HomeMy WebLinkAboutAGENDA BACKUP 02-20-97
~-
{,entral Contra Costa Sanitary ilisbict
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
illllllllllllllll!!!llIll1llllillllllli BOARD MEFnF;;uary 20, 1997
:;:;:;:::;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:::;:;:;:;:;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::~:::::::::::;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:::;:::;:;:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::;:::::;:::;
Page 1 of 2
NO.
4.
CONSENT CALENDAR d.
February 10, 1997
TYPE OF ACTION
ACCEPT ANNEXATION FOR PROCESSING
DATE
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZATION FOR P.A. 97-1 (DANVILLE) TO BE INCLUDED IN A FUTURE FORMAL ANNEXATION TO
THE DISTRICT
SUBMITTED BY
Dennis Hall, Associate Engineer
INIT1A TING DEPT iUtV
Engineering Department/Infrastructure Division
Parcel
No.
Area
Owner/Address
Parcel No. & Acreage
Donald R. Parker
170 Willow Drive
Danville, CA 94526
216-171-006 (0.40 AC)
Remarks
Lead Agency
97-1
Danville
(98D3)
Existing house with a
failing septic system; must
connect to the public
sewer system. Project is
exempt from CEOA.
CCCSD
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize P.A. 97-1 to be included in a future formal annexation.
'NIT1ATI{~)Y0ENTiUt~SOD H .
lit!
/11
DH
JSM
RAB
H:\PP\ANNX97-1.DH
8/6/96
~
~
~
~
~
(Co
~
~
~
~
~~
~
o
~
~
,
"
,
~D~/"'" ~.
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
P.A. 97-1
~.
C~ntral Contra Costa Sanitar, District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
..:.11111111.1'.'11111111111111111111: BOARD MEEnF~;uary 20, 1997
Page 1 of 6
NO.
4.
CONSENT CALENDAR e.
DATE
TYPE OF ACTION
February 14, 1997
ACCEPT GRANTS OF EASEMENT
SUBJ ECT
ACCEPT GRANTS OF EASEMENT FROM FIVE PROPERTY OWNERS FOR THE SOUTH ORINDA SEWER
IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT, D.P. 4928
SUBMITTED BY
Ricardo Hernandez, Engineering Assistant
INITIATING DEPTIDIV
Engineering Department/Infrastructure Division
ISSUE: Board approval is required to accept Grants of Easement.
BACKGROUND: The design of the South Orinda Sewer Improvements Project, D.P. 4928, requires the
acquisition of permanent sanitary sewer easements and temporary construction easements through private
properties along the alignment. Appraisals have been prepared by a licensed real estate appraiser
(Associated Right of Way Services) hired by the District to determine the value of the proposed easements.
Agreements for permanent easements have been reached with five private property owners (see attached
maps) and negotiations are continuing for additional easements.
Based on recent comparable sales of similar land and the impact of the proposed easements on the value
of the existing lands, the just compensation amounts for these properties are as follows.
Patricia K. Andersson, Inc.
One Kendra Corporation
Toshiyuki and Kayoko Nakamura
Loewen Family Trust
Catherine L. Lambert
184 Moraga Way
120 Moraga Way
194 Moraga Way
202 Moraga Way
116 Moraga Way
$1,711.00
500.00
1,531 .00
1,997.00
2,504.00
Funds for the purchase of the easements are included in the authorized budget for the South Orinda Sewer
Improvements Project, D.P. 4928.
On November 7, 1996, the District Board of Directors determined that this project was exempt from the
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). A Notice of Exemption was filed with the Contra Costa County
Clerk on November 8, 1996.
RECOMMENDATION: Accept the Grants of Easement from Patricia K. Andersson Inc., One Kendra
Corporation, Toshiyuki Nakamura and Kayoko Nakamura, the Loewen Family Trust, and Catherine L.
Lambert, and authorize staff to record said Grants of Easement with Contra Costa County Recorder.
~ AND RECOMMENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
hP
RAB
ID-G L \C:\INFRA \PP\EASEMENT. RH
EX~i'~l~~I~
RIGHT OF :.;, [f!:; :::\" ~'fi::;ffOr SEWER
, .. '"'~~~'X ,M. ~ "U .., n
! f~!~~\\\,\:"=.t .:'I,:~:.,"".:'1;~i! fit!
"3j
c:.
V)
M
t"'I
:ti~
~')::.~
~~Zs:.
~~C)C)
~~V)";:J;)
~ '" -... ')::.
~CJ~(;)
a";:J;)\:Xl')::.
\ ~ 0)
%~~"t
-...~~-<.
~
-<.
"3j
c:.
V)
-I
SCALE:
1 "=40'
l"-
N
U.
o
I'l
~
0:
I-
W
W
J:
III
~
o
30
0:
IXl
N
~ DRAYM BY:
~
j;: SCALE:
C)
-'
w
I
20 40
PSC
1 "=40'
~
o
'P
-y
Q
-y
AREA -
........
\:Xl
~
~""""""":l>~
~~zC)
\ \ ~";:J;)
........C)~":l>
~"'V)(;)
aO)V)":l>
\~CJ
a::z~
a,--, )>.
~ -<.
CENTERLINE - SEWER
ALIGNMENT
,&?~
~
~
\
........
~
C)
\
C)
C)
~
CHECKED BY:
mOMAS BRO.:
DATE:
ELG
NOV. 27, 1997
co. ASSMT. NO.:
273-140-002
~
0)
~
\
C)
~
C)
\
C)
........
~
~
-y
.J-
~
0)
~
\
C)
~
C)
\
C)
~
,IS'
\~.
\~.
'\~
\
~
\.~.
'\fA
\ 0,>.
\ -:..J
\
71A7
\
JOB NO.:
4928
PARCEL NO.:
20
.-
EXHI8I:~~ ;:"::""'8. "
. ..'." 1\ ....
. .... . ,. ,-\,~~J: .. .'
. ..; i /.::" : -.~1t\~ :.:--;.:..:. .
OF.;.;~A.y:\~iti~~;!.f'or SEWER
1.....6....,~"..........-,~. ....,......,.-,
~ ~ ' ~, ! 1 ' 1 r":., : "; ";. ;"t "; "I": 0: 01 t f f ! f ! :0 ( .
RIGHT
~
o
-::0
y
Q
y
SCALE:
1"=40'
CENTERLINE - SEWER
ALIGNMENT
.....
N
\'V
~
\
C)
'"
-...
\
C)
-...
~
l!>
OJ
o
~
0::
...
1:::1
:x:
VI
FEE T
~ ~~
3:' 0 10 20
0::
GO
N
:g DRAWN BY:
I
-40
CHECKED BY:
lliOMAS BRO.:
PSC
ELG
NOV. 27, 1997
71A6
~
~ SCALE:
Cl
...J
W
DATE:
CO. ASSMT. NO.:
273-051-001
1 "=40'
___,._______m._'_'..__.__,_._,_._~___.~._.,._,___.,_.~_"._..,____~'"_~.'^_.,.__________,_____,__..._._.___...,_..___.___,._. .,.."'___".__...'"'.____,________...,__"_'".__._.__~"
%
y
,l..
\
\~
\~
\~~
\~
\ ~
'\
JOB NO.:
PARCEL NO.:
~
.->
\~
\~
\~
,:..;I
4928
11
RIGHT
EX~~~~':l\I!!~
. i.... f, ; : : -:::.~~ :-:-:~.:. .
OF' w,(Jl'X' ..:..". ';'Y4il\;t..:}f" ':or SEWER
1/\ .... ~.'. I\lt.'...
.." ".,,0.....' .~ .......... ....... ..... . ,.... ~,' ~".:..
! 1: 1: 1: 1: ~ 1: 1: 1: " 1: r ':' :'J";" '''1' OJ'1 ' { ( . ~ I
,-1--
\~.
\~.
,.?
\~
\.
\
CENTERUNE - SEWER
AUGNMENT
~~
~
.->
'0
'-.
<b
~
AREA =
~
:li?
r; -t.- ~
~""9:~
~~ ~ f- "Y':
''':. u>- ~)7'~ ~
-v~ '-. 0 c..,
~ ',...:'> '->::;oc"', ~ ~
" , ,- 3<"': r- ....... .......
);~ ~ ~~ <:::> r r ,.J.....
C <,~,'.. '-. ~
,oe:,...' ... S> ~
'~~ -<::,~ ~
~'-..... ' -...
__A
I'
C'I
"-
o
""
~
0::
I-
W
W
:I:
1Il
~
~.->
~ <.9~
~~
r-;.~~
<.9 C'I
~~ ~ :0)7'0
~ .-> % )7'
.-> ~ ~~
'0 ~ <: )7",.J.....
" ~<'
o 'S/ .A
~ ~C-
~....A
~b
SCALE:
1"=40'
~
o
~
0::
CIO
C'I
~ DRA'M'l BY:
W
..J
iL: SCALE:
C>
..J
....
CHECKED BY:
THOMAS BRO.:
PSC
1 "=40'
ELG
73A1
DATE:
NOV. 27, 1997
CO. ASSMT. NO.:
273-140-012
~6"'
\9
'-.
o
'0
'-.
S>
:li?
JOB NO.:
4928
PARCEL NO.:
21
EXHIBt::F;<;~B. v
. . :<',' -s~~}J .'.'.,. .
. i:/f/:::": :::::~~~\~ ::::::::: :
RIGHT ~F~'~;~i~X:;~j~!;f~'f~~ r !SEWER
/
/
/
/
/
/ ~
/ <-
/ o~
ll:J
<-
~
'"
, "V
"'(xr~.~
, u6'
~6'~
'It--
~
~~
<.9
"
~
?
"-
<=b
<9
~
O-'P
AlQ
AI
Jt,
AI)-
AREA - 705 S.F.:f:
CEN1ERLlNE - SEWER
ALIGNMENT
~o
,...
~
~<'~
~~ ~ Y"'~ Y"'Q
~ ~ "% Y'"
~ <.9 <:<' ~
~ <..:5' Y"',
,,:srs:, .-
C>~
q,
t'-
N
~ SCALE:
co
~
a::
I-
w
w
:x:
en
FEE T
~ ~-
3i 0 10 20
a::
to
N
:g DRAWN BY:
I
40
THOMAS BRO.:
CHECKED BY:
73A1
ELG
NOV. 27, 1997
CO. ASSMT. NO.:
273-152-008
~
r;: SCALE:
C>
.J
""
PSC
1 "=40'
DATE:
~
<.9
"
o~
?
"
00
~
JOB NO.:
4928
PARCEL NO.:
23
RIGHT
EXHIBIT"":'~"'BV .
. . "'f'_\;~~ ..:.:,
p,f,\,~\'~WI~.,~r~,~, ,SEWER
z
-...
-...
~ ~
~~ ~
~O) ~
~~r-C)
\O)")>.?;)
~C)~~
~?;)t"t\")>.
\~
%\0 ~
~~ "'"
~~
c.~
~rj
~~
~*'
\
<A
~
~
~
~
~~ S:.
\..t~r-C)
\ \ ")>.?;)
C)~<")>.
~~'=><0
~~t"t\")>.
\\0
C)~ ~
~~ )>.
\0 "'"
AREA = 1,144 S.F.:I::
-...
-...
0)
~~ ~
~\Or-~
~O)")>.CJ
\ \ S:.?;)
~~~")>.
~~~~
\~-\-.c:;:.
~~ ~
C) "'"
SCALE:
C)
<.
t"t\
-..,
x.~
~-t>..
~~BS:.
~~?;)C)
\ \ ")>.?;)
.~ C) ")>.
~\OC)<0
-..,0) C)")>.
\\O:J;J
~\)-.c:;:.
<::)~C)~
<::) '--' ?;)
")>."'"
:::j
C)
<.
,...
N
"'-
o
co
o
~
0::
I-
~
~
~ ~-
'" 0 10 20
0::
CO
N
3: DRAWN BY:
CHECKED BY:
THOMAS BRO.:
ELG
NOV. 27, 1997
psc
1 "=40'
DATE:
~
iO: SCALE:
C>
-'
W
CO. ASSMT. NO.:
273-042-010
~
o
jO
y
(;)
y
71A6
JOB NO.:
PARCEL NO.:
%.
y
...l..
\s
\~
\~~
~
:/
\
4928
10
~.
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
:::::i5..II.:.:.:::::.:.::::i..iI::i5':i.lIne~II@@@:: BOARD MEETING OF
:::::m:II.":,,:t:,,::::BIII::mm']t::.,,,,:t,,;:;::::::II February 20, 1997
Page 1 of
5
NO.
5.
HEARINGS a.
DATE
TYPE OF ACTION
February 14, 1997
CONDUCT HEARING - AUTHORIZE RESOLUTION
SUBJECT
HOLD A HEARING AND ADOPT A RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY FOR THE PURPOSE OF INITIATING
EMINENT DOMAIN PROCEEDINGS FOR ACQUISITION OF PUBLIC SEWER EASEMENTS FOR THE SOUTH
ORINDA SEWER IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT, D.P. 4928
SUBMITTED BY
Tad J. Pilecki, Senior Engineer
INITIATING DEPTIDIV
Engineering Department/Infrastructure Division
ISSUE: A hearing must be conducted and a Resolution of Necessity must be adopted to initiate eminent
domain proceedings for acquisition of public easements.
BACKGROUND: The 1986 Collection System Master Plan identified numerous sewers with inadequate wet
weather hydraulic capacity in the Orinda area. Wet weather overflows occur frequently along the Moraga
Way trunk sewer during the rainy season. Four wet weather overflows occurred in the Orinda area during
the recent heavy rains. Overflows are of particular concern since the watershed drains into San Pablo
Reservoir, a drinking water supply for East Bay Municipal Utility District. Some Orinda sewers also
experience periodic dry weather overflows due to root and grease blockages and structural deficiencies (off-
set joints, damaged pipe, etc.). The majority of the collection system is over forty years old and requires
extensive maintenance to keep it functioning. The South Orinda Sewer Improvements Project will address
many of these problems and has been the subject of several recent Board reports and decisions.
In evaluating how to address the overflow problems in Moraga Way, staff concluded that the geographic
limitations precluded a new alignment that could be constructed utilizing open cut construction without
seriously impacting traffic in Moraga Way. Further evaluation showed that even a microtunneling operation
could not be utilized within the Moraga Way right-of-way without seriously impacting traffic. After careful
evaluation, staff determined that a microtunneling operation with bore/receiving pits located on private
property could be utilized to minimize traffic impacts. Staff evaluated feasible locations for bore/receiving
pit sites based on required staging areas, proximity of improvements and San Pablo Creek, major trees,
feasible push lengths, overall cost effectiveness, and the desire to keep the alignment accessible from above
if the tunneling equipment should get stuck. These requirements resulted in only one combination of
bore/receiving pits that would work. This alternative, although more expensive, will result in significantly
less impact on Moraga Way than other alternatives. It will, however, result in protracted construction
impacts on the properties where bore/receiving pits are located.
~ AM) RE~ FOR BOARD ACTION
JSM
RAB
/II(
ffj
ID-GL \C:\INFRA \PP\49 28HEAR. T JP
....i.i!:.:.:.!.:I,I:.IIIIIIII!I.lllllt:i41:!.I:III~I.1.1.1:1,1:1 DATE February 14, 1997
I
Page 2 of 5
SUBJECT
HOLD A HEARING AND ADOPT A RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY FOR THE PURPOSE OF INITIATING
EMINENT DOMAIN PROCEEDINGS FOR ACQUISITION OF PUBLIC SEWER EASEMENTS FOR THE SOUTH
ORINDA SEWER IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT, D.P. 4928
District staff is in the process of completing the design for Phase 1 of the South Orinda area which includes
8,000 linear feet of microtunneling in Moraga Way. To reduce the traffic impacts on Moraga Way, the pits
for the microtunneling operations have been located on private property. The selected alignment resulted in
the need for permanent and temporary easements across 34 properties. District staff has been negotiating
for these easements. Staff has been unable to obtain property rights from owners of six properties. These
are Breed A-operties; Kent E. and Barbara J. Hagen; Wallace M. and Kathryn C. Francis, Trustees; John and
Mary McDonnel Trust; Corinne A. Lampke; and Betty N. Yee, Trustee.
Each of these property owners has received an offer of just compensation based on an appraisal prepared by
a licensed real estate appraiser. District staff and Associated Right of Way Services have continued
negotiating with these property owners in the hope of reaching an agreement. It is now appropriate to
proceed with the adoption of a Resolution of Necessity to obtain needed property rights to provide for a timely
start of construction of the project. A-ior to adopting a Resolution of Necessity, the District must conduct a
hearing to receive input from the property owners. A-operty owners have been notified at least 16 days in
advance of the hearing, as required by law.
If the Board adopts a Resolution of Necessity and authorizes the filing of condemnation complaints and the
deposit of probable amounts of compensation, the District may apply to the Court for Orders For Immediate
Possession. Even if the Court were to grant such an order, it is possible, depending upon Court rulings, that
it might take ninety days or more after the issuance of the order for the District to obtain possession. Given
these time restrictions it is advisable that the Board take action regarding the Resolution of Necessity at this
time.
Specific details of the eminent domain issues will be provided to the Board in closed session. Staff will
provide a brief presentation to the Board on the route selection and eminent domain issues in open session.
On November 7, 1996, the District Board of Directors determined that this project was exempt from the
California Environmental Quality Act (CECA). A Notice of Exemption was filed with the Contra Costa County
Clerk on November 8, 1996.
RECOMMENDATION: Conduct a hearing to receive input from property owners on the following issues:
1 . Whether the public interest and necessity require the project;
2. Whether the project is planned or located in the manner that will be most compatible with the greatest
public good and the least private injury; and
3. Whether the property rights sought to be acquired are necessary for the project.
After the conclusion of the hearing, adopt the attached Resolution of Necessity to acquire permanent and
temporary easements by eminent domain for the South Orinda Sewer Improvements A-oject, District A-oject
4928. The resolution will also authorize the filing of eminent domain actions, the deposit of amounts of
probable compensation, and the application for Orders For Immediate Possession.
ID-GL \C:\INFRA \PP\49 28HEAR. T JP
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY FOR THE ACQUISITION
OF PUBLIC EASEMENTS FOR SEWER PURPOSES
AND AUTHORIZING EMINENT DOMAIN PROCEEDINGS
WHEREAS, Pursuant to the State of California Health and Safety Code Sections 6514
and 6512, the Central Contra Costa Sanitary District is empowered to acquire sewer line
easements for public use, to wit, for purposes related to wastewater collection and transport,
and the District intends to construct, own, and operate sewers as part of its South Orinda Sewer
Improvements, D.P. 4928; and
WHEREAS, the Central Contra Costa Sanitary District has identified the need to acquire
permanent and temporary publiC sewer line easements more particularly described in
Attachment "A," attached hereto for said purposes, and said easements are located within an
incorporated area of Orinda, Contra Costa County, State of California; and
WHEREAS, on February 3, 1997, the District gave mailed notice as required by law of
the hearing on this Resolution to the following property owners: Richard F. and Joanne Lande;
Breed Properties; Kent E. and Barbara J. Hagen; Wallace M. and Kathryn C. Francis, Trustees;
John and Mary McDonnel Trust; Corinne A. Lampke; Edward D. and Joy L. Millpointer; Betty
N. Yee, Trustee; Jivendra K. and Patricia I. Kale; and
WHEREAS, said hearing was held on February 20,1997; and
WHEREAS, a timely, written request to appear and be heard was received from certain
property owners; and
WHEREAS, all oral and documentary evidence has been duly considered.
NOW, THEREFORE, the Board of Directors of the Central Contra Costa Sanitary
District, does FIND, DETERMINE, AND RESOLVE as follows:
1. The public interest and necessity require the proposed project for which said
public sewer easements are to be acquired.
2. The subject project is planned and located in the manner which will be most
compatible with the greatest public good and the least private injury;
3. Said public sewer easements are necessary for the proposed project; and
4. The offers required by Government Code Section 7267.2 have been made to the
owners of record of the subject property.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT:
The Counsel for Central Contra Costa Sanitary District, Kenton L. Aim, is hereby
authorized and empowered:
To acquire in the District's name, the above referenced public sewer line easements by
condemnation;
To prepare and prosecute in the District's name, such proceedings in the proper court
as are necessary or appropriate for such acquisition; and
To deposit the probable amount of compensation, based on an appraisal, and to apply
to the appropriate court for orders permitting the District to take immediate possession of and
use said sewer line easements for said public uses and purposes.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 20th day of February 1997, by the District Board of
Directors of the Central Contra Costa Sanitary District by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Members
Members
Members
President of the District Board of the Central Contra
Costa Sanitary District, County of Contra Costa,
State of California
COUNTERSIGNED:
Secretary of the Central Contra Costa
Sanitary District, County of Contra Costa,
State of California
Approved as to form:
District Counsel
C
o
~
.,
u
o
....
;
~... G)
., C G)
~G)u.
8.EG)
E : <<i
G) ., ::l
~ W C7
!!!
C
o
~
.,
U
o
....
...
i1:G)
CG)<<i;
., E ::l G)
EG)g'G)
~U)(I)u.
G)"-
Q.W
U)
U)
G)
~
"C
"C
c(
-
o ~
G) C
E ~
~O
G.
u 0
<<iz
Q.
.r::. G)
o..c ~
Q)-CO
-o'Ot:
,~- ~
_CI)_
Q)o>-
~Et::
00)Q)
"""Co.
,., 0 0
+lcoCi
ex)
....
.....
~
N
o
-
-
Q)
0)
-
.....0)
.....r::.
+I....
_0)
o c
o
E - Q)
COO)
~ .r::. CO
E........
.- a. c
X Q) 0
CO-o':::
E c >-
CO'';: t::
E 0) 0)
o ~ g.
... ...
u.. 0 a.
It)
.....
N
N
...-0
Q) C
C CO
... 0
0_
U..o-o
....COO
CI) 0.. 0
to 0 :>
0) C :>
.r::.._~
....Eo
o to ~
zum
-0
Q)
Q)
...
m
M
-0
CO
o
a:
-0
...
to
.r::.
o
...
o
v
c
Q)
0)
to
:I:
It)
....
>-
~
Q)
a.
o
...
a.
-
o
-
o 0)
... 0)
Q) CO
.... ....
C C
Q) 0
U.:::
...
Q)
C
...
o
o
....
CI)
to >-
Q)....
.r::....
.... Q)
~ a.
o ~
WOo
o
It)
....
....
It)
....
..j
....
OC1)~
E.r::. Q;
....0.
~ 0) 0
E c ...
'x ~ a.
to to '0
E -E c
CO 000
O~'€
.... 0
~.~ a.
Q)........
_Q)CI)Q)
00) tOO)
-O)tO
Eco-5....
o....~c
"'+100
u.. CI) .:::
N
It)
N
....
>-
to
~
to
0)
to
...
o
~
N
.....
....
CI)
'0
C
to
...
u..
C>>
....
ATTACHMENT A
-
o
...
Q)
C
...
o
o
....
CI) >-
to....
Q) ...
.cQ)
....0.
... 0
o ...
ZOo
v
C>>
C>>
-
_0
0....
E ~
~ E
.S 0)
X C
to 0
E"ii
to.r::.
0....0)
....g-g>
~-ot:
0) c 0
~.- '-
N....-
+I~~
- ...
EO ~
oN 0
&t+lCi
ex)
ex)
N
~
M
>-
CO
~
CO
0)
to
...
o
~
<0
C>>
....
Q)
C
C
o
C
o
~
N
N
"ii
0)
c
o
to >-
....t::
0) 0) Q)
0)0.0)
-Oto
0.......
M a. c
+I - 0
0':::
v
It)
C>>
~
....
-
o
E-
~ 0
E to
'x 0)
to C
E~
to to
o-EQ)
....0.0)
.... Q) to
Q) -0 ....
Q) C
-co
N'- ...
....-
....Q)>-
+10)....
- ...
Em ~
o .... 0
&t+lCi
M
N
ex)
....
>-
to
~
to
0)
to
...
o
~
V
o
N
0)
~
a.
E
to
....J
V
N
-
o
,...
en
-
..,.
-
N
...
Q)
C
...
o
o
....
CI)>-
to....
Q) ...
.c Q)
....00
... 0
o ...
ZOo
o
o
M
....
-
0_
o
E....
~ ...
E ~
'x 0)
E a
to to
o.r::. Q)
....~O)
.... Q) to
Q) -0 ....
Q) C
-co
ex) '';: .:::
....Q)>-
+I.f?t::
EO ~
oN 0
&t+lCi
v
....
<0
>-
to
~
CO
0)
to
...
o
~
ex)
o
M
Q)
Q)
>-
l=
~
0(
o
z
a:
o
II)
>=
0(
-,
-::
:I:
-
0(
a:
u.
~
It)
M
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
February 4, 1997
File: 4928.5.1.5
CERTIFIED MAIL - P 276-422-235
ROGERJ. DOLAN
General Manager
Chief Engineer
KENTON L AIM
Counselfor the District
(510) 938-1430
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ON THE RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY REGARDING
CONDEMNATION OF PERMANENT AND TEMPORARY EASEMENTS
APN: 273-042-008- 110 MORAGA WAY, ORINDA
APN: 273-042-009
JOYCE E. MURPHY
Secretary of the District
Richard F. Lande
Joanne Lande
110 Moraga Way
Orinda, CA 94563
Dear Richard and Joanne Lande:
Mr. Rick Hernandez has informed me that you have issues related to the latest right-of-way
agreement which you wanted to discuss with Tad Pilecki. Since Mr. Pilecki is on vacation, Mr.
Hernandez is attempting to contact you to discuss these issues. The South Orinda Project schedule
includes a hearing on February 20, 1997, at which time the District's Board of Directors will
consider taking legal action to acquire easements from those property owners who have not as yet
signed right-of-way agreements. Since you have not signed an agreement, it is necessary to send
you this letter to comply with the notice requirements for the hearing. If the issues you recently
raised are resolved before the hearing, you may disregard this notice. I thank you for your
cooperation to date, and I will be contacting Mr. Hernandez to check on the progress of resolving
your issues.
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District (District) is in the process of completing the design for Phase
1 of the South Orinda Sewer Improvements Project. The project is required to reduce the potential
for both dry and wet weather overflow of sewage into San Pablo Creek, which flows into San Pablo
Reservoir, an East Bay Municipal Utility District drinking water supply. A portion of the South Orinda
Sewer Improvements Project includes 8,000 linear feet of microtunneling in Moraga Way. To reduce
traffic impacts on Moraga Way, the pits for microtunneling operations have been located on private
property.
The Phase 1 South Orinda Project is scheduled to be advertised for competitive bidding in March
1997, in order to take full advantage of the summer construction season. Either the District's right-
of-way agents, Associated Right of Way Services, or the District's right-of-way person, Rick
Hernandez, has contacted you or attempted to contact you to present an offer of just compensation.
Additionally, we have previously provided you the Statement of and Summary of Basis for the
amount established as Just Compensation. To date the District has been unable to secure the
property rights across your property required for the project. To ensure timely possession of the
property rights, the District is moving toward commencing eminent domain proceedings. This is
ID-G L \C:\INFRA \DP\49 28\Lande. L2
@ Recycled Paper
Richard F. Lande
Joanne Lande
Page 2
February 4, 1997
necessary at this time due to the notification/time requirements associated with the eminent domain
process. The eminent domain process is essentially one by which the District asks the court to
provide the District property rights for a public project, in exchange for compensation determined
by a court or jury.
The first part of this process is the adoption of a resolution of necessity by the District's Board. The
law requires that certain parties be notified by the District concerning the resolution of necessity
hearing. Please be advised that a public hearing is scheduled at the District Board Room at the
above address on February 20, 1997, at 3 p.m. The purpose of this hearing is to consider
information as further identified below. It is intended that a resolution of necessity regarding
condemnation to acquire easements across your property will be adopted at the meeting on
February 20.
You are hereby notified that you have the right to appear at the hearing and be heard concerning
the issues set forth in the California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1240.030, which are:
· whether the public interest and necessity require the District's project;
· whether the project is planned or located in the manner that will be most compatible
with the greatest public good and the least private injury; and
· whether the subject easements are necessary for the project.
In order to appear and be heard at the hearing, you must file with the Secretary of the District,
Joyce Murphy, within fifteen (15) days after the date of mailing of this notice, a written request to
appear and be heard. Failure to do so will result in waiver of your right to appear and be heard.
The District's negotiators, Associated Right of Way Services or Rick Hernandez, will continue to
discuss relevant issues with you concurrent with the District taking steps to obtain rights to enter
your property. It remains our desire to reach an agreement with you on compensation for the
property rights required for the District's project.
Sincerely,
a1j~f~
1a75. McCoy/"
Infrastructure Division Manager
JSM/vh
cc: M. Cornelius
R. Hernandez
J. Murphy
T. Pilecki
B. Tannenbaum (ARWS)
ID-GL \C:\INFRA \DPl492B\Lande. L2
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
February 3, 1997
File: 4928.5.1.5
CERTIFIED MAIL - P 621 909 648
ROGER J. DOLAN
General Manager
Chief Engineer
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ON THE RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY
REGARDING CONDEMNATION OF PERMANENT AND TEMPORARY
EASEMENTS
APN: 273-140-091 - 172 MORAGA WAY, ORINDA
KENTON L. AIM
Counselfor the District
(510) 938-1430
JOYCE E. MURPHY
Secretary of the District
Wallace M. Francis, Trustee
Kathryn C. Francis, Trustee
The Francis 1986 Family Trust
172 Moraga Way
Orinda, CA 94563
Dear Mr. and Ms. Francis:
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District (District) is in the process of completing the design
for Phase 1 of the South Orinda Sewer Improvements Project. The project is required to
reduce the potential for both dry and wet weather overflow of sewage into San Pablo
Creek, which flows into San Pablo Reservoir, an East Bay Municipal Utility District drinking
water supply. A portion of the South Orinda Sewer Improvements Project includes 8,000
linear feet of microtunneling in Moraga Way. To reduce traffic impacts on Moraga Way,
the pits for microtunneling operations have been located on private property.
The Phase 1 South Orinda Project is scheduled to be advertised for competitive bidding
in March 1997, in order to take full advantage of the summer construction season. Either
the District's right-of-way agents, Associated Right of Way Services, or the District's
right-of-way person, Rick Hernandez, has contacted you or attempted to contact you to
present an offer of just compensation. Additionally, we have previously provided you the
Statement of and Summary of Basis for the amount established as Just Compensation.
To date the District has .been unable to secure the property rights across your property
required for the project. To ensure timely possession of the property rights, the District
is moving toward commencing eminent domain proceedings. This is necessary at this
time due to the notification/time requirements associated with the eminent domain
process. The eminent domain process is essentially one by which the District asks the
court to provide the District property rights for a public project, in exchange for
compensation determined by a court or jury.
The first part of this process is the adoption of a resolution of necessity by the District's
Board. The law requires that certain parties be notified by the District concerning the
resolution of necessity hearing. Please be advised that a public hearing is scheduled at
ID-Gl \C:\INFRA \DP\4928\PUBHEAR.NTC
@ Recycled Paper
Wallace M. Francis, Trustee
Kathryn C. Francis, Trustee
Page 2
February 3, 1997
the District Board Room at the above address on February 20, 1997, at 3 p.m. The
purpose of this hearing is to consider information as further identified below. It is
intended that a resolution of necessity regarding condemnation to acquire easements
across your property will be adopted at the meeting on February 20.
You are hereby notified that you have the right to appear at the hearing and be heard
concerning the issues set forth in the California Code of Civil Procedure Section
1240.030, which are:
· whether the public interest and necessity require the District's project;
· whether the project is planned or located in the manner that will be most
compatible with the greatest public good and the least private injury; and
· whether the subject easements are necessary for the project.
In order to appear and be heard at the hearing, you must file with the Secretary of the
District, Joyce Murphy, within fifteen (15) days after the date of mailing of this notice,
a written request to appear and be heard. Failure to do so will result in waiver of your
right to appear and be heard.
The District's negotiators, Associated Right of Way Services or Rick Hernandez, will
continue to discuss relevant issues with you concurrent with the District taking steps to
obtain rights to enter your property. It remains our desire to reach an agreement with you
on compensation for the property rights required for the District's project.
Please feel free to contact the undersigned at (510) 229-7273 or Rick Hernandez at (510)
229-7132.
Sin~ fJ~'
~J'~Cki
Senior Engineer
T JP/vh
cc: M. Cornelius
R. Hernandez
J. McCoy
J. Murphy
B. Tannenbaum (ARWS)
ID-Gl\C:\INFRA \DP\49 28\PIJBHEAR. NTC
Breed Properties - Certified Mail P 621 909 654
Brookwood Road
P. O. Box 20490
Oakland, CA 94620
273-021-010
cc: Tom Cranmer, Cranmer Associates, Inc., 1511 Treat Blvd., Walnut Creek, CA 94598
Kent E. Hagen - Certified Mail P 621 909 649
Barbara J. Hagen
4 Orchard Road
P. O. Box 2143
Orinda, CA 94563
269-032-009
Wallace M. Francis, Trustee - Certified Mail P 621 909 648
Kathryn C. Francis, Trustee
The Francis 1986 Family Trust
172 Moraga Way
Orinda, CA 94563
273-140-001
John and Mary McDonnell Trust - Certified Mail P 621 909 650
196 Moraga Way
28 Honey Hill Road
Orinda, CA 94563
273-140-011
cc: Dan McDonnel, 196 Moraga Way, Orinda, CA 94563
Margaret M. Twomey, 28 Honey Hill Road, Orinda, CA 94563
Corinne A. Lampke - Certified Mail P 621 909 651
204 Moraga Way
Orinda, CA 94563
273-152-009
Edward D. Millpointer - Certified Mail P 621 909 652
Joy L. Millpointer
300 Moraga Way
Orinda, CA 94563
272-050-052
Betty N. Yee, Trustee - Certified Mail P 621 909 653
Betty N. Yee Revocable Trust
308 Moraga Way
Orinda, CA 94563
272-050-030
Jivendra K. Kale - Certified Mail P 621 909 655
Patricia I. Kale
208 Moraga Way
Orinda, CA 94563
273-152-010
C:\INFRAIDP\4928\CONDEMN9.LST 2/4197
_._-- -"-----~-,._._..,._--_."~.~_._.._~------~_.__._-~_.._..-..-.-.---. '.._-.-"~ , -
PROPERTIES SUBJECT TO EMINENT DOMAIN ACTION
Breed Property
Payless Shopping Center Parking Lot
Hagan
4 Orchard Road
Gable - Postlewait
156 Moraga Way
Francis
172 Moraga Way
McDonnell Nursery
196 Moraga Way
Lampke
204 Moraga Way
Sugimura
21 6 Moraga Way
Millpointer
300 Moraga Way
Yee
308 Moraga Way
IO-GL \C:\INFRA \OP\49 2B\EMINENT. SUB
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
11111111111:::::::::::<:::::::<::lll;;;.II'I:I'IIIIIII: BOAA> MErn~:brUary 20, 1997
Page 1 of 3
NO.
8.
ENGINEERING a.
DATE
TYPE OF ACTION
February 14, 1997
AUTHORIZE FUNDS
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZE $120,000 FROM THE COLLECTION SYSTEM PROGRAM CONTINGENCY ACCOUNT FOR
ENGINEERING AND INTERIM REPAIRS TO THE COLLECTION SYSTEM AT VARIOUS LOCATIONS,
1996-97 STORM DAMAGE PROJECT, DP 5205
SUBMITTED BY
Curtis W. Swanson, Principal Engineer
INITIATING DEPT,tltV
Engineering Department/Infrastructure Division
)SSW;: Authorization by the Board of Directors is required for allocations from the Collection System Program
Contingency Account in amounts greater than $25,000.
BACKGROUND: Severe winter storms in late December 1996 and early January 1997 have caused damage
to the collection system at five known locations. Interim repairs are being made to prevent further damage.
Additional storm damage may be discovered or occur as the winter progresses.
An allocation of $120,000 is requested to cover the total cost of the interim repairs and to perform
engineering and design of long-term repairs to four of the five damaged sites. Long-term repairs at the other
site will be accomplished by other parties. Construction of the permanent repairs will occur during summer
and early fall 1997. Engineering and design will be accomplished by District staff and outside geotechnical
consultants. Interim repairs have been or are being made by District Collection System Operations
Department crews and construction contractors. A summary of the estimated costs is shown in
Attachment 1.
The cost of interim repairs is estimated to be $53,000 with a total cost of $145,000, including engineering
for long-term repairs. These interim repairs were constructed under an emergency authorization confirmed
by the Board of Directors on February 6, 1997. An initial contingency allocation of $25,000 was approved
by the General Manager-Chief Engineer in early January to begin this work. An additional $120,000 is
required to cover this total cost.
The interim repair work performed under the Board's emergency authorization was essentially complete on
February 13, 1997. Therefore, authorization to expend funds in amounts greater than $10,000 without
competitive bidding is no longer needed. The follow-on work will be competitively bid unless additional
emergencies arise.
This project is not included in the 1996-97 Capital Improvement Budget (CIB). There are adequate funds
for this project in the Collection System Program Contingency Account of the CIB.
INITIATING DEP~~
(~,
II t1v
RAB
li11:illlliilli111.1.lli:i:'!:"IRI:::::::.',! DATE February 14,1997
I
Page 2 of 3
SUBJECT
AUTHORIZE $120,000 FROM THE COLLECTION SYSTEM PROGRAM CONTINGENCY ACCOUNT FOR
ENGINEERING AND INTERIM REPAIRS TO THE COLlECTION SYSTEM AT VARIOUS LOCATIONS, 1996-97
STORM DAMAGE PROJECT, DP 5205
Staff has concluded that these projects are exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEOA)
under CEOA Statute Sections 21080(bH2), (3), (4) since they involve emergency repairs to public service
facilities necessary to maintain service; projects which maintain, repair, restore, demolish, or replace facilities
damaged as a result of a disaster in disaster-stricken areas in which a state of emergency has been declared
by the Governor; and specific actions necessary to prevent or mitigate an emergency. The Board of Directors'
approval of these projects will constiMe an independent finding that these projects are exempt from CEOA.
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize the General Manager-Chief Engineer to allocate $120,000 from the Collection
System Program Contingency Account for the 1996-97 Storm Damage Repair Project, DP 5205.
_._-------------~.__.~_.._'".._-
ATTACHMENT 1
1996-97 STORM DAMAGE REPAIRS
DISTRICT PROJECT NO. 5205
COST ESTIMATE/ALLOCATION SUMMARY
SITE/ACTIVITY
ORINDA COUNTRY CLUB
COST ESTIMATE
Interim Repairs
$ 5,000*
17 LOMBARDY LANE. ORINDA
Design/Drafting/Survey
Geotechnical Consultant
Project Management/Legal
Permits, Other Expenses
Interim Repairs
621 AND 627 MINER ROAD. ORINDA
$ 3,000
0
1 ,000
1,000
1 0.000*
$ 15,000
$ 12,000
4,000
3,000
1 ,000
5.000*
$ 25,000
Design/Drafting/Survey
Geotechnical Consultants
Project Management/Legal
Permits/Other Expenses
Interim Repairs
FORMER SACRAMENTO NORTHERN
RAILROAD RIGHT OF WAY. MORAGA
Design/Drafting/Survey
Geotechnical Consultants
Project Management/Legal
Permits, Other Expenses
Interim Repairs
$ 16,000
6,000
8,000
4,000
23.000*
$ 57,000
QUAIL RIDGE ROAD. LAFAYETTE
Design/Drafting/Survey
Geotechnical Consultants
Project Management/Legal
Permits, Other Expenses
Interim Repairs
$ 10,000
4,000
6,000
2,000
10.000*
$32,000
$ 11,000
$145.000
$ 25,000
$120,000
Repair/Design Project Contingency
TOTAL
Less Initial Contingency Allocation
Requested Contingency Allocation
* Interim repairs total $53,000
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS Page 1 of 2
...........................................................
f'II....;::...::.:::.:;;;;;:.::':.:...:::...::......;;:;....;:;;.I....:'::.:;;;;;..::'II.....::r...::::rrmfm BOARD MEETING OF
.~:~:~ :::;:::;:, :::::;' t.:-,- {:~:~', :::::;' : :;-, :~:~:~:~:~:~:~:~:;:~:~ Februar 20 1997
:':::,{,:,:,:,)":::::,:,,,,:,,::,:,{,,:,,:,:,,::,:,:,,:,,::,:",:,:"}:",:"":::,::,:,:,:,)),,,,,: y ,
NO.
9. TREATMENT PLANT a.
DATE
TYPE OF ACTION
February 14, 1997
ACCEPTANCE OF REPORT
SUBJECT
BOARD ACCEPTANCE OF THE 1996 NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM (NPDES)
REPORT
SUBMITTED BY
Charles W. Batts, Plant Operations Department Manager
INITIATING DEPTtOlV
Plant Operations Department
ISSUE: The Central Contra Costa Sanitary District's (CCCSD) 1996 National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System (NPDES) and Collection System Overflow Monitoring Program Report has been prepared for
submission to the California Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB), San Francisco Bay Section.
The annual report, which is sent separately to the Board of Directors, is presented for its information and
acceptance.
BACKGROUND: Treatment Plant -- There was a total of 16,763 million gallons of wastewater treated for
an average daily flow of 45.8 million gallons. This flow is about 4 percent higher than the 1995 average
of 44 million gallons per day and is due mainly to the wet winter of 1996. The treatment plant produced
an effluent with an annual average carbonaceous biochemical oxygen demand (CBOD) and total suspended
solids (TSS) concentration of 6 mg/L each. This is markedly lower than our NPDES permit standards of 25
mg/L and 30 mg/L, respectively. The CBOD and TSS removal efficiency for the plant averaged 96 percent
each. Solids disposal during this year involved the incineration of dewatered sludge in the District's multiple-
hearth furnaces. Approximately 3,876 tons of furnace ash was produced. Of this, about 10 percent was
taken to Vasco Road Landfill, and the remainder was used as the foundation layer for the final cover of
Colusa County Landfill. The ash met regulatory requirements for final disposal throughout the year.
The Treatment Plant met all effluent requirements throughout the year except for 20 non-zero chlorine
residual exceedences and one pH limit exceedence. This compliance record was achieved as normal
treatment plant operation was disrupted to accommodate the following construction projects: Ultraviolet
Disinfection Facility, Aeration Basin Selector, and Aeration Basin Improvements.
The number of chlorine residual limit exceedence events are 23 percent less than 1995. Only eight of these
events exceeded the RWQCB's concentration threshold, and none exceeded the duration threshold. The
RWQCB established the concentration/duration threshold approach for chlorine residual violations because
they realized how difficult it is to have no chlorine residual all of the time; the threshold approach allows the
RWQCB not to take enforcement action against exceedences below the established threshold.
~ AND F1ECOMVIENDED FOR BOARD ACT10N
INITIATING DEPARTMENTtOIV1Sl0N
5 :\96FINALN\POSP APR.96
...................................... ........ .............................1
::1:::::::1:1:::::1:~1II:::::::::\:::::::::\~1I:::::::::::~:1::::.:::::::::::::::::.::::::::::::t.::::::f:::1i1:1:1:1..::::::::::::.:/::::\:.::::::::::::::::::::::::.::::::::::::::i::::1i:i1:1i1i1!1!OATE
........... .... .. ... ........ . ....... .... .... .. ...........
..................... ........ . .' ..... .... . . ,',', ......... ....... ... . ....... ... ,', .....................
:::::::::::::::::;::::';'::::::::::;';':';';:;::::':".:.::;.:.::::;::.:.;:::;.;.;:;::.:...:.::;::.:.::;:;.:.:.;:;:;:;::.:::.:::::::::.::;:;:;.:.:.:.:.;:;:;:;.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.::;:;.:.::;:;:::::;:;:;:;;;:;;
February 14, 1997
I Page 2 of 2
~\I:lE€f
BOARD ACCEPTANCE OF THE 1996 NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM
(NPDES) REPORT
On December 26, 1996, approximately 7,000 gallons of treated effluent were spilled over IT property due
to a leak in the outfall pipe. This leak occurred when a coupling failed at the outfall riser. The coupling
was replaced, and the leak was stopped within three hours of the first report. This leak caused no
harmful impacts on the receiving water of the pond at the IT site.
Collection System - The District was issued a new NPDES permit on May 25, 1995. The provisions of
the new NPDES permit continued the requirement that the annual Self Monitoring Report cover the
operation of the treatment plant and added the requirement to submit data on the operation of the
collection system.
The District's collection system had 30 overflows over 100 gallons during 1996. Seven of the 30
overflows exceeded 1,000 gallons. The three larger overflows resulted from a pipe failure, the discharge
of water by a contractor, and construction debris in the pipe, respectively. The remaining overflows were
caused by roots and grease deposits in the sewers.
Upon acceptance of this report by the Central Contra Costa Sanitary District Board of Directors, the 1996
Annual Self Monitoring Program Report will be submitted to the California Regional Water Quality Control
Board.
RECOMMENDATION: Acceptance of the 1996 National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System and
Collection System Overflow Monitoring Program Report.
~
Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
'1Iilllllllllllllllllllllllll'III'III BOARD MErn~:~ruary 20, 1997
Page 1 of 7
NO,
10. HUMAN RESOURCES
a.
DATE
lYPE OF ACTION
February 14, 1997
AUTHORIZE STAFFING
SUBJ ECT
CREATE ONE CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR/DESIGNER POSITION (G-67 $3729-$4512); DELETE ONE
CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR POSITION (G-67 $3729-$4512); ADOPT CLASS DESCRIPTION AND
RECLASSIFY CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR ROBERT DRAGON TO CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR/DESIGNER
SUBMITTED BY
Curtis Swanson, Principal Engineer
INIllATING DEPTIOIV
Engineering Department/Infrastructure Division
ISSUE: Board action is required in order to create an authorized staff position, delete a position, adopt a class
description, and reclassify an employee.
BACKGROUND: In October, 1995, Robert Dragon, Construction Inspector, requested a temporary work
reassignment to accommodate a medical condition. As an evaluative test period to do work that would have
had to be contracted out or covered by overtime, Mr. Dragon was reassigned to perform office duties related
to administration of the Sewer Service Charge Program and design of collection system projects. Mr. Dragon
has performed his temporary duties well and with enthusiasm. Staff proposes that Mr. Dragon be reasonably
accommodated by reclassifying him to fill the new position of Construction Inspector/Designer.
Because of economic conditions, the number of private development projects has decreased over the past
several years. In addition, the District has scaled back its Capital Improvement Program. Consequently, the
workload for inspection of private development and District projects had decreased.
During the past three years, the District has moved toward designing all collection system projects with in-
house staff and minimal use of outside engineering consultants. The departure of two engineers and a Senior
Engineering Assistant has hampered the in-house design effort. The addition of the proposed Construction
Inspector/Designer position will increase the District's ability to accomplish in-house design. In addition, the
proposed Construction Inspector/Designer position provides staffing flexibility to react to changes in design and
construction inspection workloads.
The new Construction Inspector/Designer classification has both construction and design elements (see
attached class description). Mr. Dragon has the requisite knowledge and skills to perform the construction
portion of the class. He will attain the required design knowledge and skills through an 18 to 24 month
education program (see attached list of training).
The proposed change will not increase the total number of authorized employees nor the District's labor costs.
Staff has met and conferred with representatives of Local One. The Union supports this reclassification and
waives its rights to an open/promotional recruitment. The Personnel Committee has discussed this matter and
recommends approval.
~
rnF
C :\FILES \PERS MISC\BDRAG ON. PP
9/16/96
_._------"--,._~-_._--,-~--"..----,."----"-_._-,------',---~,._.._--------_.._--
February 14, 1997
Page 2 of 7
SUBJECT
CREATE ONE CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR/DESIGNER POSITION (G-67 $3729-$4512); DELETE ONE
CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR POSITION (G-67 $3729-$4512); ADOPT CLASS DESCRIPTION AND
RECLASSIFY CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR ROBERT DRAGON TO CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR/DESIGNER
RECOMMENDATlON: Create one Construction Inspector/Designer position; delete one Construction Inspector
position; and adopt the Construction Inspector/Designer class description. Reclassify Construction Inspector
Robert Dragon to Construction Inspector/Designer.
CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA
SANITARY DISTRICT
Effective:
Range:
Respirator Class:
2/21/97
G-67
2
CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR/DESIGNER
DEFINITION
Perform inspections and enforce District regulations relating to construction of public and
private sewers; inspect construction work performed on District structures and
appurtenances as assigned; perform technical field and office engineering design work.
DISTINGUISHING CHARACTERISTICS
This is an engineering class which recognizes work requiring design and construction
technical skills and knowledge. Positions assigned to the class of Construction
Inspector/Designer work with a minimum degree of supervision, using established
procedures, guidelines, and District policies. Work may involve routine and some
moderately complex design work, research on a variety of District projects, permit
acquisition, contract administration, and construction inspection.
The use of respiratory equipment (including S.C.B.A.) may be required for this position.
Therefore, the Construction Inspector will be required to be clean shaven for annual fit
tests and for any occasions which requires the use of respiratory equipment to comply
with the District's respiratory program and Cal/OSHA standards.
SUPERVISION RECEIVED AND EXERCISED
General supervision is provided by higher level professional or supervisory personnel.
EXAMPLES OF ESSENTIAL DUTIES - Duties may include, but are not limited to, the
following:
Inspect sanitary sewers, concrete, structural steel, process piping, shoring, storm drains,
and work performed by trades personnel on behalf of the District in the construction,
modification, or repair of District facilities.
Assist project engineer in the areas of cost tracking and control, preparation of
correspondence, change order negotiation, monitoring schedules, project status, and
completion of as-built drawings.
Assess the safety precautions taken on sewer construction sites and enforce District
specifications.
CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT
Constructionlnspector/Designer (Continued)
EXAMPLES OF ESSENTIAL DUTIES
Answer questions and respond to complaints from public or private agencies concerning
sewer problems, location of laterals, and repairs.
Prepare, assemble, and correlate plans and specifications for District projects with project
engineering staff; prepare sketches and diagrams; design sewer collection system
pipelines and other types of projects and construction; prepare cost estimates and
schedules.
Perform routine and moderately difficult design and calculation work relative to District
sewer collection and related facilities in accordance with District procedures.
Perform a variety of data collection and research involving office and field investigations.
Establish and maintain a variety of engineering records, files, and related documents.
Prepare clear and concise data summaries and written reports.
Contact other agencies, developers, and contractors regarding design and construction
of projects.
May assist in project engineering and/or contract administration. Maintain records of
contract work performed on behalf of the District as assigned; ensure that progress
payments are made and that work percentages are in accordance with contracts.
As assigned, perform a variety of materials tests and take soils samples.
Perform related duties as required.
MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS
Knowledae of:
Codes, regulations, specifications, ordinances, and enforcement procedures
applicable to the area of assignment.
Materials, methods, and operations of sewage collection, treatment, and
construction.
Mathematics as it applies to assigned responsibilities.
Methods and techniques of engineering, drafting, and cost estimating.
---,.._-----_._---_._---_._---.-,_._-_._._-~---,---,--.._-------,._._-~~-------------"_._~------"_.
CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT
Construction Inspector/Designer (Continued)
Knowledge of:
Principles and practices of engineering related to design of sewer collection
systems, pumping stations, and related facilities.
Construction practices, procedures, methods, materials, tools, equipment, and
supplies as applicable to the area of assignment.
Safety hazards and appropriate precautions applicable to work assignments.
Use of computers for design, drawing, drafting, and surveying applications.
Abilitv to:
Continuously analyze construction site situations and develop solutions; analyze
plans, interpret project proposals, plans, and specifications; identify, interpret,
explain, and enforce construction violations; review and interpret construction
plans; understand and explain engineering procedures and terminology, and
perform mathematical calculations; maintain awareness of safety at all times.
Sit at a desk for long periods of time on a continuous basis; write or use a
keyboard to communicate through written means; occasionally walk through and
inspect construction sites, perform simple grasping, pushing and pulling, fine
manipulation, and lift or carry weight of 50 pounds or less.
Conduct detailed and accurate inspections of sewer system construction projects.
Communicate clearly and concisely, both orally and in writing.
Read and interpret engineering and construction plans, blueprints, and drawings.
Perform a variety of contract monitoring and administration functions, as assigned.
Interpret construction drawings and specifications.
Perform engineering calculations with speed and accuracy.
Perform technical research on engineering and construction problems.
Keep accurate field observations and records.
Learn and observe all appropriate safety precautions as required by the District
including, but not limited to, Cal/OSHA General Industry Safety Orders, the
District's Respiratory Protection Program, and District Safety Directives.
CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA SANITARY DISTRICT
Construction Inspector/Designer (Continued)
Soecial Physical Reauirements:
May be required to enter confined space and/or respond in an emergency. Must
be able to wear S.C.B.A. and perform confined space entry and emergency
response duties in protective clothing and equipment including S.C.B.A. weighing
32 pounds.
EXPERIENCE AND EDUCATION
Any combination equivalent to experience and education that could likely provide
the required knowledge and abilities would be qualifying. A typical way to obtain
the knowledge and abilities would be:
Exoerience:
Two years of experience in design and/or construction of sewage treatment,
industrial, or public works facilities of comparable complexity.
Education:
Equivalent to completion of two years of college.
LICENSES AND CERTIFICATES
Possession of a valid California Driver's License.
TRAINING PROGRAM
CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR/DESIGNER
COURSE
SUBJECT LOCATION DURATION
Mathematics
. Algebra (Math 110 or 120 @ DVC DVC Semester
LMC
CSUH
or
Mathematics for Technicians DVC Semester
(Math 111 @ DVC)
. Plane Trigonometry DVC Semester
(Math 121 @ DVC) LMC
CSUH
ComDuter
. Windows Contra Costa Y2 day
Training Center
. Spreadsheets Contra Costa Y2 day
Training Center
Enaineerina and Desian
. Microstation Design Software Martinez 10 weeks
Adult School
. Eagle Point Design Software In-House 4 days
. Plane Surveying DVC Semester
(Engineering 140 @ DVC)
. Specification Writing Construction 3 days
Specifications
Institute
. Hydraulics In-House 2 days
Riaht of Way
. Principles of Right of Way International 1 week
(Engineering and Legal Topics) Right of Way
Association
H:\DESIG N\SW ANSON\CONSTINS.TRG
2113/97
~.
Central Contra Costa Sanitary Disbict
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
.:::1:111..1:.:..:1.11:::.::1.::.1. BOARD MEE1lF:b~ary 20, 1997
.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.:-;.:.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.:.;.;.;.;.;.:.;.;.;.;.;.;.;.:.;.;.
Page 1 of 4
NO.
10. HUMAN RESOURCES b.
DATE
February 14, 1997
TYPE OF ACllON
Personnel
SUBJECT
DIRECT STAFF TO SECURE SERVICES OF STATE MEDIATION AND CONCILIATION SERVICE TO HOLD A
SECRET BALLOT ELECTION TO DETERMINE IF THE GENERAL EMPLOYEES WISH TO DECERTIFY PUBLIC
EMPLOYEES' UNION, LOCAL NO. 1
SUBMITTED BY
Paul Morsen
INITIATING DEPTIDIV
Administrative
ISSUE: In accordance with the District Code, Chapter 4.24.060.B, when a petition for decertification of a
recognized employee organization is received and found to be valid, Board action is required to request the
State Mediation and Conciliation SeNice to hold a secret ballot election in accordance with the Meyers-Millias-
Brown Act.
BACKGROUND: In 1982, the District recognized Public Employees' Union, Local 1, as the certified employee
organization representing the General employee group. The Meyers-Millias-Brown Act, which governs public
sector labor relations, requires a process for employees to form bargaining units, modify those units, designate
representation for collective bargaining purposes (certification), and change representation (decertification). The
Act also provides that governmental agencies, such as the District, may adopt reasonable rules and regulations
governing these processes. The District's requirements governing decertifications are reflected in Chapter
4.24.060 (Attachment A).
On January 30, 1997, the Stationary Engineers Union, Local 39, submitted a petition signed by over 35
percent of the General employees group, represented by Local 1, which requested that the District hold an
election to decertify Public Employees' Union, Local 1 as the recognized bargaining representative for that
group. Local 39 also submitted "interest cards" signed by employees for the purported purpose of designating
Local 39 as their representative in order to place Local 39 on the ballot along with Local 1. The District Code
requires that thirty-five percent of the employees represented by Local 1 sign the petition for decertification.
The Code also requires that thirty-five percent of the employees must designate Local 39 as their representative
in order for Local 39 to be on the election ballot. There were sufficient signatures on the petition to require
a decertification election. However, Local 39 did not submit interest cards from at least thirty-five percent of
these employees, which expressly stated that Local 39 was designated as their representative. Consequently,
it is requested that the Board direct staff to request the seNices of the State Mediation and Conciliation SeNice
to hold an election; the ballot will ask employees to vote on whether to retain Local 1 as their official
representative or to vote "no union."
Local 39 has indicated that it is considering legal action against the District on the grounds that the District is
narrowly construing the terms of its Code, and thus, improperly denying to its employees an opportunity to
choose Local 39 as their bargaining representation. Although the District agrees that employees should have
a full and fair opportunity to freely choose their bargaining representative, the procedures set forth in the Code
H:\PP\DECERTIF.PP
9/16/96
. ... " . . .
.....................................................................................................
.iii:i.iiiii:i:iii::r:.:..:.::r::::::\/::(\:::::rr:::::::::::::::::::\:::::::::::::::i:.ii:il:r:~.:.::::::t:::r:t:::f::r::::::::::.:::::iil....i.::IIII.:I.ii
DATE
February 14, 1997
Page 2 of 4
SUBJ ECT
DIRECT STAFF TO SECURE SERVICES OF STATE MEDIATION AND CONCILIATION SERVICE TO HOLD A
SECRET BALLOT ELECTION TO DETERMINE IF THE GENERAL EMPLOYEES WISH TO DECERTIFY PUBLIC
EMPLOYEES' UNION, LOCAL NO.1
do provide a process by which this can be accomplished. Chapter 4.24.0408(6) provides as follows:
Statement that the employee organization has in its possession written proof, dated within thirty
calendar days of the date upon which the petition is filed, to establish that thirty-five percent of
the eligible employees within the representation unit have designated the employees organization
to represent them in their employment relations with the District. Such written proof shall be
submitted for confirmation to the Deputy General Manager.
After consultation with District labor counsel Dan Clinton, it is staff's opinion that the requirements of Chapter
4.20.040B(6) have not been met and that Local 39 is not entitled to be placed on the ballot as part of the
decertification process. In order to meet these requirements, Local 39 needed to submit at least 57 interest
cards from employees which "designated" Local 39 as their bargaining representative. Although 58 interest
cards were submitted, six of these cards were altered in some fashion to indicate that the signer was DQ!
designating Local 39 to be the bargaining representative, but rather that the signer was in some way
interested in having Local 39 participate in an election.
Local 39 does not dispute this fact, but rather daims that the District's interpretation of this provision is "hyper
technical." On the other hand, Local 1 has advised the District that it believes that the District is obligated to
follow the specific requirements of the Code and that those requirements have not been met by Local 39.
Consequently, based on the criteria established in Chapter Four, staff is requesting the Board to direct staff
to secure the services of the State Mediation and Conciliation Service to hold a secret ballot election to
determine the appropriate employee organization representation. The majority representative shall be
decertified if the results of the election indicate that employees of the unit no longer desire representation by
that organization, as indicated by the vote for "no organization."
In the event of a ''tie'' vote, the incumbent certified employee organization shall not be decertified. The results
of the election become binding and final.
RECOMMENDATION: Direct staff to secure the services of the State Mediation and Conciliation Service to
hold a secret ballot election to determine if a majority of the employees in the General employees' bargaining
unit wish to decertify Local 1 as their bargaining representative.
4.24.040
.(
2. The following classifications are designated
executive management:
General Manager-Chief Engineer
Counsel of the District
Secretary of the District
3. The management group employees shall represent
themselves in matters of wages, benefits and working con-
ditions with the Board of Directors and shall not be includ-
ed in the same representation unit with nonmanagement em-
ployees or management support/confidential employees. Clas-
sifications within the unit are adopted by resolution of the
Board of Directors.
4. The management support/confidential representa-
tion unit is recognized as the bargaining unit for all man-
agement support and confidential employees and management
support and confidential employees shall not be included in
the same representation unit with nonmanagement or nonconfi-
dential employees. Classifications within this unit are
adopted by resolution by the Board of Directors.
5. Professional employees shall be included in a
representation unit with nonprofessional employees unless,
in a vote of all affected professional employees, a majority
of such professional employees voting in a secret ballot
election vote not to be included in such a unit. Certifica-
tion of employee organizations representing a unit composed
of professional employees shall follow the provisions of
Section 4.24.040.
6. The Central Contra Costa Sanitary District Em-
ployees' Association Public Employees' Local Number One is
recognized as the bargaining unit for all general employees
other than those assigned to other representation units.
B. The Deputy General Manager, using the criteria set
forth in this chapter, shall make the initial determination
of all questions that may arise as to whether classifica-
tions or employees included in a representation unit are in
fact management, professional, management support/confiden-
tial employees, or general employees. Any action of the
Deputy General Manager in determining issues contained in
this section which are not satisfactory to the employee or-
ganization(s) shall be resolved in the meet and confer pro-
cess and where that process fails, through the State Con-
ciliation Service as described in Section 3507.1 of the
Meyers-Milias-Brown Act. (Ord. 168 Sl(Exh. A(part)), 1989:
Ord. 150 (part), 1982: prior code S4-704)
4.24.040 Certification of employee organization. A.
An employee organization may be certified as the exclusive
representative of a representation unit for the purposes
stated in this chapter.
(
40
(Contra Costa 8/89)
4.24.040
.(
{
\
B. Any employee organization that meets the following
m1n1mum requirements may petition, in writing, during the
month of October during the final year of a memorandum of
understanding, to represent the employees in a representa-
tion unit .as established in Section 4.24.030 or Section
4.24.050. These requirements are to be filed with the Depu-
ty General Manager in a statement of representation, signed
by the presiding officer of the employee organization, and
shall state, certify and/or include the following:
1. The name and address of the organization and the
names, titles and addresses of its current officers; and
2. That employee organization is or is not a chap-
ter or local of, or affiliated directly with, a regional or
state or national or international organization and, if so,
the name and address of each such regional, state or inter-
national organization; and
3. A copy of the employee organization's adopted
constitution and/or bylaws; and
4. The organization has membership among District
employees; and
5. The organization has no restriction on member-
ship based on race, color, creed, national origin, sex, age
or eligible employment in any classification contained with-
in the representation unit; and
6. A statement that the employee organization has
in its possession written proof, dated within thirty calen-
dar days of the date upon which the petition is filed, to
establish that thirty-five percent of the eligible employees
within the representation unit have designated the employee
organization to represent them in their employment relations
with the District. Such written proof shall be submitted
for confirmation to the Deputy General Manager.
C. The Board of Directors shall require holding a se-
cret ballot election by the State Conciliation Service, or
as mutually agreed upon by the District and all employee
organizations concerned. This secret ballot election must
be held no sooner than twenty calendar days after the final
determination of the appropriate representation unit or
units, and not more than forty calendar days after such de-
termination. The District and the employee organizations
concerned shall meet and confer on the procedures for con-
ducting an election by eligible employees. Such employee
elections shall be held within an established representation
unit to determine majority wishes regarding the choice of an
employee organization, o~ resolve conflicting claims, upon
petition by thirty-five percent or more of the eligible em-
ployees in an established representation unit. In any.rep-
resentation election, the choice of no organization shall be
on the ballot unless there is a runoff election.
1. In an election where none of the choices re-
ceives a majority of the valid ballots cast, a runoff
(
41
(Contra Costa 8/89)
.24.050--4.24.060
Attachment A
.(
election shall be conducted between the two choices receiv-
ing the largest number of ballots cast.
2. There shall be no more than one certification
election in a twelve-month period within the same represen-
tation unit, except as provided above for runoff elections.
3. An employee organization receiving a majority of
the valid votes cast in a representation election and has
otherwise all the minimum qualifications as stated in para-
graphs 1 through 6 of subsection B of this section, shall be
certified by the Board of Directors as the certified employ-
ee organization for the established representation unit.
D. A decision of the Board of Directors dismissing a
claim for certification by an employee organization shall be
valid and effective for a period of one year. (Ord. 168
Sl(Exh. A(part)), 1989: Ord. 150 (part), 1982: prior code
S4-705)
{
4.24.050 Modification of established representation
unit. A. A petition for modification of a representation
unit may be filed with the Deputy General Manager between
October 1st and October 31st of the final year of a memoran-
dum of understanding. A petition for modification of a rep-
resentation unit may be filed by a group of employees in a
representation unit. Such petitions must contain the signa-
tures of fifty percent or more of the employees in a pro-
posed representation unit.
B. Such petition shall be based only upon substantial
changes in District functions, organizational structure or
job classifications.
C. Such petition shall describe the proposed modified
representation unit based upon the classes within the clas-
sification plan of the District and shall set forth the rea-
sons for the proposed modification.
D. The Deputy General Manager, using the criteria set
forth in this chapter, shall determine if the representation
unit should be modified. Any action of the Deputy General
Manager in determining if a representation unit should be
modified may be contested by the employee organization(s)
involved and may be subject to the meet and confer process
and where that process fails, through State Conciliation
Service per Section 3507.1 of the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act.
(Ord. 168 Sl(Exh. A(part)), 1989: Ord. 150 (part), 1982:
prior code S4-706)
(
4.24.060 Decertification of employee organization. A.
A decertification petition alleging that the incumbent cer-
tified employee organization no longer represents a majority
of the employees in an established representation unit may
be filed with the Deputy General Manager after the incumbent
organization has been recognized for at least one full year.
Such petition must be filed with the Deputy General Manager
when the term of memorandum of understanding has less than
42
(Contra Costa 8/89)
~
4.24.070
,
I
.
one hundred twenty days and more than ninety days rema~n~ng.
Such a decertification petition shall then contain the fol-
lowing information and documentation:
1. The name of the established representation unit
and of the incumbent certified employee organization sought
to be decertified as the representative of that unit;
2. An allegation that the incumbent certified em-
ployee organization no longer represents a majority of the
employees in the unit and any other relevant and material
facts relating thereto;
3. Proof of employee support that at least thir-
ty-five percent of the current employees in the unit no
longer desire to be represented by the incumbent certified
employee organization;
4. When the decertification petition also requests
certification of another organization, then that petition
shall include those requirements as set forth in Section
4.24.040B(I) through (6).
B. Upon receipt of a decertification petition, the
Deputy General Manager shall place the matter on the agenda
of the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Board of Di-
rectors. If the employee petition is found to be valid,
then the Board shall require a secret ballot election by
State Conciliation Service. The majority representative
shall be decertified if the results of a secret ballot
election show that employees of the unit no longer desire
representation by that organization, as indicated by the
vote for "no organization" or another recognized orga-
nization, as specified in the voting criteria cited in Sec-
tion 4.24.040. In the event of a tie vote, the incumbent
certified employee organization shall not be decertified.
The results of the election become binding and final.
C. A notice of decertification shall be sent by cer-
tified mail by the Deputy General Manager whenever an em-
ployee organization is voted to be decertified by a majority
of the voting employees. The notice shall be delivered to
the last knownofficer(s) of the employee organization.
D. In the event the incumbent employee organization is
decertified, the decertification shall not negate the terms
of the then existing memorandum of understanding between the
District and that organization as acceptance of the terms of
such a memorandum of understanding shall be a condition
required by the Board of Directors in granting recognition
to a new organization as the certified employee organization
for the representation unit. (Ord. 168 SI(Exh. A(part)),
1989: Ord. 150 (part), 1982: prior code S4-707)
.(
4.24.070 Individual employees. Nothing in this chap-
ter shall be construed to restrict or in any way modify the
right of an individual employee to present matters involving
(
43
(Contra Costa 8/89)
,--=,'
':'::'~'.l:~~~.~:;'~~."."'~~-f.:..=:ti:-.:~~:':';'..'..~~~..~
~
_ _.._ ... .__..u
..
I hereby d.lgQ"tP. alltl .dttro11'Lc tilt" STATIONAR\' t:NGIJIOt:t:US, 1.0<:'4." I'JIO-
IoN No. 99 OF THE INTERNATIONAl. tJNION 01<' OI>ERATING t:N(;fNI<:I<:ltS to
repre1'lent me ~fore the National Labor Rc,I:.Uom, noard or any othl'r go,",'rnml'lIt
agency and to negotiate and enter Into (',ollf'('t1ve Bllrgainln~ Agreemc'nt~ with m~'
Employer and his rcpresC'ntatlve8 and all Emplo)'ers of St~ltionary EngillCC'rs, ill :lll
dasslftcatlonS, In tht'> 46 ("Ountlf'1l of Northern California and Ncw~a a.nd any of th('lII,
and their repreMentativeH, with rcspe(.t to rates of pa)', wagC's, hours of labor :lnd
other conditions of employment, and for the l}rf'SCntation of any disputes or ~ri('\"-
ance8 that may arise ~tWf'C1I myself nnd any Employt"r. I do this In thl' ('xf'rC'isc' of
my rights under the l.abor-Managl'ment Relations Ad of J947 :lRd undf'r all :ll'lllic-ablc'
state or federal laW8.
Dated.... ...t: .~8..::.9.7 .... ...... .....
Name........
;9\
~
Sodal Se('
ION
u.tedmJ-=_~~-:.~..7._.......
~
Name..-
Sodal ~
STATIONARY ENmNEER~
:::~~~;:=~~7~~~~
aad to negotiate and enter Into Collective Bargaining Agreements with my
apae1 r and bIa repreeentatlVelI and all Entplo!'ers of Stationary Engineers, In aU
==Uou, In the ~ counttes of Northern California and Nevada and any of them,
aDd tbeIr representatives. with respect to rates of pa!', wages, hours of labor and
ot;ber eoadlUODlI of employment, and for the presentation of any disputes or grie\'-
aDce8 that may arllle between myself and any Employer. I do this in the exercl8f\ of
DIY rights under the Labor_Management Relation." Act of 1947 and under all applicablf'
state ~ fe4erallaws.
J)ated.....L=.?::.t..~.'!.I.............. Name....
~
Social S
"~~~~:~'''~~''.''.'':; "~~~;:,:~~ti~::\"~ ~.:'..:.~.v.:-.~
STATIONARY EN(aNEERS
r- h..:..d).J ~11A&.e aDU auUaonze DIe c.Jl..WIOJJ.\.Rl ~~61.f~~r.;I(~, L'''-.IAL 11H-
...IaN N&. 3I...eF rim IN'Jl:I!:RM ~'I'la:N ~l. umo~ oW>' n.."''' A -IN'.. .. T. II rRt-".v~ tv
..,-q-"" D)() b...~....~ thl )latllll&1 h.dh.. .~u"."" nuao(l-or any other government
agency and to negotiate and enter Into Collective Bargaining Agreements with my
Employer ....d his representatives and all Employers of Stationary Engineers, In all
clu8UlcaUoaa, In the 46 COURtieR of Northern California and Nevada aod any of them,
aDd tbeIr ftlpl'ellelltatlves, with respect to rates of pay, wages, hours of labor and
other eoDlUUons of employment, and for the presentation of any clI8putes or grIe\'.
ancee that may arise between myself and any Employer. I do this In the exercise of
my rtchts UDder the Labor-Management Relatlon..<i Act of 1947 and under all appllcablf'
state or federal laws.
Dated....I.:i?!B.:.f..1.............
~
.
STATIONARY ENmNEERS
.
N
s.
:r..waJ. Me L. () N" 3.!J ~ {de
b~
STATIONARY ENmNEERS
I hereby designate and authorize the STATIONARY ENGINEERS, LOcAL UN-
ION No. 39 OF THE INTERNATIONAL UNION OF TING ENGINEERS to
represent me before the National Labor ReI Board or any other go\'ernment
agency and to negotiate and enter Int ectlve Bargaining Agreements with my
Employer and his representatlv all Emplo~'ers of Stationary Engineers, In all
dasslftcatlons, In the 46 es of Northern California and Nevada aod any of them,
and their represen , with respect to rates of 'pa~', wages, hours of labor and
other coDClltlo employment, and for the presentation of any clI8putes or grlc\'-
ances tha ~. arise ~twf'en m)'self nnd any Emplo;)'er. I do this In the exerc.lSt' of
my s under the I..abor-:\fanagement Relations Act ~]947 and under all al'pllcablf'
sta or federal laws.
Dated......L/2.fJ!9.7.. N
(f' s,
+
~.
l ..;ntral Contra Costa Sanital District
.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
liiMiSimi..ijjjjj:iijij(:ii5'Eii5f:t:ijj BOARD MEETIFNeG bOFrUary 20, 1997
~~~~~lim;6:ClI~~~III_I*~~~~~~mME~~U:Fs~IIf~
:::;:::;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::~::::::::::::::::::::::::::::~::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::;:::::;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;
Page 1 of 5
NO.
14. BUDGET & FINANCE a.
February 7, 1997
TYPE OF ACTION
RECEIVE BUDGET REVIEW
DATE
SUBJECT
RECEIVE THE 1996-1997 OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE BUDGET REVIEW FOR THE SIX MONTHS
ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1996
SUBMITTED BY
Debbie Ratcliff, Controller
_ INITIATING DEPT tOlV
Administrative/Finance & Accounting
ISSUE: A report of the results of a comparative review of actual and budgeted Operations and
Maintenance (O&M) revenues and expenses for the first six months of the 1996-1997 fiscal year is provided
in this Position Paper.
BACKGROUND: A comparison of actual and budgeted District O&M revenues and expenses for the six
months ended December 31, 1996, and projected revenues and expenses for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1997 is summarized on page 2.
Based on the results of the first six months of the 1996-1997 fiscal year, projections have been made of
revenues and expenses for the full fiscal year. District revenues are projected to total $28,014,540 for the
fiscal year, which are $488,760 or 1.7 percent lower than budgeted revenues of $28,503,300. Major
variances between projected, or actual, revenues and budgeted revenues for the fiscal year and the six-
month period are presented on page 3. Variance explanations specifically address the six-month period.
District expenses are projected to be $27,371,081 for the fiscal year, which are less than budgeted
expenses of $28,339,406 by $968,325 or 3.4 percent. Variances between projected, or actual, expenses
and budgeted expenses for the fiscal year and the six month period are described by major expense
categories on page 4, and benefit expense variances and projections are detailed on page 5. Again, the
variance explanations specifically address the six-month period.
RECOMMENDA 1l0NS: Receive the 1996-1997 Operations and Maintenance Budget Review for the six
months ended December 31, 1996, and provide comments and guidance to District staff.
~/l
DR
RECOIVWfENDED FOR BOARD ACTION
INITIATING DEPARTMENTtOlVlSlON
S:\ADMIN\POSP APER\6MOO&M96.PP
9/16/96
-------_._.-._-_._-----~._------'-----------_.._._-----------..-.-.-,--
LO
t+-
o
N
OJ
0)
ItS
c..
~ C\J 0) ":" <0 ,.... (") I~ 'V 'V
,... 0 0),... M M ui eo M
a> - -- ,...
0
c: '#.
~
t:
~
!
0 000 ~o co ~C\J1()1()
& 2<0<0 ,... (")OC\Jco
C\J,.... ,....C\J (") C\l(")(")l()
a> ...... ,... cioocO g- LCj ~ r-: In cO 0)-
o c: ,.... ,...~~ co :! <0,....
c: :::I ~ C\l LCJ C\l 0) 'V
~ 0 --
t: E
~<
~
r--
~-
a>
c
~
C>
C
rg
JJ
~
>-
~
,....
0)
0)
,...
ci
(")
a>
c:
:::I
J
C>
~~
w,...
~,.:
~~
~ ~
~~
~~
~~
0) ~
,...~
c:
~,... 0
ft)~~~
~~~E~
P :::I a>
~ (J) 0
~....... a>
~5a
- 0 "0
c: 0 a>
,~ 0 "0
'N < c:
~a>W
8en en en
C:..c:
a>......
~ a. c:
te~~
c:
LQ ci$ .~
~a>(J)
~ :::I a>
s~:S
L~ > ~
r.;~~
8
c
~'*"
~
a>......
o c:
c: :::I
~ 0
C E
~<
Q)
C>
"0
::J
CD
"0
~
.~
e
0.
Q)
C>
"0
::J
CD
(ij
:::I
~
,...
(")
(")
~
~~~
lri'cOgf
~~1C)
"l:j":cO
C\J
,...
,...
,...
~
~
o
o
o
ci
o
,...
~
8~~
01010
. <0- a; "l:j
'V <0,...
""',...0
"l:j ,... rrf
C\l
CO'
a
Iii) ro 0)
e.ot::.
,...
-
W
aJ
cO
(")
C\J_
,...
-
~~aJ
ffiC\J~
aJ- r--: N
""10,...
--(")
<0
~
cO
<0
10
N
,...
8'VO
,... ,...
o co,...
~~~
~IC)<O
ri cO
,...
,....
'V
<0
<OO)C\l
('I)U)1()
('1)('1)('1)
lri' 0) <0-
..-0)('1)
1()'V(")
ri 10-
,...
.
aJ<O<O
~~~
aJ- c5 cO
<0('1),...
<0""10
lri'''l:j''l:j
0)100
C\JC\JO)
10"-10
('1)- lri' <0-
<0<0,....
'V1C)C\J
10- ri "l:j
'VO,...
cri"<f"<f
,...
,....<O~
~~1C)
"':cO,...
<OaJO)
C\JC\J
,...
-
C\l"",<o
aJaJaJ
("),...,....
.,.: r--: 0)
0)<0 'V
,....OC\J
NNN
10""<0
""'aJ'V
<O,....C\J
0) 0)- aJ-
C\l""'l()
10,....,...
C\J-,... C\J-
~ ~ ~.~
~C'!.~~
~~~~
""'(;)('1),...
~,.:~
~O..-O)
O)~~~
<0 aJ - ,.: (")-
<0 0)"'" 'V
t:';C\J('I)CO
C\l.,.:r--:
,... C\l
aJOOIC)
McOcO
l()aJ<ON
""'O('l)C\J
("),.....-<0
~~~t
C\J 0)S2
C\l0)~'V
~~<O~
0),...0)0)
""<OaJlC)
'V<O""'V
<0 "l:jN
,...
~o~~
",,""'lC)aJ
aJcO,..."l:j
""'''''<0'''''
":.: <0 C'!. 0_
<0 (,,)C\J
,...
"E en
p:' .~ 8 ~
~c= 8C: ~
~ ID a>
Q)~o~~
> ~ Cl:l1> a>,S
~~c3IBB~
en
c: en
o en c: -.,.
.- c: 0 en ~
a> 1a 0 .- a> 0
..~ 9}" Q>~~:glt:
~.g 58! 9~ g
'2 ~ ~ E 0 .5 dj ~
'E .~ ~ ~ c .~ ,S e:
);-0 c8se~::J 0:::1
<W cna.o.~CI)
-
".
0)$<0)
~~~
~- ri <0-
In <0 0
.....<0('1)
cOr--:
,....
0)
0)
,...
~-
a>
c:
I <0 :::I
\ 0) J
~o
_ en
,...<
>..
:; a>
J 0
_ c:
o ~
c2~
'''0
a> c:
o ::J
c:u.
~ a>
~ en
CD c:
"0 a>
c: a.
:::IJj
U.
en a> C>
:::I en .5
-c:c:
e- Q) c:
:::I a. :::I
(1)dja:
"0 r-n "0
~ "" a>
o .5 ts
a> c: a>
...... C'~
e :::I e
a. a: 0.
.
U"l
4-
o
M \
Q)
~
to
0..
..
o
M
W
Z
::)
..,
c:>>
z
o
z
w
a:
"'CI)<C
OZW
-0>
a:--J
......<C
~<CO
CZCl)
><C-
-JLL.
a:o.W
<CX:J:
!::W...
ZWC
<COZ
Cl)Z<C
<C~(g
...a:en
CI)<Cen
O>~
0... ..
<CZ~
a:::)M
"'Oa:
ZOW
000:1
O<C~
-JWW
<C::)~
a:ZC
...W
Z>C
WWW
Oa:O
Z
W
CI)
:J:
to-
Z
o
:i
X
-
CI)
W
:J:
to-
a:
o
LL.
"
(7)
(7)
~
..
o
M
CU
c:
:::l
...,
o
c:
:c
c:
w
,.....
en
en
~
~
CO
CU
>
CO
(,)
CI)
u:::
cu
(,)
c:
.~ (#a
~
CO
>
cu.....
(,) c:
c: :::l
CO 0
'0:: E
CO
>'<
<0
(7)
(7)
~
~
M
cu
(,)
c:
.~ (#a
~
CO
>
~
CU
..0
E
cu
(,)
cu
o
"'0
cu
"'0
c:
W
CI)
.c.
....
c:
o
~
><
(j)
cu....
(,) c:
c: :::l
,~ 0
~ E
~<
^
"
~
v
^
~
~
"
M
V
....
CU
o
"'0
.:::l
m
o
o
q
~
"
q...
N
N
"'0
CU
....
(,)
CU
'0'
~
Q.
o
o
o
o
o
~
..
N
N
CI)
~
~
CO
E
cu
a:
.. ....
oc:
c: cu
.- E
~-- cu
..2coco.c.
_.....c:.....
o CI) 0
- c: '+:i 0 ..:
.- .- c: c: CO
cu "'0 ,- CO cu
.c. > "'0 CI).c. >
.....1:co..2.....~
.s :::l c: (,) ~ 0
o CO ~ 5>'0::
cuu_~~o.
:::l....o-~o
"'0 CI) CO .....
>.: c: 0 -g
c - .9 0 CO ~
.- cu ..... 0 0
CO .c. CO .. "._
E....(,)~~....
.- ~ (,)
CI) - :t: M c: CU
._ 0 '0 <0 CU ~
cuC: c:-<I>E 0
(,) 0 - cu (,)
c: 'f ~ 0 10 ~
CO 0 .- ..... ..... 0
'0:: > c: CI) -
CO 0. ,- cu
>~cuECiSCI)
cu (,) ,- "'0
~~~cog5
..0 CO .......CO-
CO-"'OCI)C:CU
~o - cu c: .- ~
'" > .- -
> 0'- ~ ~ -g
~c:~cucu.....
c: . - CU ..0..0 CO
:::l ~ ~ E E .9-
o cu cu (,)
.~ "'0 c: (,) (,) .+:;
.c.:::l~cucuc:
""'..0....00 CO
^
ClO
(7)
V
^
(7)
q.
ClO
..
<0
M
N
..
~
V
....
CU
o
"'0
:::l
m
<0
(7)
q...
ClO
<0
LO
..
N
~
CO
:::l
.....
(,)
<
"
q.
<0
..
~
M
M
..
~
~
cu
(,)
.~
CU
ff)
~ CU
CU 0
~ Co
cu.c.
ff)U
N
o
o
o
LO
..
o
~
o
o
LO
..
LO
M
"
..
q.
o
o
0..
<0
q.
"
..;
cu
..0
o
.....
"'0
CU
.....
(,)
CU
0.
><
CU
.~
"'0
c: ~
CO CO
CU
CU >
::c-
CO CO
~ (,)
o CI)
>'t:
~ CU
c:.c.
:::l.....
>-
_ 0
....
.c."'O
oC:
= CU
CI) CU
CI).c.
.- ....
.....>
5..0
8~
(,)..0
CO ~
CI) 0
.- >
.c. CO
.....-
^
LO
V
^
q.
<0
<0
..
ClO
.~
V
o
o
o
..
q.
M
LO
..
M
<0
M
M
..
LO
~
LO
..
M
"'E cu
o 0
(,) ~
c: CO
o.c.
UU
- cu
o .~
~~
.- cu
Uff)
I^
o
"
~
V
^
o
<0
<0
..
~
~
V
o
o
<0
..
ClO
<0
o
q.
(7)
..
<0
LO
o
c:
'is.
E
:::l cu
,"'0 10
CI) ~
CI)"'O
~ cu
0....
....~
cu"'O
:::l :::l
"'0..0
>c:
C CO
._ .c.
co....
E CD
.~ CO
cu E
(,) CI)
~ CO
. 0:: "'0
CO c:
> CO
~"'O
..0 cu
~10
o 0.
> '0
CO .-
-.....cu
c: c: CI)
:::l CO CO
CI) c: cu
.- CO ~
.c..c.(,)
..... .... .S
^
o
"
~
V
^
ClO
N
ClO
..
LO
V
<0
(7)
N
..
q.
M
ClO
<0
q...
ClO
N
~
c:
CO 0
..... c:
(,) .-
._ 0.
..... E
o.:::l
~o
I^
ClO
..t
~
V
^
o
o
o
q."
N
V
o
o
o
N
<0
~
o
o
o
..
ClO
M
~
"'0
cu CI)
.... c:
~o
.- 0.
,~ CO
..... cu
~~
c:-
CO CO
.c. >
.... CO
Cl)z
CI) .
cuff)
~::i
.... cu
cu.c.
:::l.....
"'0"'0
CI) c:
.- CO
cu CI)
(,) ..
c: ~
.~ CO
Co~
> .
.....
CUff)
::C.c.
co....
~ 0
0..0
>
CO ~
- 0
c: - c:
:::l CI) 0
CI) :> .+:;
.- :> CO
.c.o....
.....;;;::ff)
^
"
..t
~
V
^
N
"
ClO
..
.-
~
v
o
o
o
..
~
ClO
ClO
N
~
..
(7)
<0
cu
(,)
.~
cu CI)
ff)cu
~ 0
cu ~
.c. CO
......c.
au
o
o
o
o
o
q...
~
~
~
o
o
q.
..
~
~
~
.
c:
o
c:
~B
o
"'0"'0
:::l cu
..0 Co
coo.
o E
..... 0
cu (,)
:::l CI)
"'0 CO..:
>CI)CO
c.c.cu
co 1: >
E 0 cu
Cl)E-5
.- cu
cu>.....
(,) _ :::l
~~,g
.- .t:i 0
~ :::l
co ~ 0
> cu ~
..., > .s:::.
-0.....
::C"'OCI)
co ..., 0
~ - c:
o "'0 ._
> ,--
co>=
_:c..o
c: > cu
:::l _ c:
CI) c: '+:i
.- cu :::l
~~e
^
ClO
ClO
N
V
^
N
M
o
<0
~
v
ClO
(7)
<0
..
LO
LO
<0
<0
<0
..
(7)
M
:t:
E
~
cu
a..
co
-.:,: .
....
CI)
:::l ~
"'Ocu
.ELL
<0
.
ClO
N
M
o
o
M
..
LO
N
o
o
"
..
"
o
o
o
..
M
M
o
c:
'+:i
cu
o
"'0
:::l
..0
~
cu
"'0
c:
:::l
o
....
cu
:::l
"'0
>
C
'co
E
CI)
cu
(,)
c:
co
'0::
co
> ...;
cu c:
::c :::l
co 0
~ (,)
o (,)
> co
~ CI)
Cl)1:
,- .....
.c. c:
..... .-
"
(7)
N
M
N
ClO
<0
..
N
.-
<0
q.
ClO
..
M
ClO
N
LO
..
<0
~
:t:
E
~
cu
a..
~
....
CI)
:::l
"'0
c:
M
(7)
LO
~
o
o
<0
..
ClO
o
o
q...
LO
o
o
o
..;
~
"'0
cu
.....
co
0.
'0
'+:i
c:
co
c:
co
.c. CI)
..... c:
~ .9
o CI)
E :~
0"'0
.......0
cu :::l
:::l CI)
"'OCU
CI) e'
.- co
cu-
(,) 0
.ffi !
Co E
> 0
cu'::
::CCl)
co c:
~ 0
o ._
> ....
co co
- ><
CI) cu
1: c:
.....~
q.
q.
ClO
~
o
ClO
(7)
..
q.
o
o
"
..
N
o
ClO
<0
"
~ ~
cu cu
ZLL
^
N
LO
V
^
o
o
LO
~
N
V
o
o
LO
..
<0
~
q.
o
o
q
LO
(7)
M
....
CI)
cu
~
cu
.....
,S
"'0
cu
.....
co
E ..:
'+:i co
cu
~ >
~ cu
CU.c.
-g.....
:::l'O
B CI)
cu-5
:::l c:
"'0 0
CI) E
cu .~
(,) CI)
c:.....
.~ CI)
(ij~
> cu
~-5
..0 ~
~ 0
0-
> cu
co :::l
- c:
CI) cu
1: >
..... ~
~
N
N
"
LO
<0
..
"
N
o
o
o
..
LO
N
~
"
LO
<0
..
N
LO
~
CI)
cu
C)
~
co
.c.
U
c:
o
.+:;
co
><
cu
c:
c:
<
^
LO
<0
<0
V
^
~
..n
o
~
v
o
o
o
..
ClO
LO
~
o
o
q
M
LO
..
E .. >
.c. ~
co (,) co
~ ~ :::l
ococ:
e~~
o.c:c:
c: .-
,- c: "'0
>'0, cu
COcu....
Ci3..o~
"'Oot:
CO"" 0
o "'0 (,)
..... cu ~
cu:; e
:::l "'0 ~
"'Ocucu
CI) i3 0
.- CI) .S
cuCl)"'O
(,).- 0
c: (,)
.~ E co
~ co
co ~ CI)
> C).-
cue"'"
_ 0.0
.gcuN
~.c.-<I>
o ..... cu
> .c.
~ ......
c: 0.
:::l:::l ' .
.""
.~ i (7) (7)
.c......(7)(7)
.....CI)~~
^
"
(7)
(7)
v
^
N
(7)
"
..
ClO
"
V
<0
(7)
(7)
..
ClO
"
q.
o
N
cu
E
o
(,)
c:
-
E
co
~
C)
o
~
a..
.....
CI)
cu
~
cu
....
c:
-
~
cu
.....
co
~
E
~
o
.....
ff)
'^
"
~
v
^
g
"
ex)
ClO
"'"
V
o
o
~
..
<0
M
~
..
ClO
N
o
"'"
M
..
"
q.
<0
..
"
N
o
o
o
o
o
N
..
"
<0
M
A
o
ClO
V
A
ClO
~
"
N
N
M
.-
V
N
M
q
q.
ClO
q.
..
<0
~
q.
~
M
..
~
<0
~
..
LO
.-
CO
....
o
....
I
..0
:::l
ff)
All
"
~
v
A
o
<0
"
..
ClO
ClO
"'"
V
o
o
M
..
M
o
LO
..
ClO
N
o
o
N
..
"
<0
M
o
"'"
LO
..
q.
~
o
..
ClO
N
o
<0
A
0')
"
V
o
<0
0')
..
0')
A
ClO
LO
"
N
.-
M
.-
ClO
"
o
LO
<0
.-
o
.-
.-
..
(7)
.q-
<0
..
<0
~
ClO
M
o
..
LO
"
~
N
LO
M
..
<0
M
M
..
LO
.-
CI)
....
c:
:::l
o
(,)
(,)
<
~
cu
.c.
....
a
<
-
v
CI)
cu
:::l
c:
cu
>
cu
a:
~
co
>
<0
0')
~
~
o
o
E
<0
-
a..
CI)
o
a..
-
c:
E
"'0
<
-
en
-
en
o
<
CO
....
o
.....
LO
4-
o
oo::t
Q)
C'l
to
0..
....
en
en
..-
>~
eeW
Oz
0:)
W..,
~O
(.)!:
wO
""Z
zW
wee
~~~
(.) >
->..J
eeCD<
~",,(.)
~w""
0",,-
>Zu..
eewW
i:c!~~
-wo
~:eZ
",,~<
<OeD
~o~
""w..-
o ~ ..
(.)w..-
<(o~
eeOw
~:)CD
ZCD:e
Oow
(.)Z(.)
..J<w
~..JO
...<0
Z:)w
w...o
(.)~ffi
u..""
Ox
>...
eez
<0
:E:E
:Ex
~c;;
w
x
~
ee
o
u..
to-
8 ~
~~
~
8c~
i 5 :..I
~ci
~
r.
~
Ol
C
~
~-
tiS
.gl'-
;,~
m~
C
r2
~
"2 ~.
i~
e ~
Q..
0-
CIS
~
~
~
~
10....
w.o
C\I
~~
~~
~
~~
ri"':
~-~
co
~re
....co
0>0
~::
cO::,.
0';::'
d~
0;-
t::.
5" co
ci. d
"
ai
....
C\i
"
d
....
co
C\i
ON
....
10
g
-
~
co
~
F:" .;I'
~ ',,0
!!i as
~
,...
C\l
co.
....
m
10
~
o
,...
....
.0
C\I
.;I'
,...
,...
,..:
.;I'
....
10
c
~~
~~
co
'!J
C\I
~
N
~
C\l
.0
co
".
....
10
10
C\I.
....
~
~
m.
....
,...
C\I
.;I'
~
~
('I)
....
.;I'
..(
10
m
~
t
....
88
~~
m
~
co
ri
~-
~
co
~
~
,..:
"
C\I
~
C\I
?J
m
,...
10
10.
....
10
co
....
!;t
N
,...
C\I
N
....
~
w
"
('I).
....
l/I
"0 i ~o c .!!!_3l
C iOlti l~ ...CIS~~ "0 ~60' Ol ~c ~JSC~"O
~~ c:- OlI-~~ 8-;; 8.~~'jij i (ij~D:o~o~~ t)oo, ~~8.~~.
OB CIS C 0 ~ -0-0. ~...o_~~"O~ Oc ~o-)(o--~
~C\S 1 ~~~~~~- io~! r -~~~I~~ ~Wi E"2~~~~
~> ~ Ol~~(ij~8"O iOloo. 3 ~ ~~_l/Ic ~cClS (ij_oo=c
~~ ~ 50w=e-ci c~OE CIS -1>~(ijC:-~ ~iOl c[(ij~~-
c... O[ ~~D:8.~~~ ~~]5.o~ .~j!~~g~~ ~~~ ~;g~~o!
II j !~g~~~~ ~~g~l~ ~~51~&~ 8.ci ;,il~~l/I
~: '1_ !"O~8-E8.S :QOl~~~o CIS~~8E!~g~iOl ~i!IJ;
0:;:; "'OlOlC_ > ~l/I~ ~c C;:: E...3l,--Olu _.c...o
S~ o;,~~o~~ 0;' ~u~ CIS' oEic;o~~ 0~"O~~~
~i~ J ;t~~ll! 110.o-11'~~I:;~~igll~ l~iit~
i Ol Ol ~o Ol _... ...c _~"O......- $~"O-oOl - Ol-~ O_Ol
l/I~ 0 "Oo>~~~~ c~Ol~CIS!:Q~"08cco-0..~Ol~~0 ~~o-08.Q..-
~Ol "0 ;'Ol~I-~'" ClSc~"'O ~Olc ~~-"O_c "OC C
~ '0 Q) ;, ~ -E Ol .:= ~ Q) ~ 8 :: ~ Q) 0 VI C, CIS ~ Ol .~ ! ~ Ol (ij .Q Ol 0 ~ .!!! g. .Q
~~B~ ~ =2-E~~~& 2Ol~~~~52~ll~~;g-E~g -E~g8~~
~2~~ ~ ~~E"".!!!-E_ ~5g-Ec2~~Q)2~~ClSiS2g~ 2~~~~g
OlOl"O- ... (ij"Or~ClSo-CIS "O~ClSo-OOlCIS"O"'Ol~OlC~l/IOl~O- Ol"OOl~O~
~~Q)o ~ Z~~~~!~ ~~~~~~i~;~~~~~~~~! ~~~~~c.
~~3l E a~"OcOl!o ;a&c~O~_;ac~c~-;;Q)o~Ol'" ~~ClSOl)(~;a
~~;, ~ClSOl_~ ~ E"O~~~~OECIS=ClS3ll/ln"'~5"O ~cEI-~~Ol~
ClSo."O 2 E~0.02Ol _;'E~oClS-_~~5 OlCJ)"OCIS_c CIS~o- o~
E 41 Ol';::"'~o_ - O-.t) -ECIS~o'" 0-- OlEo_CIS EOO ."O"'Ol
c~"O~~ ~0.2 OlOlo o.~"O~Ol_~o. E~~6W~_C~~--T;aC~~
o."O~c"O 2~Q)i~~3l ~gil~a~~I~~3l~~~a~c~a~E~CIS~c
!!!~~~~ "08~l/I~~;' o8~VlO"O~~82~!l/ICZ~~~~i~"OC(ijj5~
Ol Ol~Ol ~ o"'Ol"O~c Ol~OlOl C ...t1l '~oOl~~~Olooo't; Ol
o~Olco ~~g_.soOlliSClSo_"O~t:0"OCIS~8 -~~Q)oo ClSOloo~cl/ld)~>
~_og_5~oi_ ~~~"OQ)~rl/lic:~=e~i~i~C~O~CQi~iOl~~Ol~~~~
. ~_~)(' e>CIS~Q)"O_~;'>OlO_Ol_~>~ClSCIS;'~-C-~_C-ClSOOlo- ~
_~~ _0 C-O-O--O- l/Io.-"Oo-~ Ol~-l/I_--o-~~-;ao-c~Q..~-
~ccOl~ ~~~o~"O~~~;,n~~~~o-~~~~-E~~_o~>"'~::~~~
~i:~~ ~~~OlEOlI~~ClSQ)~~Ol~~~Ol"'Olol-~VlOl~O:QOligo~ ~
~ o_...-~ c ~~~;?;:o .~ ~ i~ 8~:O ~ ~~:o ~.~ ~~:O~Q.. 0:0 CIS 0"0 i:
CIS~5IOCIS ;,OOll/IClSClSc"O>o-o.c_ClSC>l/ICIS~~ CIS-ClS..."O"OClSC"'C~CISCIS
~c:-~~~ ooo~"tJl/I~~0~CIS"OECIS~E~ClSCIS-~c~l/In;'~~cOl5~~Ol...~'~
>~~~>~ _o_-"O>~CIS-CO~ >~-c O-"OOll/I>~CIS~>"'EOlC
~!a~~~~~Sl1OlS~~~ClSo~&S~~O~OEc~;a~S!o~Sgn-EOlE~i
VI;'Olll/I~l/I_C\l--El/I~~VI~~-_l/IOll/I~- CIS ...~l/I...EOl/l"O~= ~~
~-E __-_oo_-o-...-~~-~-~-O-ClS~C~~-o-o-Vl-O-...~~~
~g~ ~~~~maE~&~~8.2~~~~~~~c,~253l~S$:Q~ai~8.E~
Ol ,...
o N
~~
~
Olc~
g ;, P>.
CIS 0 ~
~ E ~
;>C
Ii
m-sj
~
(ij ~~
~!
.:
;.,
Q)
E
Ol
~
~Il
~ ~ l/I
I~ 8 &
~ ~~
~ t1~
~^ 3l ~
~J ~ ~
100
aj"';
....
~~
coCO
~~
C\I
~~
coco
'4~
C\I_
('I)
C\lF:"
~~
~N
en!
C\I
~
Ol
!
J!l C
~ 'e
c"O
OlC
m"O
Ol Ol
I~ ~
l.g ~
E 0.
w(3
.;1';:-
"';C\i
....-
i1f
-
:::.
CD
!!i.
....
C\l
o
aj
....
C":!
o
~
a>
M
....
-
C\l
....0;-
co,...
....('1)
NO
:::.
F:"
10
....
..(
o
C
it)
10
co
~
C\I
~
~
('I)
'<i
co
~
m
~
C\I
C\I
o
g
m
,...
a>
g
....
.
-
m
CO.;l'
a> co
ma>
as"':
....~
a>
co
10
~
co
,...
,...
m
....
~
10
as
....
....
('I)
a>
m
.0
('I)
,...
m
,...
.;I'
,..:
~
,...
10
,...
ri
~
....
co
('I)
as
o
m
~~
co ('I)
waS
....f5
o
-
co
.0
a>
a>
co
....
10
N
....
o.
....
~
"
0>
10
....
('I)
~
.0
C\I
....
,...
('I)
o
0>
,...
10
10
,...
....
10
,...
C\I
~
~
~
18
~
o/S
l/I
Ol
Ol l/I
LJ.-
0_ CIS
o .~
t) E
Ol Ol
.!: s:
00
l/I
.!!!
~
0.
;,
CJ)
o/S
l/I
(ij
'C
!
~
1
o
n
l/I
is
o/S
01
.S
3
CIS
:I:
l/I
VI Ol
o/S 8 o~
- .- c:
CIS c: Ol
COlCIJ
.Q CJ) Ol
l/I-"O
~ ~ .-
~4lJ!l
0- -I ;,
a.. 0
Ol
o
C
o/S ~
~~
.- C
CIS .-
0. CIS
~~
0-
Ol
~
o
;(
l/I
Ol
;g
S
-
.;I'
M
10
C\I
('I)
as
~
~
0>
~
re
....
co
o
....
,...
('I)
,..:
C\I
10
cO
~
co
C\l
a>
~
co
0>
co
....
..{
....
o
....
10
....
co
C\I
ri
....
...
o
~ ~
.- l/I
o C
~!
LO
4-
o
LO
QJ
C'l
ltl
Q..
.....
Q)
Q)
.,..
o
C")
w
Z
~
..,
CJ
Z
-
C
Z
w
a:
~
>
..J
....enct
OZO
-Oen
a:-_
........u.
enctW
CZ::I:
>:3....
a:Q.C
ct><Z
....Wct
ZWU)
ctenQ)
enZQ)
W.,..
:!~.,..
enu,JC")
Oena:
O....W
~_CD
u.:i
I-~W
ZWO
OCD~
OWc
..JWw
~~C
I-..JZ
zQ.W
w:ien
OW::I:
I-
Z
o
:i
~
en
W
::I:
....
a:
o
u.
8
;~
I::
~
t'--ON(\I
oogN
IN 10 N
I g Lri ::t.
CDO
~o
.....
N
.,....
~
.,....
p,OtOCD
ro ~~
8e: .....~
; 5
I:: E '{
~c(
I~~~
~ .....0.,....0
C')!!l.
~O
N
o
.,....
CD
N
~
to
.,....
C')
aJ
.,....
~
;;
~
Q)
I::
~
~~~~
~~cDS~
-g .,.... to_
CD .,....
o
.,....
CD
cD
.,....
C')
M
to
.,....
C')
aJ
0>
0>
~~~
y-r--:.,,:
0> CD (\I
C') .,....
~~
.0.0
~
I::
5
D
...
III
~
B
III
u::
~ ~~.~o~o
4l:"CDIOC')
r,r--. 0.....
~ .,.........
.:;. ~
e
Q.
~
..t
0>
to
N
@
ci
to
0>
~~~
~gg
C') .,....
~~
C')o .0
~
E C
,g ~
..: .~~ 9! '';-5. Ill~
III ~Q)~ C 6'" ~cE ... ~
~ ~E ca:8 III 1~~8 al&.s::.e:
~ -~~ C~ -g~ -10 _~IIl::J
'Y III 0 ,~Q. ~~... ~...... Q)~'A8
~~~jca - ~~1ll1 ~ ~~~
~El;:::E'" :Q5 ~E~ l;:::_C j~~~
Q)'iijQ)'iii~ ~u -lIl- Q)~~ c~lllQ)
~~=~~ .~ =~1~ =l;:::~ 1ll0;.s::.
~ ~~ Q)Q) o~~Q. ~ ~E-~
O~041 oC c-oE ~~.o ~'Ill
:!Q)=~~ ~Ul ~~_Q) ...~::J ~~::J~
Q) Q)Q.C ~Ill ::J>~o 1~~1Il IllIllSE
!a ~_Ill .o~ ~Q)~'" I~YQ) Q)41-
~~~~t) CIIl ~~_Q) ~~Ul ....s::.,o
::J~::JC:z III -~::J ::J::J1ll u...-c
~C.olll .s::.~ OC~ .o.oQ) ~O~1Il
Is:~;1 i~ i~~~ ~II I~ro~,;
~ c: III C = Q) 1U Q. )( _ III .!l C C Cl) - s:! "~ C
E~=....!l...I ......t) Q)1ll"'1Il Q)::J~ ~n~.s::.Q)
~~Q)~!c~Q)o ...~s~ J~~ ~o~~~
~~3~~~S~-g _~;~~~3~~ -~~=~
~_ .s::.~l1l_.o c~06~... 1ll::J-CIll
Q)o 0Q)~0'" 0;8-ca~410Q) olllEou
Q)...Q)...,oIll...::J ... )(u~Q)Q)::J ...~~E~
~Q)'OQ)_~Q)O Q)sQ)~~.o.o~ Q)Q)"')(-
O::JO::JIllC::J- ::J --"'0 III ::J_...__
~~_~~Q)~~ ~iuQ)c",s- ~=Olll~
_1Il~IIlC~IIl~ 1Il...~.s::.0-~Q) .1Il_.1Il_:~1
'~-41-~~-~ -1ll~"'U~41U ~~~
~808Q)Q.8i 8Q.OOEO!; Q)Q)Cl;:::~
~c.c~~c> cEo_~::J~ ~ ggEQ)~~
= III '= III ~ 41 Ill'- III - III E -= III III III ... = ~
~i~iQ)~i~ i~~~~I~~: ii~og
1Il>1Il>=~>'" >0 f!1ll1ll1ll- >>--
- Q) .- Q)'" Q) ... Q) '1:: ~ .- E .- .- ~ ~ Q) Q) ~ Q) Q)
~_..._0::J_0 -Q).s::.- .......YQ)-- 0.0
c.oc.o-.o.oc .oQ.e:Q)~CCO~.o.oIllCO
::J ~ ::J III III C ~ Q) III 0 = ~ ::J ::J > ~ III III III Q) ...
OoOoQ)IllO'" .o.s::.E Q:OOIll::JOO.!lQ.~
~~~~~=~~~~c: ~c~~~.o~~c:~.
1ll_1ll_~..._ ~_OE~.s::.~IllIll::JQ)--::J>~
III III III III Q.Q) III III III -~UIllIllIll.s::.IIlIllO>
~~~~~J~IJ~~li~~~~i~~~~~
8 NC')IO(\I .,.... 0> OO~~.,....
~~~~NN ~ ~ oLri::t. ~o
~
Q)...~g~~
g 5 10-0 ~ (\I C').
w~~r=""""""~
~~c(
~
...:
M
!
E
g
~
ii
l!!
~
~
~
100><0
(\It'--C')
CD to
T-~
~g
0>(\1
(\I
to
C')
..t
C')
(\I
.,....
CD
(\I
1
~_~_~~o
~~C')~~
~
::J
CD
to
.,....
0>
aJ
0>
q-
~q-tO
.....0>0>
~IO~
g~g
(\10>
fR~
NN
.,....
(\I
CD
t'--
o
:g
CD
~CD~"'"
~~~~
-as --
1llC').,....~~
~ to
c(
g}~~
~O>C')
.o"':M
O>C')CD
.,....
~fR
10(\1
.,....N
.,....
(\I
~
0>
CD
M
~
.....
10
CD
~
c ~
0.E
~...~
1II~~
~ E ~ .s::.
g.>Ill:t:
E ~.~ ~
~E~I
oJQ)~1llS
f!;5-ca
Q) ~ u
~ Q) Q) .-
~~~~
-
C
Q)
E
~
~
C
o
~
III
-g C
~ 8-
.!! E
~8
~
Q)J5
u m
C ._ Q)
~ 0 u
~ E ~
.E Q) ::J
_~1Il
Sg.E
C C Q)
cp 0 It:
O..J..J
~
.$
l1l
III
C'
8-
E
~8
III
o-g8
g 2 ~
:~ S ~
>c(c(
CDiD
cO~
10
cO
~~
CD~
.,....~
~-
~
.....
..t
~
m~
.....to
.0"':
(\I~
C')_
.....
~
0>
M
~
cD
!g
1~
tOt:::.
CD
~
.,....
0;
~
cD
.s::.
.~
.s::.
~
~
u
...
~
C
.8
8
::J .
-gt}
... .~
s e
Q) a.
::J-
~~
.~ .~
gs
III
.1:: ~
~ 2
Q) III
- .s::.
.0 u
~ III
~~
- C
C ._
::J~
III ::J
~ ~
~ -
(\I~
~!!i
10
~
~~
CD.....
siM
M~
~
to
cD
.....
(\I
~g
O>C')
g~
CD~
C')-
'!J
CD
'4
(\I
M
~~
g~
C')C')
C')-
(\I
to
.....
csj
CD
0>
N
J!!
~
C
~
-g
.!:::!
J!l~
~ '0.
c(3
~
~~
{?
J!l
~
C
Q)
CD
~
IllS
o
t)
Z