HomeMy WebLinkAbout08.a. (Handout) L. Benvenue #1E�
(Ilandoai-)
- 6er�venue�}1-
From: Iouise.benvenue@)comcast.net rmailto :louise.benvenue@)comcast.net1
Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 11:23 AM
To: Elaine Boehme
Cc: Jarred Miyamoto - Mills; Ann Farrell
Subject: Fwd: Maps and Notes from CCCSD - El Toyonal CAD Exceptions
Dear Elaine,
Welcome back. I hope you enjoyed your time off.
At the conclusion of the Board Meeting of June 21 st, President Pro Tern Williams requested a
summary of the variety of maps that have been produced.
We mentioned the maps had errors, always in favor of the sewer. Attached are 5 maps, with my
comments.
The map dated May 17 is of particular importance, because it was used at the Board Meeting, when
the decision was made to allow the CAD exceptions.
My notes should be self - explanatory, but just to clarify:
Where I wrote "XXX is a YES, should be NO" it means that household was contacted,
they clearly communicated they were not in favor of the sewer, and ended up otherwise on the map.
In the case of the Kidd's at 244 El Toyonal, they were contacted by telephone and they attended a
meeting; expressing their NO vote on both occasions.
They still ended up as a YES on the map, which was carried forward with each iteration.
Leo Kidd drove all the way to Martinez for the June 21 Board meeting and repeated his NO position.
This has finally been corrected.
In addition to the maps, I included some pages from position papers and meeting minutes submitted
on this topic that appear biased.
I may not understand everything about this process, so if I stand to be corrected, please advise.
Would you be so kind as to forward this email and these maps to Williams, other Board Members,
and whoever else you deem appropriate?
Thank you so much for your help, and if you need anything else from me, please advise.
Regards,
Louise Benvenue
L
rr
S
V
a
s �
3
0 �
n -+-
Z c
II .,�
V o
u N
v
h
(1 LL
M
0
aao� ao
ao� oa
a as
�vUiU vU.�oOo w
' � F
>1 Low
�a �
5.
a
�
wwz
az0w
Hz
a-W
o
>
a
�
on
oz
W�U.<
ti
1
m
o
>
z
ti
w
U
Cl)
Q..r
D
Q
'k
>
J
Q
Z
O
i
.�
L
=
J
w
�
a
�
z
w
>
O
CL
Z
V
w
V
� � s
V
s
Z
0
Z
Q./
V
7
v
O
ti
0
s
rt
t
J
M 10
0
1z- z
GLvViU aigo
' ��0.1 iri ✓b
v a
� 4
� y
� a �
Q
Z
W
U
V
J
Q
Z
O
J
W
J
a j
� t
z
w
O a`
a
N
Z
W
U
.a
Z I.
OW
�C1�
a
�
�0 a
cn a
o�
wa a
Q
Z
W
U
V
J
Q
Z
O
J
W
J
a j
� t
z
w
O a`
a
N
Z
W
U
.a
N
/ w � °° :• z a
F-w
• ~ �� °C9
■ �� a �-z �z::
■ ' 1 I 1 z%
I \l 3� a e
��w Igo•P ow
/ wv,a
0.m J C a
O � U2 e.
_ • y iq
T
x •
♦ yy
Q •l
x �
•
LN > 0 V
• d 1c �c
x : •k =
•
ui
2 / •k •• ♦ •�C w
Z = cn
•
> = 4.• Q
Q
s Z
Z ~ z \>
x > 0
4 > J
to v = ti �� w
J
> Q
3
zZ C
r
Z��
oo oo
7O y ILA C� \l!
fTiNWyav ��
} } C >
ONW N N >"GGd"�y; C
w'4 A
C C A
co �v; 3t cV
lCL L
N N Y C
C•�Q�L d d
S z W
>
O
IL
w
LL
_Tl.
O
/V
a.
a
S
a
ai
Z
LL
N
�D
U
X
W
d
0
U
c
H
LU
a
N
N
(O
_N
O
s
N
l0
a
0
a.
6
W
cr
Z
W
:A
a,
r 5:
<
• a�
J •o
�5
J�
O:
°- '�
Q 2
O O zi
CL =
`
}
aq I_; a,�NO �p
i� Ck roll, tL`
O O C N 3
Z Z �`' CA NO St
O m �
0.0
to Z 'D 'S O .N O
O .fl O O N�a
= N +O+ O T, 4jw
c-cu ° o
M w Ln rn M o M., ' vi
~ II N N •OO to a) a +cv �'
O 3 >@ M >t g ?.n SWO 1 O SVwOI
�Y Y 2 >LL? B woe; •
a;
Q , ai •
fO ' d s a� t �� V _, ••� 1RItlO
Q id O S.
O �
I- f
W
t�
C '
Q)
O
a
10N
Sb>
a /
� q
o
Z
$�ati
o?
N
U
u7
8
1�
m
a
N
R
Y)
N
O
N
n
O
H
_ A_
>
.0 cr
-
4•
1; . . ......
. .................
6 411
IN
(D
0 0
-, * i VIC
z z
CL
LAJ . ..... ..
I"M
z
>
0
0
Z y LLI
0
0 0
V
4)
0
O cl) U)
Lu LLI 0
N d a
le
0
w o
I
>
(a 0 to .— C.
>- 0 > u
LL m m o
.; ; L.
a W rl
o
M C*4
0 4. 0 o
=
0 0 0 c
>%
(J
M 4) % cm
2, 0)
>%
0 0 U)
E (j) >
6. *:
o
(U O
0-0
&
0
m CL
002 m
q &0
C-4 LIC
LIU
R�
Lll
V/3
im
DZ
..rl
CL
CL
cu
LL
cu
co
a.
O
CL
ui
'5
a_
O
0
0
a-
0-
p-
V7
D
N
O
cl
CL co
r
0
U) LU
cc
z
N
N46
'L
I"M
LIU
R�
Lll
V/3
im
DZ
..rl
CL
CL
cu
LL
cu
co
a.
O
CL
ui
'5
a_
O
0
0
a-
0-
p-
V7
D
N
O
cl
CL co
r
0
U) LU
cc
z
N
N46
n, 1
Cn ° o
U) QL
O _0 ®— Cll O
._ (D
U i as C�5 O
x .� � O :3 0 °>
o °— C:
ca
c�
Li 0 EZ
n _ C
CU Cll D � ° —
�� O °� o j
-F- m
w o C: ® O � C/) 4-a L--
C:
— o 0
CU Cn >
U > 0 o w
0 O e� vj
4-a O ® O w o >,-o ® a)
4) o� cn U ® am
7 o =,;� co o
— _ ® �°� :3 > W
P Z) CDL
ry
LL I I v Xo4 b x,116 r
V' dD
�, (p J �
Sad
',a3yoN
O
c
h
f67)
A
o�
Z
n
T
a
1
2
3
c AO £ o6ed
OOP'Z6-L6-9 JEW-40VO leuouoI13 jEflUe„od,o;.subdox3 hc§ CIVOIaPISUOO d&U- LL- 9\Zloe\jj1Aea-j \sjaded UOQ1Sod \O3SZ9itK131:N
siewvtu iqjadoid) Ile o4 obpuenpe ue si swa�.sAs (zsoo W6oq) „paoueque„ meu
qA,,, swarsfs o!ides plc soeldej ejeumo fsliedoid siolaq starvtas oilgnd 6u!puoZ ;3 (y
'(pamolle si swelsRs o!ldes
6u!aslxe jo auawsoeldei pus Jledel) 0L6 soups ease eqj ui s juej olldes mau
�o �uewdolanep uo wnojoaejow a peak 9e4 41leal-I IeauawuoalAu3 81900 e4uOO (C
'Agdej6odoj deals i
pue loos felo s,11!4 leuoAol 13 eqj of anp %ljood wjopad sNuej o!;des 6ulas!x3
(Z
'Qoiussa�j olged ueS) P94SJ918M 6ulNuPP onINS3 941 u! s! 109foid ayl (�
:6u!pnlouo `ease leuoAog 2 eqj 4jlm page!oosse siooloel jo jegwnu a of anp
suo!ldeoxe Ao!lod oV o easy;. pabsanbai ane4 sluauodoid oho aye 10 san!Zebuasajdaj�
'slued000ved .col jop1slo 94j Aq PaoueApe spun] eqj jo uorpod
je4j jo juawfiedej ejejejeooe pinom Inq `uo!goeuuoo uodn anp eq Aluo pinom 4o14m
`sjued!ol:aed -uou woj sbuawasingw!aj joego jou pinom juawailnbei s14L ' /4.jadoid
S41 10 ales uodn aoueleq juawssesse 6ululewej .n941 .4o Aed 01 sjuedlol:aed ailnbei
pinoo joljbs!® eqj `AlIeuoog!ppV %Z 6 �-%Vg Aq (loljisia e4l Aq peujei pue) Buioueug
941 j® apI Ilnj aqa JaAo pled IM81W 1e101 94} aseaaou!
pinom }nq ` %fig- %5Z Aq junowe
juawAed lenuue ,sluedioilied eonpai pinom sjeaA OZ jo 51, of sjeaR pl, wojj pooaad
6uooueW 8416ulpu9ix3 -poped 6ulousull ja6uol eqj 6uojnp pled si asojejuo leuooloppe
se 'elsoo lelloa a!94$ jamol you pinom wial 9416uopu%xa 'jamol juewAsd lenuue
,qued!oWed eqj 6uiNew ol!gAA, 'pros fold QVo eqj jo uoljorulsuoo jol peouenPe spun] 941
sJaAooGI ZolJjslo 9414ol4m ae�o poped 94} pua:p:a pinom weal 6uloueug 9416uluegj6ue-1
'POJ9A03e1 eq p1nom Isejejut snld s�soo 'pejoemoo Allenjuana
qued!o!:ped -uou 841 �o Ile $! `sn4i -(Aollod CjVtk,,d eqj 41lm juelslsuoo) jue3jed
suo snld pun_q �U9WJWAUl Aou96V le30-1 941 u! peoeld spun] Aq pewee (ajej
4sejejq) pleiA lenuue 941 fq eel juswasingw!ej ,sjuediol:Ped -uou 941 �sn fpe Rllenuue
pinoo aolJasoo a4� `sTsoo f4jun:poddo �uewjsanu! Isol sj! aol jop1slo s4$ ejesuedwoo of
°serpedoid 6up!�euaq Io %oof jol Giegs isoo ,Sjued!orped -uou 94Z moo of p ejeArt sieeft
o d js�g eLp u! �opZs!o 944 of pesingwlea eq Zou Am Ze4j ooaeueos goee japun gunowe
eqk smiogs (abed snoocsid u. --;z d elgei -po!jad juawAedej oVo aessi -off fuewolsno eqj
uB4llm sbuedlolgaed -uou Aq pasingw!sy Allnj eq jou pinoh,,z Zgj4sl0 aal14e4j Ale 11 s! 11 `Ile
8s 11 'ejeef Ausw ool jeMas o!lgnd eLib q, soeuuoo you AeLL se�noj fames CV3, pasodoid
q lueoefpe sso:pedoid awos sou!S 'pewiol. eq pinom, soya je48 pooq!IeN!l eqj esesiou!
pinonrt 4o14m 'sjusdoo!:ped 1e11!u! of �soo adgj eonpej pinoM uolbedlolped Zop1slo jeZeejO
•azos lewed eBejeAs
sallews a pus juewu fte q.! buola Isoo uol�onjasuoo a6eaeme iarnol a of anp fgaedoad Jed
SOVO V3Ue !VtAOAOi'13 i`` UNSi0d ZA03 SNOLd3Mf3 A01-14 1
OI�!IOI'��� "E�1 (a )1L0,WiSio LWv3NSS3SS;`,f -IvMi -,ff8iN; 0 �d3GISNCOI ,s :;Ofq s
, oz ` , � <we, 39mwaag ravooe
�''EdvId &POILLIP -off
�NQr
'40 oc
S
£dZ a,6eci — tq s1008
Ldn )IooLi of juawejinbai
-slenp!A!p ON uI!M pallgInj uediorped -uou do buiMo!d
to an ns pJemol 6u!ueal sem aq
legl pale aq uOI.ssI u ue3 MOH ui aldoad ql!m uo!ss!w sl!
, - - -. snnollol l! suollelnBei pue
salni seq louls!a eql 'sa!l!unwwoo 03 GOINGS ap!AoJd of louis!p tiel!ues a se uoissiLd �E
leluawepunl s,lo!Jls!a agl pal!o lnq `luawdolanap gl!m hales pue ssaoae aJg gl!nn
serssi eq Aew eJagl palou aH -Aem legl l! daa� of e�!l pinom aJagl an!l ognn asogl legl
pue `sma!A pelonJlsgoun sl! gl!m eaJe eql pale!oeidde aq legl palels swe!ll!M Jagwayy
'eJagl 6u!n!i
asogl Jol s.iamas AJej!ues of ssa,Ioe pue pagsaalem aql 6u!loaloJd u! sl!lauaq glleaq
i
lueo4!u6!s pusallaq `peelsu! ln� `poogJogg6!au egl_uo slaalla esJanpe Jo lueoi!u6!s
ou aq pinom aJagl legl palels aH 'az!uJapow pue puedxe of Al!I!ge agl Jol molle- pinorin
pue `luawdolanap aA!sualxa l!q!goad pinom slueweimbei 6u!pl!nq s,A11-0 agl pue `aoud
of palelaJ Apoaa!p sem saaumo 4adoJd agl Jol Al!l!q!seal agl leyl pelou aH luaoJad
xis le 6u!oueug JeaA -0Z pue uo!led!o!laed lol-gZ of -t Z 6u!wnsse `AlJedoJd JapueM aql
of au!l camas 000`009$ a Ilelsui of lued!o!ljed cad � L'6Ll$10 lsoo Algluow a palew!lse
aH Isoo aigeuoseei a le pagsJglem aql loeloJd pinom sa!}JadoJd ll!qumop aql uo seu!l
Jamas p9l- Al!AeJ6 papnloui leg; adO e legl palsoMns aH 'eaae eql ul awoq a aneq
of luem oqm asogl Jot welgoJd a paleaJo seq wnuoleJow aql leyl palels aH -eaJe aql
u! sieumo Aijedoid `aapueM p!J6ul pue :pago�l 10 l!egaq uo a�ods Alse9g0 :pago�l -JUV
•lo!iluoo ou sem ajegl os 'swe!II!M jegweW uo loedwi le!oueug
ou aneq pinom l! 'Jallew agl uo uo!l!sod a aneq Aew af1W8Ei al!gM '(anWB�i)
lo!alsla 4I! n led!o!unVj Ae8 lse�3 le JalemalseM 10 JoloaJ!a se uo!l!sod s!q 10 asneoeq
Jallew aql u! lsaJalu! 10 lo!lluoo a aneq lou p!p. swe!ll!M Jagwevq legl pewJquoo
wlV lua>1 lasunoa lo!Jls!a 'swe!II!M aagwalq woJl uo!lsenb a of asuodsaJ ul
-s� uel olldes aaJgl 6u!ApewaJ 10 lsoo agl
of paaedwoo 'slot lueoen uo sawoq mgu OZ of 9 � s6u!Jq l! 1! l! q}Jom s! 9jeAedeleJ of
asuedxe eqj 11 iep!suoo of pJeoe eql paNse aH -luawdolanap aA!sualxa 10 suJaouoo
pue 'uleJJal elgelsun 'sao!AJas Aou96J9w9 Jot Alll!glssemeu! 6u!pnlou! 'suoseei
10 Jagwnu a Jol sieumoewog lsOuowe poddns alA!I AJaA s! aaagi •slot lueoen
dolanap of qs!m oqm asogl woJ1 Allsow sawoo ada ail Jot:poddns agl legl palels
aH ,lod JaleM uealo aql 10 suollelo!A to leaJgl aql lnoge paJegs uaaq seq oijolegJ
gonw legl palels aH 'leaJgl pan!aoJad a snsJan leaJgl leaf a 9z!u600aJ of luelJodwi
S1 l! legl 6u!ppe `oda e 10 anlljoddns lou sem aq legl palels u9mo8 laego!vq -jVq
-wnluawow s!ql ql!m mou pewJol aq pinogs ada ail
pue 'sje@A 0L Jano umoJ6 seq Qda eql u!of of 6u!ll!m aldoad 10 lagwnu agl :eaJe ail
u! onpJano 6uol s! walsAs AJel!ues a legl palels aH 'uollnllod of peal pinoo sigmas
6u!llelsu! lou legl palels aq 'w!q ql!m lg6noJq eq JaA11 a wO4 6u!pea�:l -sl!nsmel Alaed
-PI! gl of peloafgns aq pue sau!1 Aed of peoJol aq pinoo seil!unwwoo leool 'uo!lnllod r:
loljnsej a se 'leglla!laq s!q palels aH 's!ql gs!ldw000e of sa!l!a 6L ql!m 6u!MJom
uaaq seq lo!Jls!Q uollemasuoo JaleAA pue Ioiluoa pooh ail pue 'salepuew Jalem
ueelo jaiepad pue alelS mau 6u!luawaldwi gl!m paMsel uaaq seq weJ6oJd JaleM
Z6oe 'g pdy,lo saanurW p-jeog
,L01&.LSIGM4V-L1NVS V1300 VWN00 W81N30
tiM