HomeMy WebLinkAboutAGENDA BACKUP 09-04-86
.
Centra. Contra Costa Sanitar} District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
POSITION PAPER
PAGE 1 OF 2
1986
NO.
v. CONSENT CALENDAR 2
SUBJECT
APPROVE JlGREE~NT RELATING TO REAL PROPERTY WITH
RUBEN LOPEZ, ET UX, JOO 2546, MARTINEZ
DATE
Au ust 26, 1986
TYPE OF ACTION
APPROVE REAL
PROPERTY AGREE~NT
SUB~ITTED BY
uennis Hall, Associate Engineer
INITIATING DEPT.lDIV.
Engineering Dept./Construction Div.
ISSUE:
adj oi ni ng
pool and
map).
The property owner has proposed to install a sw imming pool
the Di stri ct sewer easement on the QII ner' s property. A porti on of the
concrete decki ng w ill encroach into the sewer easement (see attached
BACKGROUND: The long si de of the pool w ill be about two feet into the sewer
easement and w ill be about th ree feet cl ear of the publ ic sewer mai n. Staff has
determ i ned that the improvements w 111 not interfere with the present use of our
sewers. HQllever, if the need should arise, the proposed agreement provides that
the property Qllner is responsible for all costs involved in relocating the sewer
away from the proposed improvements, incl udi ng granti ng a requi red new sewer
easement.
The property Qllner has cooperated with District staff by providing construction
draw ings of the proposed improvements and maki ng requested rev isi ons, and has pai d
the District's fee for processing the subject agreement.
RECOM~NDATION: Approve the Agreement Relating to Real Property with Ruben Lopez,
et ux, Job 2546, authorize the President of the Board and the Secretary of the
Di stri ct to execute sai d agreement and authorize the agreement to be recorded.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACT/ON
INITIATING DEPT.lDIV.
IJ~
\J~
)1)p
130211.9/85
DH
JSM
JL
RAB
SUB
L' ~10tl
-r'
ER~A
#/4/5
\
17
\
Lor /6
POOL.
SPA
LOr /5
OEweR EA. 6e... M. EN... '.. 7.
......---..................~~ -
~ ~...---.... ......
ex .a"-Z54G
G
----
13.NCROPICHMIENT
-0
Page 2 of 2
G
CE
02
L.o r 14-
VICINITY MAP
AI,7.5,
Real Property Agreement
Job 2546
Martinez Area
.
Centra. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
POSITION PAPER
PAGE 1 OF 2
1986
NO.
V. CONSENT CALENDAR 3
SUBJECT
APPROVE JlGREEM:NT RELATING TO REAL PROPERTY WITH
C. M. CISSON, ET UX, Jill 1710, PARCEL 5, CONCORD AREA
DATE
August 26, 1986
TYPE OF ACTION
APPROVE REAL
PROPERTY AGREEM:NT
SUBMITTED BY
Dennis Hall, Associate Engineer
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
Engineering Dept./Construction Div.
ISSUE: The property owner has proposed to construct a sw imming pool
adjoining the District sewer easement on the OtIner's property. A portion of the
concrete pool deck w i1 1 encroach into the sewer easement (see attached map).
BACKGROUND: Staff has determined that the improvanents w ill not interfere with
the present use of our sewers. However, if the need shoul d ari se, the proposed
agreement provides that the property owner is responsible for all costs involved
in removing the proposed improvanents if requested to do 50 by the District.
The property owner has cooperated with District staff by providing construction
draw ings of the proposed improvanents and maki ng requested rev isi ons, and has
paid the District's fee for processing the subject agreement.
RECOMM:NDATION: Approve the Agreement Relating to Real Property with C. M. Cisson,
et ux, Job 1710, Parcel 5, authorize the President of the Board and the
Secretary of the District to execute said agreement and authorize the agreanent to
be recor de d.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
1302A.9/85
DH
JSM
JL
RAB
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
.eV
V&
t11fJ
'-lE^,~ --------
G c.,.. ------
SUB
4// ~
L..OT .3
I..OTZ
L..Or
/
PASO
NOG,.ql...
Q
SIT~
Q
It
~
~
-.J
U
1l.
-.J
()
~
v/e/AI/TY MAP
.r .
Real Property Agreement
Job 1710, Parcel 5
Pacheco Area
.
Centra.. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 2
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
September 4, 1986
NO.
V.
CONSENT CALENDAR 4
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZATION FOR P.A. 86-22 (MARTINEZ) TO BE
INQUDED IN A fUTURE FORMAL ANNEXATION TO lHE
DISTR ICT
DATE
August 26, 1986
TYPE OF ACTION
ACCEPT ANNEXATION
FOR PROCES SING
SU~~Tri~~:YHall, Associate Engineer
INLJIATLNG DEPJ./DIV .
tng1neerlng Dept./Constructlon Div.
Parcel
No.
Area
I Ow ne r
Address
Parcel No. & 'Acreage
Remarks
Lead
Agency
86-22
Marti nez
( 44 CO )
I Peters & Hull
946 Ri sa Road
Lafayette CA 94546
A.P.N. 365-160-011
53 Acres
I Proposed "Saddl ehorn
Ranch" subdivision,
having 27 single
family residential
units. An E.I.R. has
been prepared and was
approved by the County
I Contra
I Costa
County
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize P.A. 86-22 to be included in a future formal annexation.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
DH
JSM
RAB
~
1!rff3
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
1302A.9/85
~A/V#EX~.
TOWNIINO
II." AC.
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
P.A. 86-22 (MARTINEZ)
IUIIT
10404AC
(44 elf)
.-..----------------....--.........~,-----------,--------.,"'-"-~....,..-.--...--...._._--.---.-...~--..-.-..--,.......-"-._-,'.. .....-.._. ...__._..'~.~m'~.__..~ ....-. ... .-.._,._._~,.~~_._.."__.__ -..----t
.
Centr&. Contra Costa Sanitar') District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 1
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
Se tember 4
1986
NO.
v.
CONSENT CALENDAR 5
SUBJECT
ACCEPT lHE CONlRACT WORK FOR CONSlRUCTION OF THE
SAN RA~N CREEK BYPASS a-tANNEL SEWER RELOCATION
PROJ ECT IN WM..NUT CREEK (DP 4046) AND AUTHORIZE THE
FIL ING OF THE NonCE OF COMPL ETION
DATE
ACCE PT CON lRACT
WORK
SUBMITTED BY
Thomas Trice, Engineering Assistant
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
Engineering Dept/Construction Div.
ISSUE: Work has been compl eted on the San Ramon Creek ByPass Channel Sewer
Relocation Project in Walnut Creek and the work is now ready for acceptance.
BACKGROUND: The Contra Costa County Flood Control and Water Conservation District
(Flood Control), in conjunction with the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers (COE), will
be constructing a flood control channel in the abandoned Southern Pacific Railroad
Right-of-Way between Arroyo Way and Rudgear Road in Walnut Creek. The channel's
construction requires the relocation of sanitary sewers in four areas (Holcomb
Court, Creeksi de Drive, Carmel Court, and Newell Avenue). Sani ta ry sewer work
included the permanent relocation of over 1,530 lineal feet of pipe ranging in
size from 6-inch to 10-inch dianeter and the installation of a new 30-foot deep
twin barrel 8- inchsi phon, various manhole and roddi ng structures and
appurtenances, as well as a temporary pump station. Abandonment of the temporary
pump stati on and install ati on of a permanent channel crossi ng w ill be compl eted
under a separate construction contract after the channel work is completed.
Mountai n Cascade, Inc. of San Ramon was issued a Noti ce to Proceed on April 30,
1986, for Areas 1 (Holcomb Court), 3 (Creekside Drive), and 4 (Carmel Court). The
Notice to Proceed for Area 2 (Newell Avenue) was not issued until May 27, 1986
after the del ivery date of the Di stri ct- furni shed speci al si phon sewer pi pe was
fixed. The contract completion dates were July 31, 1986 for Area 3; August 7,
1986 for Area 2; August 21, 1986 for Area 1, and August 29, 1986 for Area 4. All
contract work was substanti ally compl eted on or before the specif ic contract
compl eti on dates. It is appropri ate to accept the contract work at th is time. A
detailed accounting of the project cost will be provided to the Board at the time
of proj ect closeout.
RECOMMENDATION: Accept the contract work for construction of the San Ramon Creek
ByPass Channel Sewer Relocation Project in Walnut Creek <District Project 4046)
and authorize the fil ing of the Noti ce of Compl eti on.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
--rA (
1302.A.9/85 TAT
Rg,K
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
~
.
Centrh. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 1
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
September 4, 1986
NO.
V.
CONSENT CALENDAR 6
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZE $8,300 FROM THE SEWER CONSTRUCTION FUND FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION OF FOUR NEW MANHOLES IN THE DISTRICT'S
COLLECTION SYSTEM
DATE
September 1, 1986
TYPE OF ACTION
Authorize Funds
SUBMITTED BY
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
Jim Coe, Senior Engineer
Collection System Operations
ISSUE: Capital funds are needed to construct four new manholes.
BAa<GROUND: Four high maintenance sewer lines are currently maintained using
hand-powered equipment because there are no manholes to allow the use of power
operated equipment. The new manholes would allow the use of more efficient power
operated maintenance equipment. The new manholes would be located:
PROPOSED NEW DISTRICT MANHOLES
10 El Toyonal, Orinda
37 Via Farallon, Orinda
22 El Toyonal, Orinda
107 Gil Blas Rd., Danville
The total cost of the District labor and materials to construct the manholes would
be $8,300. The labor cost savings will payback this investment in six years at
current interest rates.
RECOIENDATION: Authorize $8,300 from the Sewer Construction Fund for the
construction of four new manholes by the District forces.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
\/.(...-
JAL
~-'---""~'-'-'-'~--'--~-----~'-"-._'.'..""-'"'-''--''...,.__..._.._~-_.~---,---_.._,...__.~---_._~- .'.,-.-,.,...--.,.---..--.---..---.,-- _.~,.."".,_....------
.
Centra.. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE OF 1
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
September 4, 1986
NO. v.
CONSENT CALENDAR 7
SUBJECT
DATE
August 22, 1986
AUTHORIZATION FOR BETTY GALE TO ATTEND A SEMINAR ENTITLED
"CONTROLLING TRAVEL AND EXPENSE"
TYPE OF ACTION
AUTHORIZE ATTENDANCE
SUBMITTED BY
Betty Gale, Executive Secretary
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
Administrative
ISSUE: Board authorization is required for staff attendance at seminars when the
cost exceeds $500.
BACKGROUND: With the ever increasing issues which affect the District and the
inherent increase in travel and expenses to attend to them, the need for controlling
these costs has become apparent. There is presently no central point within the
District for obtaining information regarding the most efficient and economical
method of making travel arrangements.
Inasmuch as the Executive Secretary makes travel arrangements for the General Manager-
Chief Engineer, Deputy Chief Engineer, Deputy General Manager, and members of the
Board of Directors, it would be appropriate that this position be the resource
center for District travel information.
The proposed seminar is designed for travel managers of companies whose employees
travel frequently and covers some of the following key topics:
o Travel policy: the key to managing and controlling travel expense
o Today's travel industry - deregulation...ARC...travel industry vendors
o Reducing airfares -- corporate plan...traveler commitment...frequent flyer
programs
o Travel industry automation -- reservation systems...accounting systems...
STP...reports...on-line access
o Travel agents -- types...selection...reports...consolidation...control
o In-house control of travel expenses
o Negotiating hotel and car rental rates
o Payment methods
o Travel publications
o Current issues and problems in the travel industry
Although funds were not specified in the 1986-87 Central Services budget, there are
currently sufficient funds in the Administrative Department budget to cover this
expense.
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize Betty Gale to attend the seminar entitled "Controlling
Travel and Expense" on November 6 and 7, 1986, in San Francisco at a cost of $595.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
~1~7:.
1302/1.-9/85
.
Centr&. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 1
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
September 4, 1986
NO.
v. CONSENT CALENDAR 8
AUTHORIZE A THREE MONTH MEDICAL LEAVE OF ABSENCE FOR
MICHAEL PARKINSON, MAINTENANCE CREW LEADER, EFFECTIVE
SEPTEMBER 7, 1986
DATE
August 29, 1986
TYPE OF ACTION
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZE LEAV E
SUBMITTED BY
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
John Larson, Manager
Collection System Operations
ISSUE: Board Authorization is required for a medical leave of absence.
BACKGROUND: Michael Parkinson has been off work since September 18, 1985 due to a
medical condition. During this time, he has exhausted his accumulated sick,
vacation, and earned overtime leave. Mr. Parkinson has recently appl ied for
retirement, but requires a medical leave of absence until his retirement
application is processed. A medical leave of absence is requested for three
months effective September 7, 1986.
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize a three month medical leave of absence for Michael
Parkinson, Maintenance Crew Leader, effective September 7, 1986.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
EPT./DIV.
CF
.
Centrc..Contra Costa Sanitar) District
-BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 5
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
September 4. 1986
NO.
VI.
ADMINISTRATIVE
1
SUBJECT
RECEIVE THE DEFERRED COMPENSATION PLAN ADVISORY
COMMITTEE ANNUAL REPORT FOR 1985-1986
DATE
August 26. 1986
TYPE OF ACTION
RECEIVE ANNUAL
REPORT
SUBMITTED BY
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
Walter N. Funasaki. Finance Officer
Administrative/Finance & Accounting
ISSUE: The Di strict's Deferred Compensati on Pl an Advisory Committee has
prepared its annual report to the Board of Directors and District participants.
BACKGROUND: The Board of Directors approved the establishment of the Committee in
January 1982. The scope of activities of the Committee includes the submission of
an annual report to the Board of Directors and District participants. The annual
report of the Committee for 1985-1986 is submitted herewith.
RECOMMENDATION: Receive and consider the 1985-1986 annual report of the Deferred
Compensation Plan Advisory Committee.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
..PM
~~.
1302,0.9/85 WN F
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
DEFERRED COMPENSATION PlAN ADVISORY COMMITTEE ANNUAL REPORT
FOR 1985-1986
Introduction
The Deferred Compensation Plan Advisory
Board of Directors to facilitate the
District's Deferred Compensation Plan.
activities encompass the following:
Committee was established by the
internal administration of the
The scope of the Committee's
o Establish internal District administrative procedures within the
provisions of the Deferred Compensation Plan document.
o Educate participants regarding the Plan provisions by issuing a
handbook which summarizes the Deferred Compensation Plan, and
responding to queries from participants.
o Review accountability by the Plan Administrator and respond to
participants' queries regarding accuracy or propriety of account
balances.
o Review participants' requests for emergency withdrawal of funds.
o Review investment performance of the Deferred Compensation Plan on
an annual basis.
Committee Accomplishments
The following activities were completed by the Deferred Compensation Plan
Advisory Committee during April 1985 through June 1986.
o Internal District Administrative Procedures The Committee
completed its review of other deferred compensation plans in order
to evaluate the competitive standing of the existing plan
administered by Hartford Variable Annuities Life Insurance Company.
The review encompassed twelve proposed plans, and an alternative to
the existing plan proposed by Hartford. A report on the results of
the review was presented to the Board of Directors in May 1986, with
the Committee's recommendation to retain the present Hartford
program and to add Great Western Savings as a companion program.
The Board approved the Committee's recommendati on, and the Great
Western program was integrated as a companion program in June 1986.
Internal administrative procedures were revised to accommodate the
add iti on of the compan i on program. Procedu res were estab 1 i shed to
effect the transfer of accounts from one program to the other.
o Educati on of Parti ci pants - Group presentati ons by Hartford and
Great Western representatives were completed in June 1986 to inform
participants of the features and fee structure of the new Great
Western program, as well as those of the existing Hartford program.
Participants were permitted to change from one program to the other
1
in the month of June, and henceforth, during the quarterly
enrollment months.
Hartford and Great Western representatives will be available on a
designated day each month to assist participants by providing
information and responding to questions.
o Review accountability by Hartford Variable Annuities Life Insurance
Company - There were several participant queries regarding account
accuracy which were promptly and satisfactorily resolved.
o Review requests for emergency withdrawals Three qualifying
emergency withdrawal requests were reviewed by the Committee and
submitted to the Board of Directors for approval.
o Review investment performance - A summary which presents the
investment performance of the Hartford program for the calendar year
1985 and the first six months of 1986 is provided on Attachment I.
Current Committee Activities
The Committee is currently involved in the following major activities:
o The Committee is closely monitoring the conversion to the companion
program environment to ensure that participants are provided
sufficient information to enable selecting between the two
programs, and that participants' decisions on program selection and
investment options are accurately executed.
o A new Deferred Compensati on Pl an handbook is bei ng prepared for
future distribution to each participant. The handbook explains the
Deferred Compensation Plan and summarizes the features and fee
structure of the Hartford and Great Western programs. An attachment
will be provided showing: the interest rates being paid on the
Fixed Interest Account for the Hartford and Great Western programs;
the current Social Security wage limit and rate that are used to
determine the District's contribution to the plan; and the current
Deferred Compensation Plan Advisory Committee Members.
Conclusion
During the period April 1985 through June 1986, the Committee has
addressed all of the activities included in its scope of
responsibilities. This has been achieved through the conscientious
efforts of all of the Committee members.
The performance of Hartford in administering the Deferred Compensation
Plan during this period is considered to be satisfactory.
The investment performance of the Hartford program during the calendar
year ended December 31, 1985 for stocks and bonds exceeded the general
market, as measured by the Dow Jones indexes; however, as measured by the
2
Standard and Poor's 500 stock index and the Shearson Lehman bond index.
the investments sl ightly underperformed the general market. Interest
earned on fixed interest accounts was higher than prevail ing short-term
rates. as measured by the average yields on gO-Day Treasury Bills.
Committee Members:
~ 'fu '2;:;..~'
Walter unasaki
Ken Harrison
~1 a-_~__, ~~
Maria I 0
Ben Netto
Harriette Stahl
3
x x
... CD Q)
"0 "0
+> Xc XC
C CD'" CD...
CD "0 "0
E ....0 C"O ....0 C"O
J:: "'0 ...c "'0 ...c
u -"" 0 -"" 0
:l '- "0 CD '- ~CD
+>11I C ' +>11I
+> III '- OC 11I'- ~;
C ::JO CD.., ::JO
.... "00 E .... "00 E
.... ca.. OJ:: .... ca.. OJ::
- ... NCD in ... NCD
X CD "" ~ X "" ~
~ .,!. III III CD .,!. III III
CD "0 !C "0 CD"g CD C
CD C C '- og CD C c'- gg
u... >. 0.., u... >. 0..,
c .., ..,"0 ..,'- C .., ..,"0 ..,s..
ICI+> 0 c .., ..,+> 0 c ..,
E~ I !~ !~ E~ I !~ 8~
0 0
0'- 0\ oen oen o '- 0\ oen
.... .., .... ..,
'-2: '-2:
CD ,... ,...0 ,...0 a? I'f'l ,...N co 10
a.. 0: 0:'"': ~~ .... I'f'l CO 00\
. . . . .
III ,... ,...~ ""~ III I'f'l NO COo.
J:: NI'f'l ~N J:: NN
+> -v-- --v-- +>"0 - -.,--
C C '-
a. "0 00
'- 2: ....
0 10 "" ~ +> CO I'f'l 0
N .... ~ CO ~ 10'- CO ~ I'f'l
~ +> . . . .., . .
'- 0 0\ 0\ ::z: .... \0 ""
.., ~ N ~ ~
\0 ::z:
CO
~~ ~~ j~
tl~ 0 "" :g I ~I ~ \0 "" ~I
s.= I'f'l I'f'l ,... ,...
~ 0 ~ "" ~ N
IIIC .. .. CD '- .. .. ..
... I.L. W CD'- N "" N ~~ CO 0\ ~
~a::Z >ICI CO N ..,. ~ 10
en~~ CW I'f'l N ... N ~
...
...
Ot-O III III
>-~~ : CD
.>. CD . >.
i jfj I.L. CD.... I.L. CD....
>'-CD >'-CD
t-en CD CCD::J CDCCD::J
... w en > +>.... 0\ ,... > +>.... ..,. ....
i>F!: - ....'-.., ~ ~ - ....'-.., N N
enZ +>> 0..,> +>> 0..,> . .
~i~ .., ::J .., ::J
'- Md '- Md
+> +>
III UI
enEtx - -
8 :;: C N ,... C N 10
- ~I ~ ~ - ~I ,... 10
c!o ! 0\ ~ -6 ,... 0
.. .. ..
~"'i "" ~ < N ~
!c
~en"" >. "" 0 ~ >. 0 N 0\
zco &1: ~ CD ..,. I'f'l 0 &1: ~ CD ,... 0 N
~~~ "" ~ ..,. ~ ,... ""
..,CD::J::J .. .. .. "'CD::J::J .. .. ..
'-+>>8.... CO ..,. "" ~f8';ij ~ ..,. N
~8i CD '- .., "" "" 0 CO \0 ""
>..,~> ,... CO ..,. >..,u> ..,. ~ ....
Zo~ <::J .. <::J< .. ..
~w d I'f'l d .... ~
12~ C C
0 0
~jfj - -
~g +> +>
UI ::J III ::J
+>> .D I'f'l N "" I ~I +> .D ~ ~ I'f'l I ~~
CM- . . . ~ M i: . .
::J '- .... CO ,... I'f'l 0\ ,...
8 t: ,... ~ 8 t: ,... ~
~ - ~ -
0 0
~ ~
,... "" 0\ ~ CO lQ CO ~
CD I'f'l ..,. 0 !l ,... 0 ~
::J ,... ..,. "" ~ \0 N ~
,.. ~I .. .. .. ,.. ~I .. .. ..
.., ~ 0 0\ .., ..,. ~ \0 N
> ~ ~ > ~ 0 "" ,...
~ 0 ..,. \0 N .... N
.. .. .. .. ..
..,. .... .... .... \0
l~ ,.. l~ ,..
.., ..,
'- 8 '- oX
! "0 ! 8 "0
C C
CD +> cB CD +> cB
(!J en (!J en
18
0\
....
III ~
~ ..
....
C I'f'l UI ....
"0 j "0 J::
0 '- 0 +>> ..
- .! - C 0
'- CD '- :i"01'f'l
CD >"0 B l.
a.. .~ X -8 !
~&5! -C::J
cnw.,
.
Centra. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF
NO.
VI!.
ENGINEERING
2
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
SUBJECT AUTHORIZE l1-IE GENERAL MAN~ER-Q-fIEF ENGINEER TO
EXEaJTE AN ~REEMENT WITH J(}fN CAROllO ENGINEERS FOR THE
DESIGN OF THE DEWATERING SYSTEM IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT; AN
AMENDMENT WITH TRC ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS, INC., FOR
ODOR CONTROL EVALUATIONS; AND AUTHORIZE $329,546 FROM
THE SEWER CONSTRUCTION FUND
DATE
AUTHORIZE ~REE~NT
AUTHORIZE AMENDMENT
AUTHORIZE FUNDS
Bert Michalcz k, Senior En ineer
SUBMITTED BY
ISSUE: Approval is required for the General Manager-Chief Engineer to execute an
Agreement with John Carollo Engineers for the Design of the Dewatering System
Improvements Proj ect, as well as an amendment with TRC Env i ronmental Consul tants,
Inc. for odor control evaluations in conjunction with the dewatering project.
Sewer construction funds are required for the design phase of the project.
BACKGROJND: The Treatment Plant requires facilities capable of dewatering sludge
produced by 45 mi 11 ion gallons per day average dry weather flow. To do th is, new
horizontal dewatering centrifuges will be installed to increase capacity and to
replace the existing vertical units. This work, together with modifications to
various support systems, is described in detail in Attachment A and is the subject
of the Dewatering System Improvements Project.
John Carollo Engineers, in conjunction with District staff, have completed the
predesi gn of the Dew ateri ng System Improvements Proj ect and f i na 1 desi gn efforts
can now be started. John Carollo Engineers is recommended as the firm to undertake
the final design based on their familiarity with the project and their satisfactory
performance during predesign. As part of the final design, John Carollo Engineers
will participate in odor control evaluations, prepare plans and specifications, and
eval uate bi ds.
The final design effort will include a full scale confirmation of the capacity of
the existing odor control unit serving the dewatering facilities coupled with pilot
scale testing of an odor control unit using newer technology as described in
Attachment A. In order to properly conduct odor removal testing, the services of
TRC Environmental Consultants, Inc. will be utilized to quantify odor removal. The
work on thi s aspect of the proj ect w ill be coordi nated with the overall odor study
being undertaken by TRC under the direction of the Plant Operations Department.
An agreement has been negoti ated with John Caroll 0 Engi neers for desi gn serv ices
with a cost cei 1 i ng of $605,000 and an amendment has been negoti ated with TRC
Environmental Consultants, Inc. for services related to odor control evaluations
for $28,000. Both documents are structured on an hourly rate times a multipl ier
ba s is.
This project was once part of the Stage 5B Project but was subsequently deferred
because of grant funding compl ications and the need to address other higher
priority work, such as the Incinerator Repairs and Modifications Project.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
DRW
RAB
.~~.
R GER J. DOLAN
INI0tffYYl7D1V.
1302A.9/85 BlM
()~tJ
SUBJECT AUTHORIZE THE GENERAl MANPGER-CHIEF ENGINEER TO
EXEQJTE AN AGREEMENT WITH J(}lN CAROLLO ENGINEERS FOR THE
DESIGN OF THE DEWATERING SYSTEM IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT; AN
AMENDMENT WITH TRC ENV IRON MEN TAl CONSULTANTS, INC., FOR
ODOR CONTROL EVAlUATIONS; AND AUTHORIZE $329,546 FROM
E SE E T TI
POSITION
PAPER
PAGE
DATE
OF
The total estimated cost through compl et1 on of detail ed des1 gn 1 s $1,064,000.
After subtract1 ng prev 10usly authorized expenses of $734,454, an authorization of
$329,546 is required as shOtln in Attachment B. The predes1gn level estimate for
the overall project cost is $9,769,000 as presented in Attachment C. Future Board
authorizations will be required to award bids for prepurchase of centrifuges and to
award bids for the construction contract. In addition, staff may recommend field
testing of centrifuges prior to the prepurchase as discussed in Attachment A under
"Centrifuges." Field testing of centrifuges would be an increase in project scope
and would require an additional authorization of funds.
The project is included in the 1986 Capital Improvement Plan under the title
"Sludge Dewatering Fac1l1t1es."
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize the General Manager-Chief Engineer to execute an
Agreement with John Carollo Engineers for the design of the Dewatering System
Improvements Project and an amendment with TRC Environmental Consultants, Inc., for
odor control evaluations. Authorize $329,546 from the Sewer Construction Fund.
13028-9/85
Page 3 of 7
ATTAOiMENT A
Proj ect Descr i pt ion
The goal of the Dewatering System Improvements Project is to provide facilities
capable of dewatering sludge produced by 45 million gallons per day average dry
weather flOt/. The heart of the system will be four new horizontal solid bowl
dewatering centrifuges. Modifications will also be required to ancillary facilities
such as the odor control, polymer feed, and sludge blending. Provisions for
emergency sludge storage will be incorporated into the blending system. In
addition, facilities will be provided to convey dewatered sludge cake to the
multiple hearth furnaces. Figure 1 of this attachment shOt/s the proposed layout of
the centrifuges. The next several sections describe each of the component systems.
CEN TR I FUG ES
Sludge dewatering is required before incineration because excessively wet sludge
will not burn properly. Four horizontal solid bowl centrifuges will be used to
dewater the sludge produced by the primary clarifiers and the new Dissolved Air
Flotation Thickeners. This sludge will be fed to the centrifuges with a solids
content of approximately 3.5 percent. The centrifuge will capture 95 percent of
the solids and in the process produce a dry sludge cake with a solids content of 22
percent. The dewatered sludge cake will then be conveyed to the multiple hearth
furnaces. The units will be located in the southeast bay of the Furnace Building
on the third floor.
The centrifuges will be prepurchased by the District after a formal
prequalification phase. In this phase detailed technical information will be
solicited from the centrifuge manufacturers. The information will be evaluated by
District staff together with John Carollo Engineers to determine that the equipment
meets the criteria established by the District. If so, a machine will be
considered to be prequalified. The next step may be field testing of the
prequalified units to ascertain their ability to dewater the District's sludge.
The deci si on as to whether or not to fiel d test w ill be predi cated upon the
information gathered during prequalification related to the manufacturer's
experience at other facilities. If field testing is undertaken, additional funding
will be requested. The final phase of centrifuge procurement will be a formal bid
among the prequal ified suppliers with award being made to the lOt/est bidder. Due
to the long lead time for fabrication, the units will be prepurchased by the
District.
POLYMER FEED
A new polymer feed system will be designed. Polymer is fed to the sl udge to make
it dewater better. The system will be capable of providing both liquid and dry
polymer conditioning of sludge fed to the centrifuges at doses of up to 20
pounds/ton; operati ng dosages are expected to be approximately 8 pounds/ton. An
evaluation of the components of the existing polymer system was made to determine
which could be used in the new system. Several components can be incorporated into
the new facilities. Most notably, the presently used dry polymer feeders will be
incorporated into the new system. The facilities will be located on the third
floor of the Solids Conditioning Building in the west wing.
Page 4 of 7
ODOR CONTROL
Existing Odor Control Unit No.3 (OQJ 3) located west of the sea will not be
capable of adequately treating the 18,200 scfm of foul air containing up to 130
parts per million of hydrogen sulfide generated by the systems associated with
dewatering. The exhaust from OQJ 3 must be essentially odor free. The
requirements will be more precisely defined as part of the upcoming odor control
study bei ng undertaken by the Pl ant. In addi ti on, the exact capaci ty of OaJ 3 is
unknown at the present time. A technology now exi sts which competes with "packed
bed" scrubbers such as OQJ 3. The new tech nol ogy is categori zed as a "spray
tower." The ability of the new technology to meet the applicable requirements as
well as the capacity of OaJ 3 will be determined during field testing conducted at
the start of the design phase in conjunction with TRC Environmental, Incol John
Carollo Engineers, and District staff. If either technology is unable to achieve
the required performance, then a two-stage scrubbing system util izing the most
economic of the two scrubber types tested at the first stage unit will be used.
Because of the present uncertainty, it is conservatively pl anned that two new
two-stage scrubbers will be designed and installed.
SLUOOE BLENDING
Sludge blending, or equalization, is the process of "smoothing out" the
characteristics of a sludge stream that has a varying flow rate and composition.
This process is required to ensure consistent operation of the dewatering
centrifuges so that the incinerators will operate efficiently with optimal air
pollution performance. Blending and equal ization is accompl ished by providing a
tank with a 1 arge enough vol ume to dampen the fl uctuati ng sl udge feed rates and
composi ti ons.
The tank will be equipped with a pumped mixing system to physically blend the two
sl udge streams. The present centrate thickener will be converted to the primary
blending tank. The present blending tank will be modified slightly to serve as an
emergency sludge storage tank. The modifications to the present blending tank will
consist of the removal of the existing thickener mechanism, the installation of
interconnecting piping, and minor structural improvements. The various
improvements represent Phase 2 of the modi fi cati on to the bl endi ng equi pment
started under the Stage 5B proj ect.
CAKE CONVEYANCE
The dewatered sl udge cake produced by the centrifuges must be transported to the
furnaces. Presently thi s is done usi ng short 1 engths of screw conveyors from the
existing vertical centrifuges. Because of the different configuration of the new
horizontal units, they cannot be located immedi ately adj acent to the furnaces.
Considering the distance to be conveyed, the dewatered cake will be pumped from the
location of the centrifuges to the furnaces with a hydraul ically-driven
reciprocating piston pump. These pumps are similar to units used to pump concrete.
These types of pumps can efficiently and economically convey the dewatered cake.
Four such units will be required, one serving each centrifuge.
Page 5 of 7
i -~-----
" -~._---_._-_..-
1'-- , "/ I ",,~/ il "/
~~-+:-:-'- ~-t-~ "~I --'~r /~
! ! " ' " i!
...~ -.--u------6'l-
[J C
,I SYSTEM . C::J 0 :J
- -r-r- -- Oc- ! - ·
FUTURE CENTRIFUGES
11
i I -.J :1
' . I,
di" ~
~ I!
."2 'I
II
--QI,
t '~
I!II-
MUL T1PLE
- HEA-RTH
FURNACES
ELEV A TION AT 3RD FLOOR
SOLIDS CONDITIONING BUILDING
CENTRIFUGE
(TYP)
CENTRIFUGE
SUPPORT
PLATFORM
~
i
19'6" __
1
-
~
FIGURE 1
Page 6 of 7
ATTADUENT B
COST SUtl4ARY
FOR lHE DESIGN OF lHE
DEWATERING SYSTEM IMPROYEJENTS
PROJ ECT
1. Consultant Expenditures During Design
a. John Carollo Engineers $ 605,000
b. TRC Environmental Consultants, Inc. 28,000
c. Total Consultant Expenditures $ 633,000
2. District Expenditures During Design
a. Proj ect Management $ 38,900
b. Engineering 64,600
c. Printing/Advertising 9,500
d. Total District Expenditures $ 113,000
3. Conti ngency 56,000 (a)
4. Prior Expenditures
a. Predesign $ 147,000
b. Centrifuge Manufacturer
Prequal ification 115,000
c. Total Prior Expenditures $ 262,000
5. Total Estimated Expenditures $1,064,000
6. Less Funds Previously Authorized 734,454)
7. Total Additional Authorization Requested $ 329,546
(a) If necessary, District staff will use this contingency to issue contract change
orders to John Carollo Engineers or TRe Environmental Consultants, Inc. to
expand their Scopes of Work or to fund additional force account work.
Page 7 of 7
ATTADlMENT C
TOTAL PROJ ECT COST ESTIMATE
Predesign Level (a)
Total Estimated Proj ect Cost
$ 147,000
115,000
802,000 (b)
602,000
(c)
1,850,000
5,516,000
737,000
$9,769,000
1. Predesign Phase
2. Centrifuge Manufacturer Prequalification
3. Design Phase
4. Construction Management
5. Field Testing of Centrifuges
6. Prepurchase of Centrifuges
7. Construction Cost
8. Construction Contingency (10% of Lines Nos. 6 and 7)
(a) Plus or minus 20 percent accuracy
(b) Sum of lines 1, 2, and 3 on Attachment B
(c) Not proposed at this time; if a decision is made to recommend field testing, an
authorization will be requested. The best estimate for this work is
approximately $100,000.
.
Centra. Contra Costa Sanitar~ District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 3
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
Se tember 4 1986
NO.
VIII.
TREATMENT PLANT
1
SUBJECT
DATE
NJTHORIZE $32,400 FROM THE SEWER CONSTRUCTION FUND FOR
THE DESIGN OF THE REPLACEMENT OF ODOR CONTRa.. UNIT
NO. 1 - DISTRICT FROJECT NO. 10015
TYPE OF ACTION
AUTHORIZE FUNDS
SUBMITTED BY
William E. Brennan,
Plant 0 erations Division Mana er
INITIATING DEPT.lDIV.
Operati ons/
Plant 0 erations De artment
ISSUE: Approval is requested fran the Board of Di rectors to authorize sewer
construction funds for the preparation of design documents for a replacement for Odor
Control Unit No.1.
BACKGROUND: The barscreen roan ventil ati on system is exhausted through an odor
control unit provided as part of the SA project. This unit has reached the end of
its useful life and must be replaced.
It is req uested that the Board of Di rectors authorize funds for preparati on of
contract documents for the prepurchase of an odor control uni t and eq ui pment
installation contract. Further funds will be requested at the award of these
contracts. The project is described in detail in Attachment A, and a cost estimate
for the design is included as Attachment B.
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize $32,400 fran the Sewer Constructi on Fund for the
preparation of design documents for the replacement for Odor Control Unit No.1.
INITIATING DEPT.lDIV.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
2'G
1302A.9/85 WEB
CWB
ATTAa;MENT A
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
At present, all the exhaust air fram the barscreen roam is treated by Odor
Control Unit No.1. This piece of equipment was provided as part of the
SA plant expansion. This unit is subject to a corrosive environment and
thus has reached the end of its useful life and must be replaced.
In addi ti on to the eq ui pment repl acement, Pl ant Operati ons Depar1ment
staff plans to modify the supply and exhaust air distribution system
within the barscreen roam. This will improve the circulation of air
through the roam, provide a better working environment, and decrease the
volume of foul air to be treated by the odor control unit.
The major part of the design for this project will be performed by
Di stri ct staff with the structural desi gn to be done by an outsi de
consultant.
A pil ot test of a modern odor control uni t for th is proj ect has al ready
been conducted on an authorization of the General Manager-Chief Engineer.
This will assist in the preparation of the prepurchase specifications.
The preliminary cost estimate for this project is $390,000.
ATTAa-lMENT B
DESIGN COST ESTIMATE
Descri pti on
Consultant
Associated Industrial Designers
Odor Control Unit Testing
Force Account
Total Funds Required
Prey ious GM-CE Authorization
Total Funds Requested
Cost
$ 5,000
$ 10,000
$ 27,400
$ 42,400
$ 10,000
$ 32,400
.
Centra. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 4
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
NO.
SUBJECT
AUTI-lORIZE GENERAL MANJlGER-a-IIEF ENGINEER TO EXEaJTE A CX>N-
TRACT WITH REALOOIC AND AUTI-lORIZE $35,000 FROM TI-lE SEWER
CX>NSTRUCTION FUND TO PLAN AND ESTIMATE TI-lE CX>NVERSION OF
TI-lE TREATMENT PLANT'S MODCX>MP CX>NTROL SYSTEM SOFTWARE TO
UTILIZE TI-lE LATEST MODCX>MP OPERATING SYSTEM
TYPE OF ACTION
AUTI-lORIZE GM-CE TO
EXECUTE JlGREEMENT,
AND JlJJTI-lORIZE FUNDS
i neer
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
Plant Operations Department/
o erations
ISSUE: Board approval is requested for the General Manager-Chief Engineer to
execute a contract with ReaLogic (a canputer software consultant specializing in
ModComp systems) and to authorize $35,000 from sewer construction funds to plan and
estimate the conversion of the Treatment Plant's ModComp computer operating system.
BACKGROUND: The Pl ant's process control computer system, a ModComp computer system
with custom software, was supplied as part of the 5A Pl ant expansion in 1972. The
"Operator-Machine" interface is unique and still superior in spite of computer
advances si nce its i ncepti on. The exi sti ng operati ng system is not supported by
ModComp. Revisions to this system will be needed as part of a project to expand the
capacity of the muliplexor control units.
An overall approach to the updati ng of the pl ant process control computer was
developed in 1984 and built upon the earlier work of pl ant staff and outsi de
consul tants. The al ternatives were either to pl an a total repl acement of hardware
and software or to gradually upgrade subsystems of the exi sti ng process control
system. Since the subsystem upgrade approach afforded better control of changes in
a very sensitive area of plant operation and was estimated to be more economical, it
was decided to proceed with a detailed study.
The first major changes in hardware have al ready occurred with the upgrading of the
central processing units with modern ModComp Classic lIs which are more reliable and
have the capacity for one million words of memory. This change required modest
revisions in our operating system software. Other hardware upgrades have included
the operator CRTs, the offline user CRTs, the two graphic printer/plotters, and 10
megabyte di sks. The system has reached an operati ng stage where it has become
necessary to begin implementing major changes in software.
The first three phases of this project have been identified thus far. Phase I is
the conversion study for which funds are now requested. This study includes
planning the conversions and a manpower and cost estimate for the actual conversion.
A more detailed description of Phase I is included as Attachment A. Phase II is the
actual conversion of the operating system and all Plant programs. Phase III is the
study for the tel emetry control hardware repl acement, i. e., the repl acement of the
multiplexor control units. Phase III is a long-term project.
REVIEWED AND ECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
WEB
CWB
./CHIEF ENG.
~ tv.-
ROGER J. DOLAN
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
AJ
,/
1302A.9/85 GW
W€~
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZE GENERAL MANAGER-CHIEF ENGINEER TO EXEaJTE A OON-
TRACT WITH REJ\L.OOIC AND AUlHORIZE $35,000 FROM lHE SEWER
OONSTRUCTION FUND FOR A STUDY TO PLAN AND ESTIMATE lHE
OONVERSION OF THE lREATMENT PLANT'S MODOOMP OONlROL SYSTEM
SOFTWARE TO UTILIZE THE LATEST tvDDCOMP OPERATING SYSTEM
POSITION PAPER
PAGE
DATE
2
OF
4
August 29, 1986
Neither a schedule, technology, or cost can be determined at present. This project
is not delineated in the Capital Improvement Plan as it is an emerging project.
ReaLogic has been selected to perform the Phase I work. The personnel of ReaLogic
have the necessary famili arity with ModComp operati ng systems and have al ready
provided several days of training to the Plant Operations Department Computer
Section staff. ReaLogic's offices are in Sacramento, and their staff is currently
working with the Sacramento Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant on a ModComp
computer system. ReaLogic will provide services for the Phase I conversion study
via a lump sum contract for $26,000.
REOOMMENDATION: Authorize the General Manager-Chief Engineer to execute a contract
for professional services with ReaLogic Software Consultants and authorize $35,000
from sewer construction funds for planning and estimating conversion of Plant
control software to utilize the current ModComp operating system.
--------.
13028-9/85
ATTAa-tMENT A
MAX IV CONVERSION STUDY - PHASE I
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The current operati ng system used for the Pl ant process control computer
system is known as MAX III. This software was developed in the mid-1970's
by ModComp and is limited to 64,000 words of memory. ModComp ceased
upgrading this system in 1981 and superseded it with MAX IV. The lack of
factory support, the need for the eventual conversion of the Plant
multiplexor units to a new technology, and the replacement of the
multiplexor control units with software utilizing the larger central
processing unit memory, creates the need for updating the ModComp operating
system with MAX IV.
Si nce there are a 1 arge nlll1ber of custan programs for the Pl ant's uniq ue
process control system (over 200), the conversion to MAX IV requires more
than just obtaining the MAX IV system. The use of MAX IV will require an
intensive effort to make all Plant programs compatible with the new
operating system. The MAX IV operating system was acquired from ReaLogic as
part of a training course given to introduce the differences between MAX III
and MAX IV. The purpose of this authorization is to make funds available
for the Phase I study. Once the conversion project is defined, the Plant
Computer Secti on staff can pl an Phase II. At th i s time it is estimated
that it will req ui re approximately two man-years of work to make the
conversi on compl ete usi ng both in-house staff and outsi de consul tants for
software assistance.
ATTACHMENT B
MAX IV CONVERSION STUDY - PHASE I
August 29, 1986
Cost Summary
Description Funds Requested
Consultant
REALOOIC
Protostar
Contingencies at 10 percent
$26,000
2,000
2,800
Di str i ct Forces
Process Management
Process Control
200
4,000
Total Authorization
$35,000
.
Centrc.._ Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 3
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
Se tember 4, 1986
NO.
VII 1.
TREATMENT PLANT 3
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZATION OF $10,400 FROM THE SEWER CONSlRUCTION
FUND FOR THE INSTALLATION CONlRACT, FORCE ACCOUNT LPBOR,
AND CONTINGENCY FOR DSP 10017 - FURNACE ID FAN VARIABLE
FREQUENCY [RIVES
DATE
TYPE OF ACTION
AUTHORIZE FUNDS
SUBMITTED BY
David Reindl,
Assistant En ineer
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
Plant Operations Department/
Maintenance En ineerin
ISSUE: The Board of Directors must approve expenditures from the Sewer Construction
Fund for capi tal proj ects.
BACKGROUND: On July 3, 1986, the Board of Di rectors authorized the purchase of two
200 hp variable frequency drives for the furnace induced draft fans. The equipment
is scheduled for delivery in mid-October. District staff has received proposals from
two electrical contractors for the installation of the units. The lowest bid is
from Beard Electric Company for $8,002. In order to be eligible for a P.G.& E.
energy savings rebate of approximately $17,000, the installation of both units must
be completed by December 1, 1986. Additional funds are requested at this time to
complete the project. The requested funds will cover installation costs, District
force account labor, and testing the equipment. A breakdown of costs is shown on
Attachment 1. Authorizati on of $10,400 increases the total proj ect budget to
$72,218. The original engineer's estimate for the project was $81,000.
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize $10,400 from the Sewer Construction Fund for the
installation contract, force account labor, and contingency.
130211.9/85
DR
J,~.
/I-&-
JB
INITIATING DEPT./DIV.
~~
ATTAa-lMENT I
FURNACE ID FAN
VARIABLE FR81UENCY DRIVE INSTALLATION
Installation Contract (Beard Electric) $ 8,002
District Forces (Electrical/Instrument Shops) $ 1,000
Photo-Electric Tachometer
$ 450
$ 9,452
Contingency
948
TOTAL
$10,400
ATTAa-tMENT II
V JlSUABLE FREQUENCY [RIVE
BUDGET
Total Proj ect Estimated Cost
Previous Authorization
(July 3, 1986)
Funds Requested At This Time
$72,218
$61,818
$10,400
.
Centrh. Contra Costa Sanitar) District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PAGE 1 OF 1
POSITION
PAPER
BOARD MEETING OF
September 4, 1986
NO.
IX.
LEGAL/LITIGATION
1
SUBJECT
DENIAL OF $2,460 CLAIM FOR PROPERTY DAMAGE
FROM DON YOUNG FORD
DATE
August 27, 1986
TYPE OF ACTION
DENY CLAIM
SUS.r[tRD ~~ Campbell
Administrative Operations Manager
INITIAIlt)lG .DEfT.tlDIV. t. /
"om' n s ra we
Risk Management and Safety
ISSUE: The District has received a claim for $2,460 from Don Young Ford for
alleged damage to underground telephone cables as a result of the installation of a
new sewer line by CCCSD.
BACKGROUND: Underground telephone cables, located on Car1back Avenue in Walnut
Creek, were severed on May 20, 1986, during a District sewer line project. Prior
to starting work the District had notified Underground Services Alert and obtained
an Encroachment Permit from the City of Walnut Creek. Notices of the intended
construction were hand delivered to Don Young Ford on May 9. Pacific Bell, as a
member of Underground Services Alert, marks the location of all of its facilities
to prevent accidental damage. However, they did not mark the location of an
underground conduit in this case because their records showed this conduit to be
abandoned. Don Young Ford apparently has been using it for a private telephone
line unbeknownst to any of the public agencies or utility companies. The City of
Walnut Creek has no record of issuing a permit for this private telephone line to
be placed in the public street.
Both the District and Pacific Bell incurred costs as the result of this incident.
Pacific Bell, not knowing who was responsible, made the initial repairs to put the
telephone system back in service immediately after the incident. The District
incurred additional costs totaling $1,000 while awaiting the initial repairs and
providing access to the trench for final repairs by Don Young Ford's contractor.
Don Young Ford was informed of the nature and extent of the District's proposed
underground constructi on pri or to the i niti ati on of the proj ect, but di d not
disclose that they had a private telephone line crossing the street, nor did they
mark its location in a way that would prevent its accidental excavation. The
correct Di strict procedures were followed in thi s case. Accordi ng1 y, the c1 aim
should be denied.
RECOMMENDATION: Deny the Don Young Ford claim for $2,460 against the District and
refer to staff for further action as necessary.
REVIEWED AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
INIT!~TING eT.lDIV
JEC
PM