts. We will further optimize our intrusion, protection and prevention systems in alignment with our cyber security roadmap. Q1: At 60% training level presently; continued focus area. Prevent, detect, and remediate effects of attacks. Q2: Posted an opening for a Cyber Security Analyst to assist in Measure and reduce employee susceptibility to phishing. Mallory creating & implementing a full cyber security program. Q3: No significant improvement this quarter. We will ramp up training and phishing exercises in Q4. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 32 of 84 Page 14 Page 17 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL FIVE — SAFETY AND SECURITY Provide a safe, secure, and healthful workplace that foresees and addresses threats Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q4 / Q2 Q3 Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Already have redundant paths for internet connections. Continuing to evaluate other needs for redundancy for internal Upgrade network and equipment to create redundant paths. Mallory systems as part of IT Strategic Plan. Q2: Redundant internet paths currently exist and periodic testing will continue. Q3: Completed. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 33 of 84 Page 15 Page 18 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 6 — INFRASTRUCTURE RELIABILITY Maintain facilities and equipment to be dependable, resilient, and long lasting Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Draft Asset Management Plan will be presented in Q3 and includes process details for condition assessment. Q2: Ongoing. Formalize a condition assessment process for each asset class and complete Meyer / Goel / Q3: Asset Management Plan was presented to the condition assessments on all critical equipment. Lopez Engineering and Operations Committee. E&O committee commended the Asset Management Plan and recommended for a workshop along with the Process and Technology Optimization Report. Q1: Plan to include into CAPEX scope/work flow. Conduct Failure Mode & Effects and other reliability -based analyses as part of key Meyer / Lopez Q2: Attended RCD workshop by CWEA; looking at ways to Incorporate Asset Management Capital Improvement projects. integrate with CP. practices into the Capital Improvement and Maintenance Programs. Q1: Ongoing, FRACAS process in place. Report, analyze, and identify corrective actions to eliminate or mitigate the Meyer / Lee Q2: Completed 1 RCA on Hypo system. recurrence of the failure of key and critical assets. Q3: Completed 1 RCA on Wet Scrubber. Complete Planner Updates to work orders and use other feedback mechanisms for Meyer / Lee Q1: 20 planner updates completed. Q2:18 planner updates completed. continuous improvement. Q3: 47 planner updates completed. Manage Assets Optimally Optimize rehabilitation, replacement, and cleaning of pipelines. Seitz Q1: Ongoing. Perform strategic reliability -based analysis on treatment plant process systems. Meyer / Lee Q2: On target. Identified processes for PMO and RCM. Q3: On target. RCM refresher training contract executed and actual training scheduled. Q1: On -going vibration monitoring, machine lubrication, fluid Deploy condition -based and predictive -based technologies across asset classes. Meyer / Lee analysis, Infrared imaging, Ultrasound testing for critical assets. Q2: Staff obtained certification in various technologies. Develop reliability -centered asset Q1/Q2: This is part of the Process and Technology management strategies. Optimization strategic plan. Develop Asset Health Indicator Requirements and an Asset Tool Framework. Meyer / Goel / Q3: Identified for prioritization exercise in May/June. Mallory Maintenance, Optimization, and IT divisions are summarizing the background and objectives to engage consultants in Q4 Q1: Ongoing incorporation of service contracts to CMMS. Add service contracts to computerized maintenance management software Meyer / Lee Q2: Ongoing, creating inboxes, work flows and creating PM (CMMS) to track work orders. task in CMMS. Q3: Ongoing. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 34 of 84 Page 16 Page 19 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 6 — INFRASTRUCTURE RELIABILITY Maintain facilities and equipment to be dependable, resilient, and long lasting Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Ongoing CMMS set up for Pump Stations Operations preventive maintenance work order and in the process to pilot Transfer Pumping Stations Operations preventative maintenance work orders to Meyer /Lee San Ramon Pump Station. CMMS by the end of 2022. Q2: Ongoing, creating inboxes, work flows and creating PM task in CMMS, plan to complete end of FY. Q3: Ongoing. Q1: This is part of routine CAPEX review and CAPEX Ensure all critical assets and processes in need of repair or replacement are Meyer / Lopez / coordination meetings. appropriately scheduled in the 10-Year CIP. Weer Q2: Ongoing. Q1: InfoAsset license is up-to-date. Asset management group Develop a prioritization model for vertical assets and update the risk model. Gemmell / Bohan is working on completing the Asset Management Plan. / Meyer Q3: Asset Management Plan is scheduled for E&O and Board Perform capital improvements in in Q4. accordance with the Q1: In progress. Executed contract with Oracle implementor Comprehensive Wastewater Master Plan (CWMP) and Asset and initiated planning phase for EPM capital project budgeting Management Program findings. solution. Q2: Completed "discovery" and successfully transitioned to Maintain and evolve tools for effective financial and project management of the Lopez / Mizuno "design" phase of project planning. Expect to complete "design" "test' capital program. and transition to phase in Q3. Q3: Worked through various design and pre -implementation tasks including 10-year actual and budget CIP data migration Execute Long -Term and validation. Staff training and change management Capital Renewal and sessions to commence in Q4. Replacement Program Identify vulnerable assets and develop mitigation measures. Lopez / Gemmell Q1: Projects identified for 2022-23 CIB for implementation. Q1: Brown and Caldwell completed Treatment Plant Flood Vulnerability Study in July 2022, updating flood and SLR Update the CWMP Technical Memo (TP8) on Resiliency and Vulnerability. Gemmell / Lopez evaluation in TM TP-8. Collection System Infrastructure Plan starting this FY includes resiliency and vulnerability evaluation. Harden infrastructure against Q2: The technical memo will be initiated in the next FY. resiliency risks associated with climate change, earthquakes, and Q1: Levee Improvements project design with Flood Control energy availability. Improve the wet weather basins, berms, and levees to reduce risk of flood damage Lopez / Gemmell District is in progress, expected to bid this FY. Wet weather in extreme wet weather. basin evaluation and berm raising planning are in progress. Q2: In process. A consultant is reviewing this item. Q1: Laboratory seismic retrofit is in progress, will be completed Seismically retrofit the Laboratory and Maintenance Reliability Center buildings. Lopez / Hodges / Schectel / Meyer in Q2. Q2: Laboratory seismic improvements completed. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 35 of 84 Page 17 Page 20 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 6 — INFRASTRUCTURE RELIABILITY Maintain facilities and equipment to be dependable, resilient, and long lasting Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Planning tasks are complete for procurement of electrical blowers. Capital is leading effort for construction. Q2: Design is in progress for Phase 1 Steam Improvements. This project will improve the safety and reliability of the steam system. Expected to bid project Q2 of FY 23-24. Blower Complete renovation of steam and aeration blower operations to increase capacity Lopez / Mizutani / Project to be complete Q3 2023. during energy outages. Hodges Q3: Design continues for Phase 1 Improvements with bid expected Q1 of FY 23-24. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 36 of 84 Page 18 Page 21 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 7 — INNOVATION AND AGILITY Optimize operations for continuous improvement, and remain flexible and adaptable Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible 1St 2°d 3'd Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) QTR QTR QTR FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Consultants have been contracted and the initial Process Optimization Workshop is targeted for January 2023 (Q3) to assess control loops. This work will also be directed and supported by the new Optimization Manager that is currently being recruited, with anticipated on -boarding in Q3. Review plant process control loops and evaluate and rank based on potential cost Goel / Director of Q2: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this savings. Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Develop performance metrics Q3: Control loops are continuously updated as part of major related to key operational systems. capital improvement projects such as Electric Blower Improvement Project, Solids Phase 1A, Influent Pump Station Electrical Upgrade, etc Q1: In scope for completion during initial Blue Ribbon Optimization Committee in Q3. Assess existing monitoring, metrics, and controls for those processes with greatest Goel / Director of Q2: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this optimization potential and develop recommendations for improvements. Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Q3: To start engaging consultants in Q4. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Design and implement new real-time control systems for improved monitoring, Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this Leverage Data control, and optimization. p Operations p KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Analytics to Become a More Efficient Utility Q1: On -track for Q3. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Assess and pilot test digital monitoring and cloud analytics to leverage machine Goel / Meyer boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this learning where effective and applicable. KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Q1: On -track for Q4. Deploy improved monitoring and Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - performance tracking and Integrate data collection and analysis for reporting performance of key business Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this analytics. areas. Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Q1: Consultant contract with Aquasight is in progress to complete this task for development of real-time monitoring of plant processes. Q2: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Develop new reporting dashboards to track strategic, tactical, and operational Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities performance metrics. Operations related to the optimization effort. Q3: SCADA hardware upgrades is in a critical path and to be completed first before the implementation of Aquasight dashboard. Aquasight is developing dashboard and will be live after the SCADA upgrades are complete. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 37 of 84 Page 19 Page 22 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 7 — INNOVATION AND AGILITY Optimize operations for continuous improvement, and remain flexible and adaptable Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible 1St 2°d 3'd Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) QTR QTR QTR FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: The Q1 deliverable recently completed is the establishment of a "Blue Ribbon Process Performance Committee" composed of consultant and Central San treatment process optimization experts. The scope and contracts are now in place for 3 of the 4 consultant process experts. This is a phased plant optimization Goel / Director of program, with this element of work assigned to the newly formed Develop best practices guidance for process control. Operations Blue Ribbon Process Optimization Committee for completion in Q3. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Q1: On -track for Q4. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Conduct a review and ranking of current versus target treatment efficiencies. Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this Evaluate the treatment process Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities and carry out recommendations for related to the optimization effort. optimization. Q1: On -track for Q4. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Implement Identify conceptual improvements and their potential efficiencies. Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this Organization -Wide Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities Optimization related to the optimization effort. Q1: On -track for Q4. Goel / Director of Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Develop an implementation plan and schedule of recommended opportunities. Operations boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Q1: On -track for Q4. Goel / Director of Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Communicate progress and results on process measures. Operations boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Gee / Gemmell / Q1/Q2/Q3: Managers continue to review optimizations progress Continue the Optimizations, Applied Research, and Smart Initiative programs. LaBella / Goel / on a quarterly basis. Meyer Q1: FY 2021-22 Optimizations Program Annual Report targeted Support innovation in capital and operational improvements. to be presented to the Board in late 2022. Provide Optimizations Program Annual Reports to Board. Gee Q2: Innovations Fair recap was presented. FY 2021-22 Optimizations Program Annual Report is scheduled to be presented to the Admin Committee and full Board in Q3. Q3: FY 2021-22 report was presented to the Board. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 38 of 84 Page 20 Page 23 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 7 — INNOVATION AND AGILITY Optimize operations for continuous improvement, and remain flexible and adaptable Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible 1St 2°d 3'd Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) QTR QTR QTR FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Consultants are at work, and project is on track. Q2: Workshops held to present tentative results; Smart Utility Develop and begin implementing the IT Strategic Plan. Mallory workshops will take place in February 2023. On schedule for a Q3 completion. Q3: Completed Smart Utility workshop in February. Blue Wall prioritization exercise planned for May. Q1/Q2: Phase 1 of Chathu's Mentorship Project is complete. Phase 2 included in IT/OT master plan. Automate the Treatment Plant Asset Handover Process and track completion of Mallory / Goel / Q3: IT provided access to Engineering folder that houses the key points along the workflow. Meyer asset information until the process is either automated or further improved. Q1: Still under consideration and discussions with Operations. Q2: Bar coding fixed plant assets has been piloted and proven successful. Now in the stage of implementing at the treatment Evaluate and use geocoding/barcodes to tag and track plant assets. Gaines / Leiber / plant, where bar codes will be put on all fixed assets. Piloting Deutsch / Meyer geo-tracking devices for mobile assets (loss prevention) is still under consideration. For the first item tested, it did not prove effective. Q3: Implementing bar coding for TP assets. Q1: RF Smart Barcode has been implemented and used in the following areas: Cycle Count,and Receiving. Material Issuances Implement a barcode Warehouse inventory program to fully automate all issues, Gaines / Leiber will be a major project with assistance from I.T. receipts, and inventory cycle counts. Q2/Q3: The issuance of inventory items is a collaborative project with IT and Risk Management. Discussions have been held but full implementation is projected by Q4. Evaluate, select, and implement new Sewer Service Charge development and Gemmell / Leiber Q1/Q2/Q3: Have not started project; have created hardware redundancy for existing HTE system until a change is made for a billing software. / Mallory new system. Waiting for Permitting Software go -live. Q1: Project will restart with Oracle on 10/17/2022, with a targeted date of Summer 2023 go -live. Implement Permitting and Community Development software. Gemmell / Leiber Q2: Progressing. Summer 2023 go live still anticipated, but could / Mallory extend to fall depending on implementer issues. Q3: Good progress on implementation. Go -Live scheduled for fall Continue to configure new ERP 2023 to focus on training/UAT after billing is completed. system to meet evolving needs. Utilize digital database storage and retrieval to reduce paper processes. Young Ongoing as needed. Create procedures to reflect new business workflows. All Managers Leiber / Gaines / Q2/Q3: Reviewing Oracle functionality for tracking these items. Improve Maintenance, Repair, and Operations metrics monitoring. Meyer Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 39 of 84 Page 21 Page 24 of 34 ATTACHMENT 1 CEN74AL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY SUCCESS MEASURES (KSMs) PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 7 — INNOVATION AND AGILITY Optimize operations for continuous improvement, and remain flexible and adaptable Strategy Initiative Key Success Measures Responsible 1St 2°d 3'd Q4 / Activities/Performance in Achieving KSM Person(s) QTR QTR QTR FY-End (Status, Comments, and Exceptions) Q1: Scoping of this effort is underway, as it follows the completion of the above tasks of the performance reliability of key treatment processes. Identify potential collection and treatment system catastrophic events along with Goel / Director of Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - key operational decisions and responses. Operations boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Q1: Scoping of this effort is underway. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Develop Decision Analytics to provide the required support documentation for Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this Make sound decisions when faced rapid response. Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities with unforeseen events. related to the optimization effort. Q1: Scoping of this effort is underway. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Develop the analytic infrastructure to gather and use information to make data- Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this driven assessments. Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities Be Adaptable, Resilient, related to the optimization effort. and Responsive Ongoing as needed. Survey best practices of leading sister agencies. All Managers Q1: Scoping of this effort is underway. Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - Design and perform Failure and Response Evaluations of major operational Goel / Director of boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this upsets. Operations KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Develop and employ improved Q1: Staff is working with Aquasight to develop a digital real time operational decision support systems and approaches where (DRT) monitoring program to support data analytics and practicable. performance trending. Implement the Jarvis Operations Response software pilot to facilitate decision Goel / Director of Q2/Q3: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on - making based on real-time data. Operations boarded, but with the departure of the Director of Operations, this KSM may be reworked or be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. Color codes indicate the status of the KSM as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information about the status of the KSM. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (KSM was fulfilled) (KSM is in progress or being done differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold /Delayed /At Risk Off Track (KSM is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) 0 (KSM is in danger of not being fulfilled by 6130124) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 40 of 84 Page 22 Page 25 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CE SANITARY RY TRADISTRICT COSTA ICT SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 1 - CUSTOMER AND COMMUNITY Provide Exceptional Service Metric Target Responsible Person(s) Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Average onsite response time for collection system emergency calls, <30 minutes Seitz 15 minutes 20 minutes 18 minutes during working hours Average onsite response time 41 minutes for collection system emergency calls, 540 minutes Seitz 34 minutes 42 minutes FY 2021-22: after hours 32.47 Average customer service rating for >_3.8 out of 4.0 Seitz 4.00 4.00 4.00 emergency calls Q1: No surveys sent. Surveys will be mailed to customers for WC 15 and N. 94% Orinda 8 projects in Q2. ° 75 /° Q2: Walnut Creek 15 overall satisfaction was 75%. Results for N. Orinda 8 will Average customer satisfaction rating on ° ?95 /° Carpenter Lopez No surveys sent FY 2021-22: FY 2021-22: be available next quarter. ro construction projects p� No surveys sent in No surveys sent in Q3: North Orinda 8 overall satisfaction was 94%. Q2; 90. 1% in Q1 Q2 or Q3; 90.1 % in Q1 Q1: 10 surveys submitted. 8 Excellent, 1 Fair and 1 Needs Improvement, which provided a comment to have more options to schedule an inspection than 90% 86% calling standard phone number. Average customer satisfaction rating on ?95% Gemmell 100% FY021-22: Q2: 4 Surveys submitted with Excellent ratings. permit counter interactions p FY 2021-22: 100 % Q3: 6 out of 7 surveys submitted with Excellent ratings. 1 Needs Improvement y g p 90.1% rating related to customer who was told that their existing encroachments would need a Real Property Agreement and no further encroachments would be permitted. Sewer Service Charge affordability <2% Q1: New SSC rate schedule is in process for Financial Workshop in Q3. (Environmental Protection Agency Lowest (or lower than Gemmell Q2: Existing and new proposed rate remains within EPA affordable criteria. Quintile Residential Indicator) High impact) Q1: Two hundred and seventy-seven (277) people were served through virtual and community events. Q2: One hundred and five (105) people were served through virtual and Participants in public tours and ?500 Barnett 277 105 150 community events. presentations Q3: One hundred and fifty (150) people were served through virtual and community events. Q1: Next session tentatively planned to be held in person in spring 2023. Participants in Central San Academy >_35 Gee 20 Q2: Planning next session to begin in Q3. Q3: Central San Academy was held with 20 participants. 4 Q1: 2 awards received. Awards or recognitions received >_10 Young 2 2 Q2: 4 awards received. Q3: 2 awards received. Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. •Completed O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 41 of 84 Page 1 Page 26 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANDARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 2 — ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP Meet regulatory requirements, promote sustainability, and identify and reduce contributions to climate change and mitigate its impacts Metric Target Responsible Person(s) Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues National Pollutant Discharge Elimination 0 violations Weer System compliance Recycled Water Title 22 compliance 0 violations Weer See comments 01: Opacity excursion on 8/31/22. This will or will not constitute a violation. Q2: Inoperative monitor RCA for Aux Boiler 1 landfill gas flowmeter on 10/14/22. FY 2021-22: Violation is not expected. Title V compliance 0 violations Weer 0 Reportable Q3: Inoperative monitor RCA for Furnace 1 opacity monitor on 1/27/2023. Compliance Violation is not expected. Activities Regulatory Title V work orders ° 100 /° Meyer ° 100 /° 100% ° 100/o completed on time Q1: On track to meet calendar year (CY) 2022 GHG target. Anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) <_25,000 metric tons (MT) Cheng Q2: Met CY 2022 target. Pre -verified total: 24,025MT CO2e. emissions CO2e per calendar year Q3: On track to meet calendar year (CY) 2023 GHG target. Sanitary sewer overflows <_1.3 spills per 100 miles Seitz 3 9 2 of pipeline 1 3 1 Spills to public water <1 Seitz FY 2021-22: 0 FY 2021-22: 2 FY 2021-22: 2 3 0 Spills greater than 500 gallons s3 Seitz 1 FY FY 2021-22: 4 Sanitary sewer overflows 0 Seitz / Lopez 0 0 0 resulting from construction work Annual Environmental Compliance Q3: 100% of Environmental Compliance inspections and permitting completed inspections and permitting 100% Henry / 100% ° 100 /D ° 100 /° on time. completed on time Talarico Household Hazardous Waste (HHW) 0 violations Wyatt 0 violations 0 violations 0 violations management compliance Q1: Five thousand, seven hundred and sixty nine (5,769) students were served through education programs. Q2: Three thousand, eight hundred and sixty three (3,863) students were served Students served by education programs >_6,000 Barnett 5,769 3,863 **4,393 through education programs. Q3: Four thousand, three hundred and ninety-three (4,393) students were served through education programs. **Delta Discovery Data will be added when it becomes available** Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 42 of 84 Page 2 Page 27 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANDARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 2 - ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP Meet regulatory requirements, promote sustainability, and identify and reduce contributions to climate change and mitigate its impacts Metric Target Responsible Person(s) Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Q1: On track. Gallons of recycled water '-240 million gallons (MG) Foss 90.7 MG 23.6 MG 4.2 MG FY2021-22: Q2: On track.Q3: Recycled water usage was lower than usual due to wet distributed to external customers 24.2 MG weather. Electricity produced by co -generation using >_18 million kWh (reported Lee / Shima 22.8 million kWh 22.0 million kWh 22.0 million kWh 01: On track. 02: On track. natural gas as a rolling average) Q3: On track. Q1: On track. Solar power produced at Collection System >_220,000 kWh (reported Lee /Shima 286,000 kWh 293,000 kWh 279,000 kWh Q2: On track. Operations and HHW Collection Facility as a rolling average) Q3: On track. FY 2021-22: Boarded Q1: Start of construction delayed by 45 days due to a pipeline easement issue FY 2021-22: adopted CEQA on the Lagiss Property. Still on track to complete project by end of fiscal year. Focused on mitigated negative Q2: Start of construction continues to be delayed as Central San's solar vendor completing CEQA declaration, approved works with Kinder Morgan and PG&E to gain approval for crossing over their Solar power produced >_2.5 million kWh environmental the project, approved existing easements with facilities for the new solar array. by a new solar array near the treatment (reported as a rolling LaBella review, start-up Amendment 1 to the 03: Central San's solar vendor continues to await approval from Kinder Morgan plant campus p p average) g) anticipated for Power Purchase for crossingover their three easements and two pipelines on the La iss property p p g p p y January/February Agreement, and with the interconnection facilities for the solar array. The project cannot proceed 2023. approved creation of to construction until this is resolved. $600,000 capital project. Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) OOff Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 43 of 84 Page 3 Page 28 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANDARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 3 — WORKFORCE DIVERSITY AND DEVELOPMENT Recruit, educate, empower, and retain a workforce from diverse backgrounds Metric Target Responsible Person(s) Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Average time to fill vacancy <_60 day s O'Malley / 45 59 45 (from request to hire) Manor 2.1 % (incl. 2.5% mints. 0.7% (incl. Retirements) 56.5% O'Malley / retirements) Retirements) Turnover rate (incl. retirements) Granzella 1.1 % (excl. 0.36% (excl. 0.72% (excl. retirements) Retirements) Retirements) Average annual training hours O'Malley / 2.70 per employee >_15 Smith 7.22 3.69 (external and internal training) See comments for FY See comments for FY See comments for FY Q1: Jul rec'd 73%; Aug rec'd 80%; Sep rec'd 95%. 2022-23 performance 2022-23 performance 2022-23 performance Q2: Oct rec'd 82%; Nov rec'd 76%; Dec rec'd 79%. Q3: Jan rec'd 84%; Feb rec'd 65%; Mar rec'd 65% Completion of annual performance evaluations 100% O'Malley / Howard FY2021-22: FY2021-22: FY2021-22: July evals 86% reed, Oct. evals 91 % rec'd, Jan. evals 83% reed, Aug. evals 86% rec'd, Nov. evals 91 % reed; Feb. evals 62% reed; Sep. evals 83% reed. Dec. evals 72% reed. Mar. evals 68% reed. Q1: All eligible employees received Temporary Modified Duty. Temporary modified duty provided >-95% of recordable Deutsch ° 100 /O ° 100 /° ° 100 /° Q2: All eligible employees received Temporary Modified Duty. (Return to Work program) injuries Q3: All eligible employees received Temporary Modified Duty. Q3: Only one new hire and it was an entry-level position. Internal promotions ° ?25 /° O'Malley / ° 66.67 /° ° 33.33 /° ° 0 /° (excludes entry-level positions) Granzella Formal grievances processed 0 O'Malley / Manor 0 0 0 O'Malley / Q1/Q2: Wellness Expo takes place in Q2. Employees continue to engage in Participation in annual Wellness Expo + >>-10% each year Howard ° 15 /° increase Wellness activities. Q3: 54 Attendees at 2023 Expo vs. 47 in 2022. 15% increase. Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 44 of 84 Page 4 Page 29 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CE SANITARY RY TRADISTRICT COSTA ICT SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 4 — GOVERNANCE AND FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY Uphold integrity, transparency, and wise financial management in an effective governing model Metric Target Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Person(s) Compliance with Public Records Act 100% Young requests on time Board meeting videos posted online 100% Young Standard and Poor's and Moody's AAA/Aal Leiber / Mizuno AAA/Aal AAA/Aal AAA/Aa1 Q1 - Q3: No known change to standing S&P and Moody's ratings. credit ratings Debt service coverage ratio >_2.0 Leiber /Mizuno n/a n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. Debt as a percentage of total assets :560% Leiber /Mizuno n/a Debt financing n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. of prior 10 years' CIP spending ° <_60 /° Leiber /Mizuno n/a Debt financing as a percentage n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. of projected 10-year CIP ° <_60 /° Leiber /Mizuno n/a Total revenue funded collection system CIP n/a n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. spending in past 10 years ° ?100 /o Leiber /Mizuno Total revenue funded collection system n/a n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. spending in 10-year CIP (projection) ° ?100 /° Leiber /Mizuno ° n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. O&M reserves of next year's°budget Leiber /Mizuno n/a >50% n/a n/a This is a year-end calculation only. To be updated in Q4. Sewer Construction reserves of next year's budget Leiber / Mizuno n/a (non -debt financed) Q1: Slightly below target, largely due to July always being lower due to prior year Operating expenditures 95 2% AP/payroll accrual reversals. Conversely, June is typically higher following current as a percentage of Board -approved 90-100% Leiber / Mizuno 87.4% 94.7% year AP/payroll accruals. operating budget Q2: On target. OPEB trust contributions approved by Board in Fall 2022 increasing % from Q1 in addition to other factors. Financial reports disseminated Q1 - Q2: On track. Three overviews and one quarterly report to Board/Finance every month (summary) and quarter (full) ° 100% Leiber / Mizuno ° 100% ° 100% ° 100% Committee. Reported material weaknesses or Q1: This is a once a year result only. To be updated in when Financial Audit is significant deficiencies 0 Leiber / Mizuno n/a 0 0 available for FY 2021-22 (in Q2 of this fiscal year). in internal controls as part of annual Q2/Q3: Audit of ACFR completed without material weaknesses or significant financial audit deficiencies. Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. •Completed O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 45 of 84 Page 5 Page 30 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CE SANITARY RY TRADISTRICT COSTA ICT SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 4 — GOVERNANCE AND FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY Uphold integrity, transparency, and wise financial management in an effective governing model Metric Target Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Person(s) Q1: No overflow claims. Average cost per overflow claim <_$25,000 Deutsch $0 $8,777 $12,100 Q2: $8,877 (which includes $20k reserve. Avg cost paid to date is $3,877). Q3: Average cost per Overflow (combined) $12.100.00. Q1: 197 purchase requisitions received; 81 % met processing time metric. Avg Purchasing requisitions completed within 86% requisition processing time is 5 business days. standard processing time o ?80 /o King 0 81 /0 0 86 /o Q2: 180 purchase requisitions received; 86% met processing time metric. Avg requisition processing time is 4 business days. Q3: 222 purchase requisitions received; 86% met processing time metric. Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. •Completed O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 46 of 84 Page 6 Page 31 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CE SANITARY RY TRADISTRICT COSTA ICT SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 5 - SAFETY AND SECURITY Provide a safe, secure, and healthful workplace that foresees and addresses threats Metric Target Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Person(s) Safety -prioritized work orders 100% Meyer 100% 100% 100% completed on time Q1: 2 recordables, 136,988 hours worked. Incident Rate - 2.9 Employee injury and illness < _3.3 Ledbetter 2.9* 3.8* 3.0* Q2: 3 recordables, 125,556 hours worked. Incident Rate - 4.77 lost time incident rate Q3: 1 recordable, 134677 hours worked. Incident Rate - 1.5 *Cumulative Incident Rate Workers' compensation Q1-Q4: Ex Mod applies for the fiscal/policy year. experience modifier <_1.0 Deutsch 82 .82 .82 .82 Q1: Some items are added into the Capital Improvement Budget and can take Days to implement approved months if not years. Performance reported reflects days to act upon (vs. Safety Suggestions <-60 Ledbetter <45 <45 <60 implement). Q3: Chair for Safety Committee resigned and we only could have one meeting in the past quarter. Q1: 174 accounts in full compliance, 40 accounts in partial compliance, and 9 accounts in non-compliance. Contractors/consultants in compliance >70% King 78% 81 % 83% Q2: 180 accounts in full compliance, 35 accounts in partial compliance, and 7 with insurance requirements accounts in non-compliance. Q3: 181 accounts in full compliance, 28 accounts in partial compliance, and 9 accounts in non-compliance. 99% uptime Q2: There was an internet slow down during a board meeting due to security Information system outages 100% uptime Mallory 100% uptime 100% equipment "phoning home". The root cause was a patch applied by the vendor affecting normal business operations FY 2021-22: that switched the timing from 2AM to 2PM. 100% uptime Q3: No incidents. Q2 / Q3: No data lost. Data backup and recovery 0 lost data Mallory 0 lost data 100% 65% 65% Q3: Status unchanged. Will ramp up in Q4. Employees trained in 100% Mallory 60% cybersecurity awareness FY2021-22: N/A FY2021-22: N/A (new metric) (new metric) Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. •Completed O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 47 of 84 Page 7 Page 32 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CE SANITARY RY TRADISTRICT COSTA ICT SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 6 — INFRASTRUCTURE RELIABILITY Maintain facilities and equipment to be dependable, resilient, and long lasting Metric Target Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4/ FY-End Comments / Issues Person(s) Planned treatment plant 97% preventative maintenance >_90% Meyer 97% 95% completed on time Planned recycled water distribution system preventative maintenance >98% Seitz 100% 100% 100% completed on time Planned collection system preventative maintenance ?98% Seitz 99.2% 99.2% 99.5% completed on time Pipeline cleaning On >A% of pipelines 3.21 % 3.31 % 3.81 % quality assurance / quality control (QA/QC) cleaned on an annual Seitz basis FY 2021-22: 4.43% FY2021-22:3.31% FY 2021-22: 2.42% 95.1 % 96.43% Pipeline cleaning QA/QC passing rate 2:98% Seitz FY 2021-22: FY 2021-22: 98.74% 95.45 % 94.20 % 31 miles 18 miles 18 miles Pipeline inspected through 10% inspected Closed Circuit Television Program (150 miles) / 37.5 miles per quarter Seitz FY2021-22: N/A FY2021-22: N/A FY2021-22: N/A (new metric) (new metric) (new metric) Uptime for vehicles 100% Seitz 100% 100% 100% Miles of sewers replaced 0.5 miles 1.3 miles (focused on deteriorated >_6.0 Mestetsky / 1 mile small diameter pipelines) Lopez FY2021-22: FY2021-22: 1.3 miles 0.9 miles FY 2021-22: Began Ir Y 2021-22:Q1: Completed Phase 1 inspection of large diameter pipelines in Martinez and work on ITpipes Coordinated Danville Blvd and associated maintenance access covers. Results expected in multi -sensor meetings with Q2: Preliminary files for manhole inspections, CCTV, and H2S provided to Large diameter and force main Waples / Frost / inspection portal. I contractor and subs ITpipes. Cues processing of laser data delayed, anticipate remaining data condition assessment >_3 miles per year Gemmell <1 mile Inspections delayed to address delivered to ITpipes early 2023 and accessible to District in Q3. by contractor contractor delays. Q3: ITpipes platform completed. Data being reviewed. Additional inspections performance; Pushing for to achieve >3 miles/year would not be authorized until after staff determines inspections still inspections to begin the value of MSI results in Phase 1. expected this FY. this FY. Average time to execute Engineering agreements from <2 weeks King 9.81 business days 6.35 business days 6.69 business days complete package submittal 99% Contract renewals executed on time 100% King 100% 100% for uninterrupted service FY2021-22: N/A (new metric) Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. •Completed O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 48 of 84 Page 8 Page 33 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CE SANITARY RY TRADISTRICT COSTA ICT SANITARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 6 - INFRASTRUCTURE RELIABILITY Maintain facilities and equipment to be dependable, resilient, and long lasting Metric Target Responsible Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Person(s) Q1: 29 Items requested to stock with 26 items added within the specified 5 working day threshold. Three items outside this range required additional Approved request -to -stock items entered in databases o 100 /0 Gaines / Leiber 100% o 100 /a o 100 /o information from the requester. Q2: 9 Items requested to stock and 9 items added within the specified 5 within 5 business days working day threshold. Q3: 19 Items requested to stock, all 19 items were added within 5 working days and linked to the appropriate assets. Q1: Rollover in FY 22-23 was large at $69.41VI excluding project close-out savings, thus falling well short of target in Q1. Finance/Capital/Planning teams are looking into the spending pace as we gear up for rate adjustment hearings. Capital expenditures 29.2% 37.3% 37.0% Q2: Increase from Q1, although well short of target due to large carryforward as a percentage of capital budgeted from FY 21-22. 1/12/23 Financial Workshop communicated that approximately (YTD estimated budget) o >-90 /o Lopez / Mizuno FY 2021-22: FY 2021-22: FY 2021-22: $28.91VI in FY 21-22 carryforward would be released to reserves for future cash flow including carry forward Data was not yet Tracking below 90% Tracking below 90% years as part of FY 23-24 budget cycle. available as of November as of April Q3: Slight reduction from Q2, still short of target due to carry forward from FY 21-22. FY 23-24 CIB significantly lowered from recent years in an effort to catch up on projects impacted by pandemic and supply chain challenges over past 2-3 years. Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. •Completed O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) •Off Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 49 of 84 Page 9 Page 34 of 34 ATTACHMENT 2 CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANDARY DISTRICT FY 2022-23 STRATEGIC PLAN KEY METRICS PROGRESS TRACKER GOAL 7 - INNOVATION AND AGILITY Optimize o erations for continuous improvement, and remain flexible and adaptable Metric Target Responsible Person(s) Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 / FY-End Comments / Issues Q1/Q2: This initiative is on hold pending completion of the IT Strategic Plan Mallory / Goel update. Projects initiated under Central San Smart >_3 03: This initiative is being rolled into the Process and Technology Optimization (PTO) Strategic Plan. Q1: This is a phased optimization program. The Q1 milestone completed is the development of the approach and scope for Aquasight to develop a digital real time (DRT) monitoring program to support data analytics and performance trending. Q2: Operations Optimization Manager Nitin Goel was on -boarded, but with Improved process monitoring or ?3 control loops Goel Director of Operations FY 2021-22: N/A the departure of the Director of Operations, the development of control loops performance reporting p P 9 new metric i � will be put on hold to pursue other priorities related to the optimization effort. p p p� p� Q3: Control loops are continuously updated as part of major capital improvement projects such as Electric Blower Improvement Project, Solids Phase 1A, Influent Pump Station Electrical Upgrade, etc. 01: Membrane pilot decommissioned. Reports anticipated in Q2/Q3. 02: Received draft Membrane Pilot report. Final Pilot report and Draft Reviews or pilot tests -3 '' Frost All Managers alternatives evaluation report anticipated in Q3. of new and promising technology Q3: Received Final Pilot report. Final Alternatives evaluation report anticipated Q4. Received draft multi -sensor inspection pilot inspection reports from Cues/ProPipe. Q1: Abstract submitted to WateReuse: "Sustainable Membrane Performance for Refinery Reuse of Challenging Non -Nitrified Wastewater". Poster presentation for Membrane Pilot at Central San's Innovations Fair. >_3 papers or 02: Envision abstract submitted to WEF CS 2023 and WEFTEC 2023 Research papers and findings presented presentations Frost / All Managers 2 3 conferences. Membrane pilot abstract submitted to WEFTEC 2023.Abstract "Re submitted to WEFTEC -use and Rehabilitate to Recycle: A case study on modernizing dual media tertiary filters at the Central San WWTP" Q3: No new papers completed this quarter. Membrane pilot was presented to both Central San Academy and Externship programs. 2 1 7 Q1: In addition, 20 Planner updates completed. Don't Just Fix It; Improve It '25 Meyer 02: In addition, 18 Planner updates completed. work orders completed FY2021-22: 6 FY2021-22: 1 FY2021-22: 2 03: 7 completed. Completed optimizations >_20 Gee / All Managers Q1/Q2/Q3: Optimizations are tracked quarterly by the managers. Color codes indicate the status of meeting the target for the FY as of the end of the quarter. Explanations in the right -most column provide additional information on the status of meeting the target. OCompleted O On Track / Revised Approach (Target was met for the FY) (Target is on track to be met or metric is being measured differently from how it is written in the Strategic Plan but preserving the intent) OOn Hold / Delayed /At Risk (Ability to meet target is on hold, delayed, or at risk but recoverable) OOff Track (Target is in danger of not being met for the FY) May 2, 2023 Regular ADMIN Committee Meeting Agenda Packet - Page 50 of 84 Page 10