HomeMy WebLinkAbout03.a. (Handout) Presentation from meeting Item 3.a.
(Handout)
March 23,2023
AN
Pump and Blower Building
Roof Replacement, District � -
Project 7370
Engineering and Operations - ;L
Committee Meeting -- `
Edgar J. Lopez, P.E. r
I
Capital Projects Division Manager
Background and Drivers
`a
Central coatm costa PUMP AND BLOWER BUILDING °�=n���
sao.tatyoistna ROOF REPLACEMENT
` District Project 7370 t
Martinez,California
1
Engineer's Estimate: $1,050,000
Bid Results ($1,350,000 with alternates)
Ten Bids (10) bids received
Lowest Bidder: Pac Shield
NO. BIDDER BID PRICE
1 Pac Shield Roof Services,Inc. $973,006
Modesto,California
2 Roofing and Solar Construction,Inc. $1,022.198.10
Santa Rosa,California
3 Stronger Building Services $1,075,000
San Leandro,California
4 San Francisco Roofing Services,Inc. $1,200,000
San Francisco,California
5 State Roofing Systems,Inc. $1,217,661
San Leandro,California
6 18A Contractor,Inc. $1,299,000
Redwood City,California
Waterproofing Associates,Inc.
7 Santa Clara,California $1'308 200
8 Andy's Roofing Company,Inc. $1,373,200
San Leandro,California
9 Western Roofing Service $1,395,000
San Leandro,California
10 Pioneer Contractors,Inc. $1,743,135
San Francisco,California
,n
�..r•
:9
Bid Protest
Second low bidder, Roofing & Solar
Construction Inc, filed a protest.
Pac Shield has responded to original
protest letter. _
Several other correspondence has
occurred since between the two bidders. '--
Staff conducted an independent review
then reviewed the letters.
2
Bid Information
*precise wording from bid
Bidder Name of Subcontractor Portion of Work to be Done*
Manufacturer
1 Soprema Alliance Contracting Services, Roof Demolition
Inc.
2 Garland PARC Specialty Contractors Abatement
3 Garland B&M Tear Off Inc. Demo+Abatement
4 Garland B&M Tear Off Inc. Demo/Hazmat
5 Soprema Alliance Contracting Services, Demo Roof Removal
Inc.
6 Garland B&M Tear Off Inc. Demo&Abatment
7 Garland B&M Tear Off Inc. Roof Demo
8 Garland Alliance Contracting Services, Demo and Abatement
Inc.
9 Garland/Siplast/ B&M Tear Off Inc. Demolition
Soprema
10 Garland Alliance Contracting Services, Demolition
Inc.
1
Discussion
and
Questions?
w
3